Thursday, June 6, 2019

Tweet Scoop: Bituin Escalante Explains Why She Thinks She Might Not Make the Cut for 'Idol Philippines'

Image courtesy of Facebook: Bituin Escalante





Images courtesy of Twitter: gobituin

235 comments:

  1. Well as per reginge and vice im sure ang assign sakanila is the voice quality and star quality.
    While the two, i dunno.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree 12:42

      Kay regine, 100% she for voice.
      Kay vice, star quality.
      But two, ???
      ... They are not credible on anything. Their foundation is too weak to be considered as judge. Ni hndi nga kagandahan ang boses nila. Lalo n si guy, n autotune/ipit voice lng. S tingin nila basta may fanbase or may few hit song, ok n maging judge.

      I do understand n the mgnt are looking for popularity for the show, but its look like it was popular in a negative way. Lugi sila

      Delete
    2. The guy na minaliit mo is a PRODUCER lang naman! Billonaire kaya meron syang say! Fyi

      Delete
    3. Akala ko si Hidilyn Diaz nagsideline para me pampondo siya sa Olympic dream niya.

      Delete
    4. FYI 236, James is a producer n WLANG HIT SONG and BAGUHAN LNG NMAN. So dont put ur horses high 2:36

      Delete
    5. PRODUCER, 2:36? Really? Ano n b napasikat niya n song n nirelease nila? May song b sya n LSS ang tao at lgi pinapatugtog? And anong billionaire k dyan? Hndi nman sya kasama s mga top tax payer ng Pilipinas ah! Pti that Billionaire/millionaire/less than a million chenes came from their mgmt which they help him and his partner to be on that paycheck status, and not from his OWN COMPANY. So, please ENLIGHTEN us 2:36

      Delete
    6. Producer and billionare, 2:36? Sige bulahin nyo mga sarili nyo, sino niloloko mo? Make sure n mraming n sya hit song n narelease and kasama sya top tax payer ng bansa bago mo yan sabihin.

      Delete
    7. Lol at billionaire 不不 ,kala mo naman producer ng bigating mga kanta 不不不

      Delete
    8. Maliit nman sya to begin with but making him impossibly big is to absurd 2:36.

      Producer? What hit song and how may hit song did he release under his label/company?

      Billionaire? Why he is not included to our country's top tax payer? Ano yun tinalo p nga si Kris A., Vice, Mr. Sy (ng SM)?

      Ur delusions are way out of control, 2:36

      Ps: he is really not that tall in personal. Mas matangkad p ako despite his portfolio says that we have the same height

      Delete
    9. 2:36 James is a billionaire?!? I have to laugh. Vice nga millionaire lang claim sa sarili niya. Chosera ‘to haha

      Delete
    10. 2:36 billionaire whut? Kris aquino levels na ba yang idol mo para tawagin mong billionaire. Delulu ka na naman. So what kung producer siya? May grammy award or kahit billboard hit man lang siya? Ano na ba kanta na naproduce niya ang tumatak sa masa? Eh mas sumikat pa nga si energy gap niya sa milo. Sarili nga niya hirap na niyang imarket tapos tutulong pa siya magmarket ng iba. Delusional fantard.

      Delete
    11. 2:36, sobrang tard mo naman. Yes, producer sya pero madami na ba syang naiproduce na sumikat? And ano kinalaman ng pagiging "billionaire" nya sa pagjujudge ng singing contest? At sino nagsabi billionaire sya? Proof nga ng income nya! Patawa!

      Delete
    12. 2:36 wag masyadong tard. He himself still needs voice lessons kaya hindi sya credible judge. And billionaire? Pwede pa millionaire but wala pa sya sa Billions

      Delete
    13. 2:36 lomis and their delusions your idol is not a billionaire jusko

      Delete
    14. BillionAire okay ka lng? Dinaig pa niya sila Justin timberlake at Bruno Mars!m na legit na singer At composer .... it takes years to be billionaire, awarded, recognition around the world! Pang world Class... lomi pa girl @236!!!!

      Delete
    15. Philippines IDOL noon, judges Mr. C, Pilita Corales, and Francis M. Winner Mau Marcelo, she's not an artista material. but talent prevail, because PH Idol is a singing contest not an artista search!
      actually nung nalaman ko na si james at Moira ang mga judges, i found them not credible with this huge franchise!

      Delete
    16. Pabebe and pajeje quality. Ayan kinumpleto ko na

      Delete
    17. Grabe yung delulu dito oh! Oy te hindi si jay z si james reid ha! Reality check lang hahaha

      Delete
  2. Mag audition kaya siya sa Idol ng matahimik siya! Marami siya chika hanggang doon lang naman!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. butthurt tard spotted

      Delete
    2. totoo naman ang sinasabi niya, let us admit the fact that there is something wrong with the OTHER judges.

      Delete
    3. If she auditions the judges won’t be their usual self in reaction go her statement. The 3 judges will say YES to prove her wrong.

      Delete
    4. Ok lang ang madami chika pero may substance ang sinasabi. Engaging a discussion of a certain subject can open eyes and minds. Kita mo ikaw limited saklaw ng utak mo gang fandom ka cheapan lang.

      Delete
  3. Unfortunately, life is not fair. It's not the person with the most talent who gets far.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As they always say in singing contests like these, it’s not all talent but the total package that is important. Hindi lahat ng talented people may hatak sa tao. Like the super duper talented soprano duo The Nightingales from the UP Madrigal Singers will be chosen hear if one of them joins.

      Delete
    2. that's not unfair. that's showbiz truth. what will you do with pure talent kung hindi ka naman kikita? it's a total package to make it. it's business after all.

      Delete
  4. Alam naman na ang tatlong judge walang alam sa tawag na talent maliban Kay reg.sa kanila looks over talent ang pinipili

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree, that will be awesome if someone like Bituin will be a judge to "Idol" unahin muna alisin si J then M then V

      Delete
  5. Takeaway is piliin ang contest na para sa'yo. If you are a singer/artist go to TnT or The Voice but if you are after celebrity/superstardom status and can decently sing go for Idol. Know what they're looking for. But once in a while, some challenge the status quo and want to go outside the box, some succeed some don't. At the end of the day, you take pride in yourself and your talent regardless of the opinions of others.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True sa TNT, hindi nila bet yung mga usong bosesan ngayon like nung kay Moira. Choose your battle.

      Delete
    2. And kung alam mong medyo kulang ka sa artistahin look.. Mag the voice ka.. Di naman lahat ng sunikat pogee at magaganda.. Swertihan din at charm din talaga.. Dagdagan mo pa ng true talent..

      Delete
  6. Wag kana mag Join girl, magaling ka kumanta Yes! ngunit may 2 Or tatlo mag NO sayo.... sasabihin your too Good For Pinoy Idol marami mas deserving sayo etc etc...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. un nga point nya

      Delete
    2. Magaling ba talaga kumanta or just another biritera? Ang dami nang biritera juice ko at di hamak na mas magaling sa kanya.

      Delete
    3. 3:20, if you haven't seen Bituin perform live, don't assume that she's just another power belter. Also, she's in theater. She isn't just your usual showbiz singer. She's a thespian. I suggest we look into what other local artists have to offer because there's a ton of underrated talent here.

      Delete
    4. si 3:20, halatang walang alam sa OPM kaloka. baka sampalin ka ni Bituin ng mga awards nya, maghinay-hinay ka.

      Delete
  7. It seems that this show will never survive. Lging negative ang feedback about the show. I do understand that in every industry, like showbiz, getting to the top is brutal. But due questionable credibility of the judges, people are unhappy with the way or flow of the show. Sna ksi pumili sila ng judges ng may K s lhat. Dpat may charm/mass appeal, real talent, knowledge, and respected by the mass. Hndi basta may fanbase lng. Sayang ang ginastos nila

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They have to replace James and Moira. They haven’t been in the music industry nor have the voice(James voice is too auto tune) to even be judging others. They should get someone like KZ, Erik S, or Jed M. Vice doesn’t have music credibility either but we all know he’s there for entertainment purposes.

      Delete
    2. AUTO TUNE is not considered as talent.

      Delete
    3. The judges that you mentioned are in the TnT na already kasi...

      Delete
    4. In fairness, may sense naman mga sinasabi ni James, but Moira...NAH!

      Delete
    5. Anon 1:11 eh di magproduce ka ng sarili mong show. Huwag ka sa aming nageenjoy ng current format ng Idol Philippine. Don’t fix it if it ain’t broke ika nga.

      Delete
    6. 10:48 “don’t fix it if it ain’t broke” teh broken yan! Kaya lagi may negative feedback at criticism galing sa viewers at artistas! Yung ratings pa hindi bongga, ok lang. mas mataas yung WOD ratings! For sure mag reformat yan second season, baka wala na si james at Moira!

      Delete
    7. Wla nang second season ang idolph 1:08. Umpisa plang 2 thumbs down n ang mga tao s mga judges. Pinagpilitan nila kya bagsak n bagsak n sila

      Delete
  8. I cant even sa Throw Shade at Serve Tea

    ReplyDelete
  9. I tried to watch one episode and hinde na ako umulit...
    Meron talaga ako napanood dun comment ng isa sa mga Judges“ you have the Voice pero my kulang, Or wala originality “etc loob loob ko talaga po? Eh D hamak mas maganda pa ang boses nasa harapan nila kysa sa naka upo.... singer ka? Magaling ka ba?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True. Parang sa school lang yan eh. Kung biology teacher mo ang magtuturo sa calculus maniniwala ka ba sa pinagsasabi niya?

      Delete
  10. Ewww....these idol pinas “judges” are so awful. No credibility. Not worth watching at all.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Eh di hwag kang manood. Ang taas ng rating kaya!

      Delete
    2. 10:49 hindi kabog ang ratings no. paka nega kasi

      Delete
    3. Hahahahaha...kaya nga low ratings nila e.

      Delete
  11. Hmmm...it’s a good thing I don’t watch it.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Ang hinahanap kasi nila artista hindi singer. Sana star circle quest na lang binalik nila.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 12:55 Right? Kakarelease lang nila ng bagong batch ng Star Magic at andaming artists pa nila ang tengga. Sana dun na lang sila nagfocus. Anong point nito kung hindi pala singers ang hanap nila. Sakit sa bangs

      Delete
    2. yun nga, gawa sila ng Star Academy kung saan nanalo si Yeng Constantino para ma distinguish kung ano ba talaga gusto ng network sa mananalo.

      Delete
    3. hindi ko rin magets ang ABS. Laging may pa-artista search eh super dami ng artista nilang tengga.

      Delete
    4. Regine- Musicality
      Vice- Entertainment value
      James- Star appeal
      Moira- Artistry
      Total: Idol Phils

      Delete
    5. Ahahhaha 7:09 star appeal is not equal for james, ni hndi nga nila masilba ang lubog nilang career. Moira - artistry, ni hndi nga alam ng tao ang totoong identity niya as an artist, kung baga hndi p hinog

      Delete
    6. LOL at Moira for Artistry. Rico Blanco or even Bamboo is shaking.

      Delete
  13. The Voice is way way BETTER than Idol Philippines. Sana yong judges mga ganoong kalidad nina lea bamboo sarah at apl.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Iba ang format ng Idol Philippines. Yung may star quality.

      Delete
  14. Hinahanap kasi ng 3 judges idols daw meaning sa kanila visually pleasing

    ReplyDelete
  15. Baka nga maski kay Regine eh hindi siya pumasa eh!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wahahaha! Tumfact! May kayabangan ang lola mo.

      Delete
    2. Luh! Low standard ka lang siguro tulad ng idol mo kaya di ka aware sa tunay na talent!

      Delete
    3. ok ka lang bituin escalante na yan. pasado yan panigurado kang regine

      Delete
  16. Naku, kulang sa attention si Bituin!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kulang sa kaalaman sa pagjujudge ang idolet mo

      Delete
    2. 1:00 do u need a doctor?

      Delete
    3. nagsasabi ng totoo si Bituin, your judges have low standards when it comes to talent.

      Delete
    4. Ikaw naman ay walang high standards. Pwede na ang motto mo?

      Delete
  17. naku girl ma guest ka pa kaya sa abs cbn shows after this?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. She doesn't need to. Theaters will always want her and her husband can provide. As she said, it is a moment of awareness which you seem to lack lol.

      Delete
    2. naku girl, intelligent opinion yung sinasabi ni Bituin at siguro naman pagdating sa talent, marami na siyang napatunayan not just in the Philippines but internationally.

      Delete
  18. Yes the judges should be credible sana. Kaso mga waley eh. Other than regine, the 3 does not have enough talent din naman.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Vice ganda is popular and smart but talent wise he is a mediocre. He doesnt excel in any though he can be good at times. James and Moira ewan ko kung bakit andyan. Si Regine ang pure talent sa kanilang 4.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Pero mas ok magbigay ng critic si james kesa sa pa cute na si Moira!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Still not credible as a judge. 116...sorry james just seems so pabibo with his comments. Wag syang mema kung hindi nya alam pinagsasabi niya.

      Delete
    2. 116 bakit hindi niya iapply sa sarili niya yung mga comments niya? Puro kasi siya me, myself and I. Kakanta ako ng kanta na gusto ko lang kantahin bahala kayo kung matripan niyo o hindi.

      Delete
  21. I still think "star quality" is bs. Naniniwala ako na para maging successful dalawa lang yan eh: talent/skills at network/connections. Looks can only get you so far.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Gusto ko yung sinabi niya pa sa isang post na parang wala raw siya star quality kaya nag-teatro siya haha

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Eh sa wala naman talaga. I don't even remember her having a hit song. Meron ba?

      Delete
    2. Napaghalata kayong mga mema, siya lang naman ang original singer ng "Kung Ako Na Lang Sana" na nirevive ng sandamakmak na mga singers sa Pinas. Mga wala talagang alam tong mga to

      Delete
    3. May hitsong sya na ginawa pang movie

      Delete
    4. 3:24 wag masyadong pahalata na tard ha. lawakan rin ang musical sense para di mapahiya.

      Delete
  23. Ang gusto kasi ng judges: Total Package daw. By that, yung gagawing multimedia star: Singer/performer at gagawing artista.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. But the 3 judges itself are not considered as a total package, most especially to singing department. LOL

      Delete
    2. so parang lost ang gustong makitang winner ng IDOL. Marunong kumanta, maganda/ pogi, may acting ability. Dapat may hatak sa fans.Baka gusto nila vlogger, ano pa, komedyante na pwede isabak sa modelling pa minsan minsan. Lost, walang direksyon. Anu ba gusto niyo?

      Delete
  24. Can we all just agree na the other three are just not competent enough to be judges? Like ok they can sing, may hit songs sila.... oh tapos? How influential are they sa music scene?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 100% agree ako syo 1:22 that these 3 are not compentent, not qualified, and not considerable as a judge of a singing competition.

      Delete
    2. true! ni ang mga boses salamat sa auto tune.

      Delete
    3. All four of them, not just three.

      Delete
  25. This reminds me of phband contest. Vice was also one of the judges. I remember him saying na Joao should be included for the kilig factor. And that’s what happened. Hindi na umangat ang boyband ph kahit pa ipalit sila sa Hashtags sa It’s Showtime. Somehow, very negative always karamihan sa feedback ng Idol PH. Something is wrong somewhere and it’s not James for me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 1:23 true naman na up to this day si Joao talaga ang nagdadala. if hindi waley na talaga boybandph.

      Delete
    2. Iba naman kasi ang Boyband sa IdolPH.. Pag boyband kailangan may visual para panghatak ng kilig. Si joao naman talaga ang panghatak nila dun sa totoo lang

      Delete
    3. Yup. Boyband can’t even sing. Without Joao, nobody will scream for them.

      Delete
  26. Bitter si sister.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hahahhaha she just telling the truth 1:40. U are the one tha is bitter

      Delete
    2. The truth hurts, you don’t get it.

      Delete
  27. You know what I noticed? The judges on the singing competition on It's Showtime, a noon time show, is WAAAAAAAAY more credible and precise when giving critics than those 3 judges from Idol Philippines. Just sayin'..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Correct ka te!

      Delete
    2. Truth...sa voice talaga sila...they even give good tips

      Delete
    3. Ay Oo naman. From Louie Ocampo, Dulce, Ray Valera, Gary V, Yeng, Erik, Kyla, Nyoy, ZsaZsa, etc bongga tlaga sa TNT

      Delete
  28. Palitan nila si Moira, James at Vice. Magaling si Vice but for me di niya forte ang maging Idol judge, unlike hosting. For Moira and James, no further comment. Much better cguro na sa mga TNT hurados sila kumuha ng judge. Mas magaling kumilatis un mga un kahit papano

    ReplyDelete
  29. At least Moira and James are actual musicians. Si Vice nagfi-feeling Simon Cowell. At natatawa ako when he comments about vocal technique kasi madalas naman hindi accurate.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. musicians my a*s!! ewwww overhype lang kamo like what the heck!

      Delete
    2. what kind of musicians, kakahiya naman sa mga legit. Auto tune ang panlaban, yung isa naman lasheng lasheng musician na?

      Delete
    3. Hahahahaha.....”actual musicians”? Too funny.

      Delete
  30. She is right though. I stopped watching idol Philippines because the judges are nonsensical. Can’t believe them. Ang babaw nila. No depth at all.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Magpapayat muna sya bago sya kumuda

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hahahah singing/performer ang hanap s idol, hndi sexy star 1:54. Just look jennifer hudson and kelly clarkson, hndi slim and sexy during their batch pro they prove that they can be star

      Delete
    2. Your body shaming is uncalled for, she’s entitled to her opinion.

      Delete
    3. kinalaman ng timbang niya dito? hello mas madaming magagaling na singer na ganyan ang timbang kesa sa mga payatot/ may energy gap.

      Delete
    4. Tell that to Adele and she'll slap you with her talent.

      Delete
    5. so we're fat shaming now? mga kagaya mo ang di dapat kumukuda.

      Delete
    6. Teh okay lang? Sapal ko sayo si Adele E.... kakainin niya buhay sila James and Moira sa sobrang galing niya. Si Bituin naman baka tapakan ka niya ng oras habang bumibirit. Siya may pangkain at may maganda boses ikaw meron ka sa dalawa?

      Delete
    7. Typical delulu. Pag walang maibato achievment ng idol sa body shaming ang bagsak. At least bituin is a credible singer. Hindi siya pacool kid na sa autotune naman kumakapit.

      Delete
    8. uuuy yung isang judge nga din hindi payat pero kung kumuda kala mo magaling kumanta eh nakakaantok nga. yung isa naman maganda katawan pero auto tune. wag masyadong buttthurt.

      Delete
  32. Malamang isang season lang tong idolph. Hindi rin kasi sya kataasan ang ratings di tulad ng The Voice.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Agree. Look at the 13k followers and Ave of 400 Likers per post in their IG acct.

      Delete
    2. Pero sa youtube sikat sila infer. Nearing 1 mil subs na sila at lahat ng audition vid2os 1 mil and above viewd

      Delete
  33. Mag audition ka kaya di yung puro ka assumptions.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. mahina lang reading comprehension mo bakz kaya di mo gets point nya

      Delete
    2. kilala mo ba pinagsasabihan mo besh 2:07 ,may google o or kaya nood ka ng performance niya sa You tube.

      Delete
    3. Hindi assumptions un. #Fact
      Pabebe idol mo

      Delete
    4. Hahahahaha...nalito ka baks. Anong pinagsasabi mo?

      Delete
  34. Magtaka na lang ako kung magkaroon pa ng Season 2 ang Idol Philippines, unless palitan mga judges for next season. X-Factor Nga at Pinoy Boyband Superstar di na kagad nasundan eh kasi major flopped...

    ReplyDelete
  35. Sa totoo lang itigil na yang mga pa contest na ganyan especiallt sa ABS CBN na ang dami dami dami nang singer at artista na nalaos na hindi naman lang sumikat

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. may option ka naman na wag panuorin at wag bilangin mga contests, sobra kang affected parang daig mo pa natalo na contestant lol

      Delete
    2. true, saan ba nila pagsasaksak ang mga mananalo dyan sa Idol? yung mga baguhan nga nila frozen delights eh.

      Delete
    3. Strongly agree!

      Delete
    4. 3:31 don’t you even feel sorry for those?

      Delete
    5. 3:31 sinong relative mo nakapasok sa finals. I guess ilan na lang kayong super supportive even though it’s very obvious na wala ng sense tong Idol philippines unlike other contents before.

      Delete
    6. Doon sila sa ASAP, puro sintunado lang naman.

      Delete
  36. Hay nako aantayin ko nalang the clash 2. Buti pa si sir christian at miss lani. Si aiai kahit papano nakikinig sa opinion nung dalawa. May napanuod akong clip nyang idol ung kumanta ng one in a million, halatang nainis si miss reg. Comment ng mga judge kulang sa emotion. Sabi ni reg eh hopeful song un at tama naman pagkakakanta. Lol

    ReplyDelete
  37. It's business. Tanggapin na ang truth the di pwdeng boses lang. Dapat yung pwde kang ibenta at pagkakitaan at boses alone is not enough. Wag nang ipag pilitan.

    ReplyDelete
  38. I get the point of netizens and Bituin. Nakikita ko rin yun na brutal yung ibang judges. Pero I understand Vice as well sa "star quality." Lagpas isang dekada na ata siya sa business and being a keen observer alam niya na ang kalakaran. Ilang singers lang ba ang talagang pumatok at patuloy pumapatok? Usually ito yung mga singers na hindi lang kumakanta, pwede ring umarte, mag commercial etc. Maraming talented na kahit magaling kumanta eh hindi talaga umaalagwa ang career or hindi natutuloy tuloy ang momentum, kasi well walang face value. Brutal, yes, pero ganun ang showbizness. May mga stars ngayon na on the chararat levels pero yun kasi ang marketing ng management sa kanila, to gain the masa market. Iilan lang ba sila? So yeah. Kaya nandiyan yung mga judges para may balance.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Funny that she would say this when in fact she is the very example why singing contests these days factor in the star appeal. Bituin was given all the chances back in the day. She even became a regular on asap alongside anna fegi. But the masses just did not take to her. And yes, as much as we want to deny it, looks is one of the reasons why. It’s show BUSINESS. It’s about who is bankable. It may not be right but it’s what the market dictates.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Correction, that seems to be what the Filipino audience wants. They go after the looks even if the celebrity can’t even sing.

      Delete
    2. Nope. Sobrang lakas lang talaga ng SOP nun with Back to Back to Back. Super talented kasi sila Regine, Lani, Ogie, and Jaya. Super good looking ba sila? hindi rin naman.

      Delete
    3. 3:58 that is why we should not settle on what the BUSINESS dictates, it’s time we need to give more importance to quality, hence talent. I used to watch american idol and I think that is the reason why it failed since season 9. The winners are very famous in terms of looks and star appeal but those quality did not last long because people eventually realized they just don’t have enough talent in singing.

      Delete
    4. Kaloka ka baks. So you just want to continue the nonsense? Never improve?

      Delete
  40. Dahil sa mga judges ang baba ng ratings ng show last saturday mas mataas pa rating ng mmk kesa idol. Ang dalang nila makakuha nang 30% rating last weekend 25% and 28% ang ratings nila.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Yung dalawa kasi maipasok lang... yung nsa loveteam parang ewan ko ba. No comment na nga lang ulit

    ReplyDelete
  42. Sana binalik na lang ung pinoy dream academy ung contest na sinalihan ni yeng constantino. Mas okay pa concept nun at lalo naman na mas magaling ang mga judges nung time na yon.

    ReplyDelete
  43. ang dami ng singer sa abs cbn pinipilit pang dagdagan ang mas nakakarindi nga lang kung sino pa yung mga boses paniki yun pa nagkaka album. sana pasikatin muna lahat ng artista as in lahat and after 5-10 yrs chaka sila mag recruit ng bago kakaloka sa sobrang dami nawalan na ng exposure ang iba kahit may contract pa.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Simple solution is replace the judges! Regine Velasquez, Lea Salonga, Moy Ortiz of The Company and Maestro Ryan Cayabyab should be the judges in show, hindi yung nagka-album lang feeling legit singer na.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Showbiz is business. Ganun ang pamantayan nila dahil alam ng ABSCBN kung ano ang gusto ng mas nakararaming Pilipino kung sino ba sa kanila yung bebenta pagkatapos ng contest. Sino ba ang iniidolo ng Pinoy? Diba kung sino yung maganda at gwapo? Marami naman na mas magaling pa sa pagkanta o pag-arte kesa sa mga pinakasikat ngayon pero ilan ba ang fanbase nila? Kasi sa Pilipinas may sarili tayong kultura ng entertainment. Iilan lang naman yung cguro na kayang maka-appreciate ng talent despite sa looks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Seriously? Do you still think alam ng ABSCBN kung ano ang gusto ng mas nakakarami given the very negative comments of the many pinoys? And if you say un ung pamantayan nila, is that even a standard? Anyway, sino ba ung mga nanalo recently sa mga singing comp nila and nasan na sila? Looks like their standard is not enough. Regine is the only credible judge, but her alone together with the other crap judges won’t bring ABSCBNs standard up. Just saying.

      Delete
  46. pwede bang palitan na yung tatlong judge? nasasayang yung talagang talentadong pilipino na mas magaling pa sa kanilang kumanta...

    ReplyDelete
  47. So far, sa mga napili at nakapasok, lahat talaga magagaling at may kanya kanyang uniqueness at strength. Very exciting to. I love Idol Phils!

    ReplyDelete
  48. In fairness naman sa American Idol, yung mga pinapasa nila sometimes hindi kagalingang kumanta and yes, sometimes hindi rin good looking, PERO MERONG ARTISTRY. May sariling style or composer or musician talaga. Dito sa PI? Waley lol

    ReplyDelete
  49. Regine only wants those that can birit.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Bituin, you don't have it that's why you didn't make it. You are a good singer but yes, you are not idol material. Is it a bad thing? Nope. Because it happens not just in show business but everywhere. It is about having the right fit. And besides, the judges are there for a reason. Whatever it is, hindi kayo ang may discretion sa pagpili kaya take it as it is. Kung di nyo gusto, wag kayo manood. Pero kung di kayo manonood, wag kayo magcomment like you know everything. It is a pain to hear Moira, even her nose contour is a pain to look at. But what can we do? She is there for a reason. James might not be credible but I am surprised because he is making a lot of sense, to be objective about it. Vice is not a good singer himself but again, he is there for a reason. And he brings life into the show. I watch not because of the judges but because of the contestants. And if you only watch the auditions completely without leaving a single contestant, you will realize that the bunch of kids they chose to move on to the next round is a deserving bunch.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "you don't have it that's why you didn't make it" LOL sampalin ka kaya ng talent at multiple awards ni Bituin, ano? yan hirap sa mga pinoy e.. "andyan na yan, pagtyagaan na lang" di ba pwedeng mag-aspire ng better/credible judges? no wonder Phil entertainment industry is mediocre, to say the least.

      Delete
    2. Too much blah blah from you as if you know anything. Low ratings nila, that says it all, not your blahblah.

      Delete
  51. What they should do is bring pinoy dream academy to hone artists'singing and song writing skills. Puro kinukuha natin ay singers n walang alam kundi bumirit at kumanta ng sa iba. We need artists who will contribute to opm

    ReplyDelete
  52. One of the judges's most well-known song is a jingle about not having enough energy. Enough said.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hahaha 8:20 mukang mas kailangan niya yung energy na yun. Ang lamya mag judge parang laging puyat. Parang laging antok e.

      Delete
  53. How sure are you na papasa ka kay Regine? Charot.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mismo!Huwag niyang pangunahan si Regine.

      Delete
    2. Meh, nothing great about Regine either. Sakit tinga Lang sa birit niya, kung minsan sintunado rin.

      Delete
  54. For everyone who keeps criticizing James and his “autotune” voice, Google and YouTube are free. Listen to him sing live.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We listen to him 10:10 and we prove that if hes not using autotune, he has an "Ipit" voice.

      Delete
    2. 10:10 Hindi rin siya magaling mag-live singing. What's your point? He's a weak/below average singer. Listen to Sam Concepcion or Inigo Pascual (they do the same genre as James) para may idea ka kung anong magaling.

      Delete
    3. No need to Google. His song is Not so Good. Besides WHO listens to his music anyway? Ay meron pala his die hard picon fans!!!

      Delete
    4. 10:10 okay I searched and listened to him. In the end, I hope I did not. Mas okay na lang mag auto tune sya. 2:34 is right.

      Delete
    5. He has a below mediocre singing voice. If not for his network and handlers, no music producer will sign him up.

      Delete
  55. James might be young and new but his comments have more substance than Moira in my opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  56. Because the other 3 judges are not legit singers kaya looks and “star quality” ang tinitignan nila.

    ReplyDelete
  57. Sa idol ph... yung mga judges yung jinujudge

    ReplyDelete
  58. The Biebs, One Direction, Shawn Mendes, Ariana, Taylor, Beyonc矇, Drake, Kanye, Lady Gaga, BTS, Blackpink. These are artists who have or still are raking in lots of money. We have to be honest, they’re all talented but more than talent, they all possess extreme charisma & appeal and / or good looks. It does take a LOT more than talent to make it. It may be a bitter pill to swallow but that is reality. You cannot blame judges for wanting a complete package.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anon 1:03, are the judges even star makers to recognize someone who has the potential to become a big star? When you’re a judge of a talent show, either you’re good at that genre or you’re an established producer. Moira and James don’t fall in either category.

      Delete
    2. Meh, you make no sense. These performers didn’t enter talent contests at all. Most of these artists write their own songs. Gets mo.

      Delete
  59. Basta ako hihintayin ko muna ang Top 12 nila. Sabi ni James magagaling daw. So tingnan natin kung totoo ba. Minsan kasi may mga auditions na hindi pinapalabas. Ang pinapakita lang usually is yung mag draw ng ratings. Let's see.

    ReplyDelete
  60. Totoo naman. Pag good looking, plus points agad. Kahit di ganun kagaling

    ReplyDelete
  61. I think many are missing the point of what Bituin is saying here. She understands how the Idol judging goes. Come to think of it - Bituin isn't exactly 'the' biggest music star then and now, so totoo naman what she said di ba? Sure she is a VERY talented singer, she is a GEM on the theater stage - but a 'star' by conventional standards, no.

    And what she's saying is, SHE IS OKAY WITH THAT. And that raw talent is not always enough - true din! So much raw talent out there, but not everyone has the makings of becoming a star. Di ma-gets ng mga Pinoy for some reason.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Meh, you make no sense. It’s a singing talent contest, not a beauty pageant. Gets mo.

      Delete
  62. Agree naman ako Kay bituin, malamang nga Kay regine lang siya pumasa. Kasi naman kaya nga ang tagal na niyang kumakanta Hindi siya sumikat kasi Hindi siya complete package. That's the reality , kahit mahirap tanggapin.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. sure ka dyan na di sya sumikat? google is your friend

      Delete
  63. Yabang naman ng nagsabi na "mataas ang standards ng three judges." Hindi ba alam ni manong na si Bituin Escalante ang kausap niya? Ang ganda ganda ng boses ni Bituin Escalante, idolo yan eh. Taas ng boses. I bet konti lang sa atin mga commenters dito ang nakaka abot ng mataas na notes sa "Kung Ako Na Lang Sana." Bituin Escalante vs. Shai Gomez? Come on! Kahit akong mahilig sa magaganda, MAS pipiliin ko yung deserving, yung talagang mas magaling kumanta. Dun pa rin ako sa talented!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Eh di ikaw na magproduce!

      Delete
    2. Oo yan ang gagawin ko. @7:45. Kung meron lang ako kakayahan. So tired of pabebe singers. Mas gusto ko yung talagang talented whether may good looks or not. Playlist ko: Tori Amos, Linkin Park, Machine Gun Kelly (rapper na marunong mag play ng guitar at actor and model din-- he can offer more than good looks) Bjork, Imogen Heap, A Perfect Circle, Lana Del Rey, Cynthia Alexander, Saydie and Eraserheads. Malamang sa iyo puro Taylor Swift at Justin Bieber lang ang pinapakinggan mo. Walang kalidad ang favorite music mo. Puro good looks lang kasi habol mo, binge ka na!

      Delete
    3. Despite 3:00 produce a show, but as an audience, almost all audience, are not happy with the way this show goes. Kya nga bagsak ang ratings nila. Kya nga obvious n hndi mabibigyan ng 2nd season. Kya nga obvious n nsa pitch line or cliff line ang show. Because this show is still depends to the audience and it still a business. Kung wlang tumangkilik means walang kita or return of investment

      Delete
  64. Haynaku tapusin na ang Idol PH. Excited the ako sa The Voice Kids.

    ReplyDelete
  65. Uy may issue pampasalba sa poorita ratings ni Idol lels

    ReplyDelete
  66. I wish someone from the auditionees who got rejected would say to the 3 judges "Sure ka? Eh di hamak na mas magaling akong kumanta kaysa sayo. Di ko nga alam bakit naging judge ka dito".

    ReplyDelete
  67. Baka naman kasi lahat ng magagaling kumanta hindi talaga para sa idol ph kasi the title itself says "idol" ka dapat at totoong ma star quality. well nasa tao yon kung paano nya icarry sarili nya, dapat uto utoin din ang mga judges. kaya pinahalo halo ang mga judges na idol din ng masa, millenials, singers na bumibirit at hindi bumibirit.

    ReplyDelete
  68. Pag ba pangit na magaling kumanta ang grand winner diyan,maipapangako niyo bang manonood kayo sa mga concerts nya at bibilin nyo mga songs nya? wag hipokrito, mga pinoy pa eh mahilig sa magaganda at gwapo.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is why most Filipinos do not know Nina Simone. But they know BlackPink. Most Pinoys would prefer good looks over talent.

      Delete
    2. korek! parelevant ung iba, wala namang magagawa. di na lang manood. kung ayaw di wag panoorin simple. hindi yung parang nag hihimagsik makagawa lang ng usap.

      Delete
    3. So you just want pinoys to be ignorant forever? Kaloka ka. You never learn, you never involve. Omg.

      Delete
  69. Mababa ba talaga rating nila?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yep, kya nga nagrelease ng confirmation n babalik n ang the Voice despite Idol Ph is not half way through.

      Delete
    2. Walang nanonood diyan. It’s bad kasi. Judges are no good.

      Delete
  70. ung idol franchise kasi hindi naman basta singing competition lang. it was originally Pop Idol, so total package talaga hanap nila. di uubra na magaling na singer ka lang, kailangan may star quality (looks) din talaga.

    ReplyDelete
  71. In the end, text votes naman ang magdedecide so yung mga hindi credible, walang talent at alam sa music, wag nang mag-text! Lalo na yung boboto lang because naawa sa back story. Si Regine lang dapat ang mag-text!

    ReplyDelete
  72. Guys idol ph yan at big requirement talaga ang star quality. Wag kayong balat sibuyas dyan. Para sa mga legit singers may competition din kayong pwde salihan which is the voice ph. Kung magaling lang kayong kumanta pero wala kaung confidence at star quality, hindi kau pra dyan sa idol ph.

    ReplyDelete

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...