Ambient Masthead tags

Friday, February 17, 2023

Official Statement of 'FPJ's Batang Quiapo' on Offending Muslim Community in Episode

Image courtesy of Instagram: dreamscapeph

65 comments:

  1. pandagdag publicity. good or bad news. publicity pa rin

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Una at huling beses na may Muslim sa eksena yan pramis hahaha. Ginusto niyo yan eh. Kathang isip lang un kwento gusto nilang gawing totoo lol imbes forward eh pabackward sa pagiging entitled at insensitive

      Delete
  2. Tanggol ba ang name ni FPJ dun sa movie?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nope. Ang layo nga ng story nitong adaptation ni Coco.

      Delete
    2. Baldo ang pangalan niya.

      Delete
    3. Batang Quiapo lang ang title pero mukhang mash-up ito ng pieta & anak ng cabron. malayo sa original movie, siguro para may “room for growth” for 7-8 years plus. 😉

      Delete
    4. Sana inacknowledge naman si Ace Vergel dahil siya ang bida sa Pieta at Anak ng Cabron. Na obviously eh pinagkuhanan ng storya at dialogue ng Batang Quiapo ni Coco. Chopsuey action serye pala ito.

      Delete
  3. Tanong ko lang, so kung Kristiyano (all types), Buddhist, Atheist or ibang religion ang portrayed ok lang? Meron namang masama sa bawat religion. It's not the religion who is bad, it's the person/s doing the bad thing. Nagkataon siguro sa story e lugar ang Quiapo ay may mga masamang Muslim gaya ng may masamang tao sa ibang religion pero di agaw-pansin kasi nakasuot sila ng pang-ordinaryong damit at di madistinguish agad anong religion nila.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kaso nga iba ang punishments for Muslims. Putol kamay levels.. Plus di rin naman essential sa story ang pagiging Muslim ng characters so bakit kailangan gawin silang Muslims? Bad potrayal yan for Muslims. May negative na nga na tingin sa kanila tapos dadagdagan pa ng show. Gets mo?

      Delete
    2. 10:54 Tanong ko lang din, napanood mo ba ung video kung bakit nagreact ung mga muslim sa palabas ni coco, o nagcomment ka lang agad ng hindi mo alam ung issue?

      Delete
    3. Never mo maiintindihan yung disappointment ng Muslim community sa pag-portray sa kanila as “bad” individuals kung never ka pang naging stereotyped minority.

      Delete
    4. Napanuod ko yung Legal Wives sa GMA. Story ng Muslim family. Pinakita don na napakahalaga ng dangal ng tao at pamilya. Umabot sa point na nagpapatayan ng magkaaway na pamilya (rido). Hinding hindi pwede sirain ang reputasyon ng Muslim.

      Delete
    5. Baks may stigma kasi sa mga muslim at simpleng galaw laging nage-generalized.

      Delete
    6. Ikaw na din ang nagsabi. Pwede iportray ang eksena without adding religious association sa characters. But they did. So inevitably na extend yung association ng religion sa behavior nung characters sa show. It all boils down to being responsible show producers.

      Delete
    7. Well, uso kasing ma offend nowadays. Lahat nalang may hanash sa bagay bagay!

      Delete
    8. 1:22 e hindi naman religious representation ginawa di ba? The person doing the bad deed just happened to be a Muslim. Again, pag may pulis o politician na corrupt portrayed on TV or film, inaalam ba natin kung anong religion niya? Hindi di ba?

      Saka 1:05 paano naging minority ang Muslim when after Christianity, it's the second predominant religion in the country? Sa ibang bansa lang yang minority sila at may discrimination. Well-celebrated pa nga Muslim brethren natin dito sa Pinas.

      Delete
    9. Masyadong balat sibuyas kase ang mga tao. Parang si Robin, i ban daw nya yung movie na”Plane” dahil bad portrayal ng Pinas. So dapat pala walang bahid ng kasamaan ang Pinas sa lahat ng movies. Nagiging laughing stock na lang tayo sa buong mundo.
      Sa Middle East nga e, may movies naman na may portrayal ng bad Muslim . Kase alam namsn nila na hindi lahat matino. Just like other religions.

      Delete
    10. Again with this kind of understanding na it is always about the religion.. If you as a person, hindi mo siya maiintindihan dahil hindi ka muslim. If you are always portrayed, labeled, stigmatized as a bad person dahil sa religion and race mo, would you still react the same way? 10:54? Will these words that came into you will be the same it you are in the same boat as those who were offended? I bet hindi. Try mo mag suot ng hijab sa labas tignan ko kung hindi ka iwasan ng mapa babae man o lalake? Pag nakakakita ka ba ng arabo, bombay do you still think wala kang iniisip towards them or even labeled them at the back of your mind?

      Delete
    11. 1:51 eto yung scenario dun sa serye ni coco, hinahabol sya ng pulis dahil nang snatch sya ng alahas, tapos dumiretso sya dun sa compound ng mga muslim at dahil dun hindi na tinuloy nung mga pulis ang paghabol sa kanya ( parang iniimply nila na takot yung mga pulis na pasukin yung compound dahil muslim ang mga nakatira). Dun sa sumunod na eksena, tinanong nung muslim kung bakit hinahabol si coco ng mga pulis, ang sabi ni coco ay dahil nga nang snatch sya, alam mo sinagot nung muslim? "OK LANG YAN KASI NAKAKATULONG KA NAMAN" so pinaparating nung programa ni coco na kinukunsinti nung muslim yung pang ssnatch ni coco. Balik tau sa comment mo, ung mensahe nung serye ne coco, ok lang magnakaw basta nakakatulong, so ok lang din mangurakot mga pulitiko basta nakakatulong? ABA ANG GALENG

      Delete
    12. Salamat 10:48. At least alam ko di pala ako nag iisa na makaisip na may mali ata sa napanood at narining ko. Nagulat din ako dun sa dialogue. Pinalalabas na ala Robin Hood yung character ni Coco and they're ok with it.

      Delete
  4. Ganito dapat ka responsable. Hanga din ako sa bumubuo ng Batang Quiapo.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Good. Accountability. Hindi nag-deny. Hindi nagpalusot. Hindi nag-justify. Umamin sa kamalian

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ngeks. in the first place, dapat inaral yan. iwasan kesa puro sorry pag napuna

      Delete
  6. Wala namang pinagkaiba to sa mga pulis, politikong corrupt sa mga teleserye eh, fiction nga, kathang isip, may disclaimer naman. Masyado lang silang sensitive.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. half meant naman in my opinion and experience may mga bad na iba ibang relihiyon kahit muslim

      Delete
  7. Sus, pero mag asawa ng marame pwede? Kasi tradition nila? Tse

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kerek. Ginawang legal ang mali kaya naging acceptable

      Delete
    2. There are rules and rituals na preserved sa bawat religion. Religion is not a one size fit all. So yes allowed sa kanila ang mag asawa ng marami kasi hindi naman sila katoliko na hindi allowed sa kagaya naten. Hindi naman kinuwestyon bakit naten sinasamba ang rebulto e.

      Delete
    3. Sus! Maka-comment ka lang. Halatang wala kang alam. Hindi basta basta pwedeng mag-asawa ng marami ang Muslim.

      Delete
    4. You are a kind of person who is ignorant. In Christianity, is it allowed to have 4 wives in.legal ways? No, right? You have to file a legal separation first but because its expensive, Catholics juat abandoned their family and have elicit affairs that's always potrayed in movies and teleseryes. Did any Catholics react?
      Being ignorant is like a cancer, its comtagious.
      So respect the islam religion.
      .

      Delete
    5. Clearly, wala ka talagang alam. You're a good example of putak ng putak, wala naman alam. Why don't you read facts on how Muslims follow polygamy. Sus, may masabi lang ket walang alam no?

      Delete
    6. 12:43 Hahahaha halatang wala kang alam. May macomment ka lang. Hindi sila basta basta pwedeng mag-asawa ng madami.

      Delete
    7. @11:39..ikaw din clearly wala kang alam..wag ng mag justify kung hindi ka sigurado dyan sa ideology mo..

      Delete
    8. @1:20. Ideology? Walang alam? Sa religion ko? Nakakahiya naman sayo. Hahaha

      Delete
  8. So hindi po OA ang reaksyon ng mga Muslim. Matuto po sana ang mga tards ng ABS-CBN sa gesture na ito.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Buti naman, humingi ng paumanhin ang management. I hope that they will have a chance na ipakita ang kanilang kultura in the future series. That’s Rez Cortez. He’s not going to be there for one night only. And the Muslims are an integral part of Quiapo. Babawi sila sa mga Muslim for this mistake.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Bakit walang opinyon si Sen Robinhood?

    ReplyDelete
  11. Owning it up is better than letting it pass na as if justify yun portrayal as fiction. Sana ganito mag isip yun mga nagsasabi dito na fiction lang naman and this is oa. This is way better than not doing anything at all. Let's all move on, better be careful lang talaga sa mga sensitibong topic gaya ng relihiyon, pulitika at gender. Hindi tyo magkakapareho ng pananaw. Kaya dapat lang na maging sensitibo kung eto ay isasama sa isang palabas.

    ReplyDelete
  12. If Coco wants to keep producing, need niya talagang mag invest sa research. Sa latest episode na kang, ilang beses binanggit yung N word. Sabihin na naman OA i-call out as nasa Pinas naman. That can be problematic kung may nakapanood niyan.

    ReplyDelete
  13. umpisa palang, sablay na.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Meron pang isa....ang paggamit nila sa word na "negra." I have nothing against the show dahil maganda ang production pero sana piliin nila ang gagamitin nilang words.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Gulat din ako diyan. Paulit ulit pa. Alam kaya nila na that word is considered racist? Di na nga ginagamit yan ngayon.

      Delete
  15. Nakakainis yung mga nanonood ng show ni coco.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Sorry pero they portrayed the Muslim characters as morally good. Mababait sila at parang anak-anakan ang turing kay Tanggol (Coco). May pagkarebelde man ang dating, but its Quaipo. Saka baka may backstory sila to justify kung bakit sila ganun.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Replies
    1. yan ang di maintindihan ng mga laging na ooffend

      Delete
    2. sensitive truth hurts kasi

      Delete
    3. Spell INSENSITIVE

      Delete
    4. F. I. C. T. I. O. N. Fiction.

      Delete
  18. Kaya nga fiction eh! Toxic ng mga utaw kahit ano na lang issue!!!

    ReplyDelete
  19. Ay awan ko kung bakit parang guilty sila. Nagpuputak agad eh fiction at may disclaimer. Pag katoliko ginawan ng ganyang eksena,, okay lang, pag Muslim , bawal .. haysss

    ReplyDelete
  20. This network is known for producing shows without extensive research. Basta na Lang.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Kahit naman fiction, you can portray the scene in a way it doesn't offend the muslim community. The police didn't have to say that they're afraid to enter the compound and just went ahead inside, knock on the door. The policed acted Muslim as if they're different breed of people.

    The difference here in BQ compared to Legal Wives, is they didn't correct that in the scene. Meanwhile in Legal Wives they did throughout when there would be discrimination happening in the show.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Double standard pala ang relihiyon. Dapat pala perfect ang portrayal parati. Sa Oinas ko lang narinig yung ganitong mindset . Sa dinami dami ng international movies na nag tackle ng mabuti at masama in relation to muslim . Sa Pinas lang ganito ka big deal. Close minded mga tao dito. Ni hindi ma differentiate and fiction vs reality.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nope. If this was also done in series in the west, for sure they’d get flak too.

      Delete
    2. 1:14 I’ve been watching Law and Order for a long time and Chicago PD . Daming na tackle dun . Watch mo.

      Delete
  23. Hindi ko gets. Ang daming palabas sa TV na Katolikong rapist o mamamatay tao. Wala naman nagrereklamo. 😂

    ReplyDelete
  24. Grabe magresearch ang GMA team para lang maging maayos nilang maipresenta ang mga Muslim sa Sahaya & Legal Wives... then there's ABS. Naalala ko tuloy yung babaylan character sa Bagani noon, ginawang katatawanan... ang layo sa portrayal sa Amaya.

    ReplyDelete

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...