In a pageant, a judge cant zero (abstain) a candidate. There is a rating rule, trashing a candidate is not allowed (example rating someone very high, while rating the other zero or abstain). Shamcey’s math makes sense. Someone made a mistake in the tabulations or rigged it thinking no one would notice.
voting system pala sa ganyan nde scoring? so simolybthe judges would pic 18, 10 , 5, and the winner, wala ng score score. Wala ngang mapapakitang score sheet yan hahaaa
But the question is, ano ginagawa ng auditing firm na na-hire nyo. hindi ba dapat sa kanila manggaling yung explanation at sila ang nakapansin? Ano in-audit nila?
11:04 mostly kasi dito mga ateng walang paki sa naachieve ni madam. akala nila 3rd runner up lang ng Ms U. hay nko kung makalait akala nila bobita si madam. eh obvious namang sila ang low compre. 🤭🤭🤭
Serious question :If mali yung tallied results after they deliberated /recalculated the results, why the need to include the top 18 in the Eve gown instead of announcing the CORRECTED top 10 finalists? Di po ako nanood. Napatanong lang based sa statement nya.
Kase nga its not really about the computation, its the number of viewers during the event. Imagine ano gagawin ng mga supporters ng hindi nakasali sa top 10, edi nawala agad malaking percentage ng viewers.
agree. sa ginawa nila lumiit ang chance ng totoong top 10 at nagkaroon ng chance yung dapat wala na doon in the first place. sa pag-announce rin ng top 18 eh mas lalong nagkaroon ng doubt ang manonood na baka me gusto siang ipasok na hindi napasama sa top 10 kaya nabawasan ang kumpiyansa ng tao sa final result.
12:50 i believe naipaliwanag ng maayos ng MUPH sa mga candidates ang nangyari kaya walang nangagalaiti sa mga contestants. yong mga fanneys at maritess lang nag feeling mga candidates na gusto din malaman yong nangyayari , as if ikayayaman nila.
Same 12:55. To me, Ms. Supsup's statement tarnishes the reputation of the auditing firm by saying that their licensed CPAs cannot even distinguish between 120 and 106. Lol.
Sa mga naghahanap ng pa-statement sa SGV, do you guys honestly think they will acknowledge the error? Of course not. Ano yun, sisirain nila sarili nilang reputation? As long as na-correct naman yung computation, okay na yun. Ito naman si Shamcey, napaka-condescending at vain din. There are better ways to explain the situation. Pero anyway, let’s all just move on and support Michelle Dee dahil deserve naman niya ang crown.
Are the 10 votes pertaining to the Top 10 candidates? So each judge will give 10 votes/candidates. Paano kung yung ibang judge ay hindi nila kinompleto ang kanilang Top 10?
Narcissistic pala si Sups hindi lang sa pagsali ng kandidata pati Math eh madam resibo na lng po. In Math solutions is important alam mo yan fellow Architect/Engr kaya pls show us. Additionally, backwards nasira ang tally nyo wala ng filter for next round. Anyway last mo na yan Sups.
I don't think Shamcey was talking about scores. She was talking about the total number of votes. So sa top 10, kada candidate dapat may 12 bilang ng scores (10 candidates x 12 judges = 120). Pwede rin may nag abstain sa pag-boto kaya 106 lang lumabas na total votes.
It’s just 12 judges - can’t you just clarify their votes again and re announce the right top 10 than change to the top 18 format? It’s just such a strange decision. Marunong nga sa math, kulang naman ng common sense.
Dba sa MU nga dati dapat mabilisan ang pagpindot kasi if may maabutan ng time, invalid votes nila. Dba makita din scores sa dati and may ibang judges na blank ang score sheet? So, baka the same concept applies. May di nakapaglagay ng score.
Ang gulo. If mali ung na announce na initial Top 10 kasi mali ung tabulation ng scores, recount lang needed at hindi umpisa sa sinula. Napaghahalata na di kasi nakapasok ung mga faves nila kaya gumawa ng paraan
Mas maayos pa noon kina Stella Araneta at Cory Quirino because they deliberate before they make announcements. Kesehodang abutin ng isang oras para lang walang ganyan na mangyari.
10:25 I don't think 11:59 is questioning her intelligence. Wala naman siyang sinabi. Alam nang marami she graduated with latin honors. He meant more tact and less condescension which is may point naman.
Para sakin ung pagbalik sa Top 18 ang pinakfair na decision na ginawa ng MUPh. Fair para sa mga natawag na di naman talaga pasok para di sila masaktan and Fair din sa supposedly nakapasok na may chance ulit sa Top 5. Admire Shamcey kasi kahit alam nila na marami magququestion sa decision nila pero tinama pa din nila at di nagpretend na walang mali sa Top 10 na innanounced nila
Obvious naman may mga di nag-enter ng scores properly. Hello kahit sa elections kung 10 ang voters, it doesn’t mean mag-total na 10 ang boto sa 2 candidates. Pano if may nag-abstain sa 10 jusko naman basic logic lang yan hindi need ng Math.
Lalong lumabo sa paliwanag tapos ginawang inutil ang accounting firm sa simpleng math. Kawawa yung mga nanalo dahil naging questionable pa ngayon pagkapanalo nila. Wala din naman gusto magsalita na candidates dahil sira ang pangarap nila pag nagkataon.
Jusko dyan kayo magaling.Gumawa ng ingay sa socmed.Pati candidates ninyo nakakahiya sa international stage.May kung ano anong eksena sa social media,may umiiyal etc etc.Tanggalin nyo na yan si Shamcey,panaybka cheapan
bb pilipinas was better in handling miss u candidates... sya kc all about her. even using the girls to promote their clothing company... oh well, ganyan naman talaga
tally sheet reveal nga Shamcey? your computation seems right if all the judges voted but is it really what has happened? what happened to the reputable audit firm? do they have lapses or is it your system & desire for a certain candidate to win that you need to go through that?
I wonder if clear sa judges na they should complete the 10 votes or they have the option na less than 10? Kasi SGV is not a pipitsugin auditing firm na magkakamali sa pagtally ng votes.
Pwede May nag-abstain ?
ReplyDeleteIn a pageant, a judge cant zero (abstain) a candidate. There is a rating rule, trashing a candidate is not allowed (example rating someone very high, while rating the other zero or abstain). Shamcey’s math makes sense. Someone made a mistake in the tabulations or rigged it thinking no one would notice.
DeleteMath ang kalaban ng mga LGBTQ dahil hindi pwedeng mamanipulate ng reasoning
DeleteThe headline! Hahaha
ReplyDeleteGorgeous!!!
ReplyDeletelol. akala ko kung anong super complicated computation or formula ang na discover ni madam shamcey. ansaveh ng auditors??
ReplyDeleteLol, d mo xa ngets… f may higher math ka na subject nun, g
DeleteMgegets mo ibig nya sabihin
4:34 hindi sya higher math lol. Hiyang hiya naman engineers and statisticians sa statement mo.
Deletevoting system pala sa ganyan nde scoring? so simolybthe judges would pic 18, 10 , 5, and the winner, wala ng score score. Wala ngang mapapakitang score sheet yan hahaaa
ReplyDelete*simply the judges would pick
DeleteBut the question is, ano ginagawa ng auditing firm na na-hire nyo. hindi ba dapat sa kanila manggaling yung explanation at sila ang nakapansin? Ano in-audit nila?
ReplyDeleteTama! Yun din ang tanong ng bayan.There is the SGV part and maayos na firm ang SGV
Deletepag maayos ba hindi na pwdeng magkamali ha 425?
DeleteShe comes across as condescending. Nega vibes tong si Supsup.
ReplyDeleteThe judger in me sees her as a self-righteous know-it-all and perfectionist.
DeleteParang gusto niya i discredit ang SGV
DeleteMataas tingin sa sarili
DeleteAn absolute narcissist. Feeling ggss. Lipas na panahon kaya dapat pa relevant pa rin.
DeleteYes I know director soya or whatever, but that's the vibe she gives off. Iplaster ba nmn malaking mukha niya sa facebook?
Top 1 sa board exam. May K naman maski papano.
Delete11:04 mostly kasi dito mga ateng walang paki sa naachieve ni madam. akala nila 3rd runner up lang ng Ms U. hay nko kung makalait akala nila bobita si madam. eh obvious namang sila ang low compre. 🤭🤭🤭
Delete5:38 sa thread na to, hindi compre skills. Sabi nila condescending daw.
DeleteWhat if the judges did not give them a perfect score? Then you can never get 120. Why don’t you show us proof so we can understand it better!
ReplyDeleteBetter ilabas nila yung actual score card
DeleteEwan ko sa iyo. Dami ko ebas
ReplyDeleteSerious question :If mali yung tallied results after they deliberated /recalculated the results, why the need to include the top 18 in the Eve gown instead of announcing the CORRECTED top 10 finalists? Di po ako nanood. Napatanong lang based sa statement nya.
ReplyDeleteKase nga its not really about the computation, its the number of viewers during the event. Imagine ano gagawin ng mga supporters ng hindi nakasali sa top 10, edi nawala agad malaking percentage ng viewers.
DeleteWala ding sagot diyan unless they're going to be extremely transparent tbh. Ang wild naman kasi na top 10 tapos top 18.
Deleteagree. sa ginawa nila lumiit ang chance ng totoong top 10 at nagkaroon ng chance yung dapat wala na doon in the first place. sa pag-announce rin ng top 18 eh mas lalong nagkaroon ng doubt ang manonood na baka me gusto siang ipasok na hindi napasama sa top 10 kaya nabawasan ang kumpiyansa ng tao sa final result.
DeleteYou' re right. And hirap din nila talaga paniwalaan sa totoo lang
DeleteKasi may mapapahiya. Nagkamali ng top 10, so may nakasama na dapat wala sa top 10. Mapapahiya yung girls.
Delete2:34 if thats the case then that should be her explanation. Pero hindi po niya sinasabi yan, so don’t assume po.
Delete12:50 i believe naipaliwanag ng maayos ng MUPH sa mga candidates ang nangyari kaya walang nangagalaiti sa mga contestants. yong mga fanneys at maritess lang nag feeling mga candidates na gusto din malaman yong nangyayari , as if ikayayaman nila.
DeleteShow your solution beh. Yung mismong sa pageant as resibo.
ReplyDeleteThis is their 4th year running this org, dami pa ding aberya. To think na pageant veterans yung nag papatakbo ng org
ReplyDeleteWaiting for SGV's statement 🍿
ReplyDeleteSame 12:55. To me, Ms. Supsup's statement tarnishes the reputation of the auditing firm by saying that their licensed CPAs cannot even distinguish between 120 and 106. Lol.
DeleteSa mga naghahanap ng pa-statement sa SGV, do you guys honestly think they will acknowledge the error? Of course not. Ano yun, sisirain nila sarili nilang reputation? As long as na-correct naman yung computation, okay na yun. Ito naman si Shamcey, napaka-condescending at vain din. There are better ways to explain the situation. Pero anyway, let’s all just move on and support Michelle Dee dahil deserve naman niya ang crown.
ReplyDeleteI think she had to do that bec people are insinuating may daya and blaming her and the org for what happened.
DeleteAre the 10 votes pertaining to the Top 10 candidates? So each judge will give 10 votes/candidates. Paano kung yung ibang judge ay hindi nila kinompleto ang kanilang Top 10?
ReplyDeleteNarcissistic pala si Sups hindi lang sa pagsali ng kandidata pati Math eh madam resibo na lng po.
ReplyDeleteIn Math solutions is important alam mo yan fellow Architect/Engr kaya
pls show us. Additionally, backwards nasira ang tally nyo wala ng filter for next round.
Anyway last mo na yan Sups.
SGV na isang auditing firm hindi nag audit?
ReplyDeleteMga ante move on na tayo. Mas nagdedemand pa ng transparency at explanation sa sa MUPH kesa sa mga results sa election hahaha
ReplyDelete🤣 at the end of th day clapper yan
ReplyDeleteI don't think Shamcey was talking about scores. She was talking about the total number of votes.
ReplyDeleteSo sa top 10, kada candidate dapat may 12 bilang ng scores (10 candidates x 12 judges = 120). Pwede rin may nag abstain sa pag-boto kaya 106 lang lumabas na total votes.
It’s just 12 judges - can’t you just clarify their votes again and re announce the right top 10 than change to the top 18 format? It’s just such a strange decision. Marunong nga sa math, kulang naman ng common sense.
ReplyDeleteso gusto mong ipahiya yong mga gurls na di sana kadama sa top 10 kaya lang natawag because of the glitches!?
DeleteDba sa MU nga dati dapat mabilisan ang pagpindot kasi if may maabutan ng time, invalid votes nila. Dba makita din scores sa dati and may ibang judges na blank ang score sheet? So, baka the same concept applies. May di nakapaglagay ng score.
ReplyDeleteMalamang ang tinutukoy nya ay kaya back to top 18 ung miss universe kasi mali mali ang computations
ReplyDeleteAng gulo. If mali ung na announce na initial Top 10 kasi mali ung tabulation ng scores, recount lang needed at hindi umpisa sa sinula. Napaghahalata na di kasi nakapasok ung mga faves nila kaya gumawa ng paraan
ReplyDeletemaari ring mga may mapahiyang naisama kaya mas minabuti pang ibalik na lang sa top 18
DeleteMas maayos pa noon kina Stella Araneta at Cory Quirino because they deliberate before they make announcements. Kesehodang abutin ng isang oras para lang walang ganyan na mangyari.
ReplyDeleteDefinitely hindi pang Ms Universe ang sagot ni madam. Apakacondescending. Walang elegance sumagot. Kaya di nanalo eh.
ReplyDeleteelegance? si shamcey pa talaga ang naquestion ang intelligence? hahaha
DeleteSure, why not? Perfect b siya? Wala p nga clang mproduce n pnalo pano p kya kung this year di p ulit mag place yan?
Delete10:25 I don't think 11:59 is questioning her intelligence. Wala naman siyang sinabi. Alam nang marami she graduated with latin honors. He meant more tact and less condescension which is may point naman.
Delete1107 ilang years din nga po pala under stella nagkaroon ulit ng miss U? duh!
Delete11:07 4 na dekada po bagong nasundan si Margie
DeleteThis is bad look sa auditing firm. Sgv ba yung firm? Wala slang official statement kung bakt nagkaganyan?
ReplyDeletePara sakin ung pagbalik sa Top 18 ang pinakfair na decision na ginawa ng MUPh. Fair para sa mga natawag na di naman talaga pasok para di sila masaktan and Fair din sa supposedly nakapasok na may chance ulit sa Top 5. Admire Shamcey kasi kahit alam nila na marami magququestion sa decision nila pero tinama pa din nila at di nagpretend na walang mali sa Top 10 na innanounced nila
ReplyDeleteThis!
DeleteSince navalidate ni sgv, before iannounce, hindi pa naibigay and checked by shamcey supsup lee?
DeleteThe design is very me me me look at me. Even the math ginawa nyang about her anuna beshiewaps
ReplyDeleteIs there really a glitch, or intentional itong issue to make them relevant?
ReplyDeleteThis is not about you and your love for Math, Shamcey. Enough!!!!
ReplyDeleteKung mali ang total, need lang bilangin ULIT nothing else. Hindi kailangang back to zero ang scores ng Top 18.
ReplyDeleteObvious naman may mga di nag-enter ng scores properly. Hello kahit sa elections kung 10 ang voters, it doesn’t mean mag-total na 10 ang boto sa 2 candidates. Pano if may nag-abstain sa 10 jusko naman basic logic lang yan hindi need ng Math.
ReplyDeleteang point niya is, lumagpas sa dapat na asahang max score yung lumabas na overall sum.
Deletebasic logic talaga! alam mo bang hindi ka pwedeng mag abstain sa pagbibigay ng scores sa beauty contest? hahaha logic ka dyan!
Delete5:47 Ngayon ka lang nanood ng pageants. Kahit dati na naka-flash ang scores meron mga di nakakabigay ng scores hahaha!
DeleteApaka oa….ilang judges ba at ang hirap magcompute? pampaingay lang diz….nawalan na talaga ng prestige ang pageant na yan
ReplyDeleteLalong lumabo sa paliwanag tapos ginawang inutil ang accounting firm sa simpleng math. Kawawa yung mga nanalo dahil naging questionable pa ngayon pagkapanalo nila. Wala din naman gusto magsalita na candidates dahil sira ang pangarap nila pag nagkataon.
ReplyDeleteMay nagsalita nman gurl, si Emmanuel. But obviously, wala na sya pake sa Shamcey org kaya nagsalita. Lmao
DeleteJusko dyan kayo magaling.Gumawa ng ingay sa socmed.Pati candidates ninyo nakakahiya sa international stage.May kung ano anong eksena sa social media,may umiiyal etc etc.Tanggalin nyo na yan si Shamcey,panaybka cheapan
ReplyDeletebb pilipinas was better in handling miss u candidates... sya kc all about her. even using the girls to promote their clothing company... oh well, ganyan naman talaga
ReplyDeletetally sheet reveal nga Shamcey? your computation seems right if all the judges voted but is it really what has happened? what happened to the reputable audit firm? do they have lapses or is it your system & desire for a certain candidate to win that you need to go through that?
ReplyDeleteI wonder if clear sa judges na they should complete the 10 votes or they have the option na less than 10? Kasi SGV is not a pipitsugin auditing firm na magkakamali sa pagtally ng votes.
ReplyDeleteSo hindi magaling sa Math accountant firms? Ikaw na pinaka madam pinaka hambugera.
ReplyDeleteUnder her rule,lahat ng controversy meron itong MUPH
ReplyDeleteNahiya ako sa SGV! Nagaral pa ng accountacy mga staff niya di mapansin ang napansin ng grade schooler
ReplyDelete