Wednesday, March 6, 2019

James Reid Reacts to Criticism on Being a Judge of Idol Philippines

Image courtesy of Instagram: idolphilippines

Video courtesy of YouTube: StarsPhotog Vidz

125 comments:

  1. Magaling si james pag caption pero pag sa interview walanf subtance si james

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 12:27, akala mo lang yon. Isa si James na with sense pag kausap. Ayaw lang talaga niya pag nega ang topic. Dinedeadma na lang niya...

      Delete
    2. @12:27 i think this is why people don't want him to be a judge. Sabaw siya magsalita on camera. He's only good with captions but when it comes to banter he's not entertaining. Have you seen his stint in showtime. He's boring. He cannot carry a show he can't even go along with Vice Gandas banter when he was in showtime. He doesn't have the personality to be a host or a judge.

      Delete
    3. True! Napaka boring nya magsalita.

      Delete
    4. Then why he unable to communicate when he was in showtime 12:52? Even he use the scripts or spiel that the prod given, his delivering is not good or not smooth.

      Delete
    5. nakakahiya na ayaw sya ng mga viewers mag judge, meron bang credibility na mag judge sya

      Delete
    6. He has a boring personality. Dami nga nagsabi na effortless ang performance nya non sa anniversary competition ng showtime kasi yung role nya dun parang inaantok lang din. Lol

      Delete
    7. He’s boring and doesn’t really know music well enough to judge it. He will be replaced next season for sure.

      Delete
    8. I think he is an introvert, si billy did all the talking here. No hosting skills yung James.

      Delete
    9. ewan ko ha, pero napaka-aloof at suplado ni james, idagdag pa yung inglisero. he can barely speak tagalog, eh most ng sasali sa pacontest na yan, galing sa masa. weakest link siya sa judges. lalamunin siya nina vice and regine sa banter. tignan natin kung di siya matameme. sa talas ng dila ni vice?

      Delete
    10. Hahahaaa!! My grad! Diba nga Palaging absent yan sa Showtime dati. LOL

      Delete
    11. Ay true 5:42. Sayang ang pinaghirapan ng lahat gwa s kanya. Yung mga judge npatanong anu kwento at nung nlaman ang kwento napaewan ang mukha ksi hndi nagtranslate ang action at mukha ni james s kwento. Kya kulelat sila

      Delete
  2. Sana tumgal siya diyan. Yun Lang!

    Bye

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Eksena pa as host si Billy? Jusko. Ang OA na waley rin.

      Delete
    2. Viva ba may hawak ng show na to? Parang eh.

      Delete
  3. Jusko daming haters. Haha. Hindi naman porket Idol Philippines eh puro kantahan na lang para singers lang din ang maging judge/s. James Reid can sing, dance and act. Andyan sya sa show na yan kasi management knows he is and he can. Sa mga daming may kuda dyan, eh di wag kayo manood. Hehe.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. pero aminin mo walang technical expertise kahit saan man si jayme. maka hehe ka dyan hahaha

      Delete
    2. Hinde talaga Kami manood. Mahirap ba sa inyo tanggapin na nag sasabi Lang ng totoo. Mahirap sa inyo gusto lagi good feedback sa idol niyo Kahit naman nega naman talaga at hinde qualified si James to be a judge.

      Delete
    3. LOL at can sing ,dance and act . You are fan for sure. He can carry a tune and some steps but you can call this those sing and dance? Lets not talk about his acting and the same role he is playing for years

      Delete
    4. @12:28 good we will not watch and because of the low ratings from people like you who tell people don't watch that show will only last one season!

      Delete
    5. 12:42. Not sure kung anong technical expertise pa hanap mo but james composes his own song, he is a producer, he has his own label. IMO compare to others seating on those chairs mas may credibility sya. To be able to do those at a young age is an achievement. I do not necessarily follow his music but i’d recognize what he has made for himself.

      Delete
    6. Truths 12:42 in denial ang mga lomi

      Delete
    7. may words of wisdom naman sya maishashare sa mga contestants, ang nakikita ko lang na problema sa kanya ay yon work ethics nya na hindi consistent. Ngayon wala syang movie at serye siguro naman maayos ang mga schedules nya at walang magiging problema sa tardiness, at sana hindi sya sumpungin ng katamaran tapos gagawa lang ng lame excuses. Pero good luck pa din, kailangan nya kumayod pangbayad sa mga artists under careless label company nya. Wala pa naman masyadong kita sa mga underground artists.

      Delete
    8. 1:03, truth, nag labasan na naman ang mga inggit, palibhasa, nasa limelight na naman si james. Nakaka suka na ang defense nyo na nag sasabi lang ng totoo.

      Delete
    9. Why tlga sinabi mo n hndi credible maging judge si regine 1:00? How shameful of u. It doesnt mean that he produce his own music it means that his credible to be judge. Being judge means that u know how to deliver your opinion, judgement, or statement. The reason why people see james as not credible judge is because his talent is still questionable since his singing voulice is not that good. Also, he's not that good in impromptu or hosting

      Delete
    10. Ano inggit doon 1:18? We are voicing out our disappoint to the show, for choicing him and moira too. How can we believe somehow who doesnt have stable or strong to the showbiz, most especially to music?

      Delete
    11. 12:28 He can sing, let’s give him that. But he was not known for his singing. He’s an actor who can sing, not somebody who’s good in singing.

      Delete
    12. @1:07 AM wala siyang movie or serye dati kaya nga sila binigyan ng showtime pero hindi parin siya sumipot kahit nga dapat saturday lang siya pumasok wala parin.

      Delete
    13. Grabe 1:00. Hiyang hiya nman si regine kay james. Regine has establish her name to the ph's music while james is having a hard time to promote his music to the pinoy/masses. Whats more, his name is still not have strong foundation to the industry

      Delete
    14. **voice and not voulice

      -1:29

      Delete
    15. 1:00 he composes his own song for his own benefits not for others. Does he has a critical acclaim as producer ?does he has a hit song?does he has an expertise about what type of a singer could be contestant ?the answer is NO is not credible enough because even as an artista he is not credible.

      Delete
    16. can s8ng dance and act e5c...BUT he is mediocre in all this. sorry but not sorry!

      Delete
    17. 1:00 kaloka, lahat ng judge may kanya kanyang strengths at role so James is not any more credible than his cojudges. If anything, si Regine ang pinakacredible dahil mas malalim ang alam ni Regine sa behind the scenes ng music industry. Marami ng startup indie labels ang inestablish ni Regine noon at marami na rin siyang artists na pinagproduce ng album jusko pati sariling album ni Regine siya mismo nag executive producer. Wala pa diyan yung experience niya as a concert and record producer.

      Delete
    18. 12:54 On the contrary, you are one of the reasons why backwards pa din ang Pilipinas. You just settle with what they feed you. Mapa-artista or pulitiko, nasasanay tayo sa pwede na.

      Delete
    19. 12:42 / 12:46 Eh di kayo na magaling mag judge. Ang daming may halhal dito. Hahahaha. Kayo na lang sa ipasok sa Idol Philippines tutal bibo ka naman.

      Delete
    20. pano ka makakapag judge kung hindi ka din naman kagalingan, mamaya mas magaling pa yung mga singers na contestant.

      Delete
    21. the guy can sing a little, can dance a little, cannot act his way out of the amboy roles he is pigeonholed into playing. what he is is a pretty face na paborito ng viva.
      even his compositions, sabaw as in. bakit kay bruno mars may recall agad?
      palitan yan. bakit di si jay-r, or erik santos or kyla?

      Delete
    22. bakit ba ginawang judge yang sila Moira and James, ni wala naman napatunayan. NEXT!!!

      Delete
  4. Medyo may yabang din itong si billy no? Akala mo napaka galing. Anu ka si usher Adam Levine? Oh please.

    James? Naco daanan Lang niya sa pa cute yan. Para bumenta.

    Pilipino shows talaga no? Minsan mapapakamot na Lang sa ulo. Hay

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 12:32, and you for a pinoy, ang tindi ng crab mentality mo. You are one of the reasons why backwards pa din ang Pinas. Simple lang, do not watch their show...

      Delete
    2. I never liked Billy nga eh. Di naman gwapo. Pero medyo may talent din. Yun lang

      Delete
    3. 1232 my opinion deal with it! Yes, I will not watch their show. Oh please!

      Delete
    4. not a fan of billy pero magaling naman siya sa sing and dance wag lang sa hosting medyo waley siya dun.

      Delete
    5. i would take billy over james anytime. at least marunong managalog.

      Delete
    6. Billy at least may napatunayan na internationally. Magaling din mag host.

      Delete
  5. I find his face to be too feminine and bland.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This is a singing competition. Kahit ako man contestant nakaka ilang sumali sa contest na ang judge mo eh primarily actor slash commercial model slash whatever who also can sing lang. In other franchises, the judges were all backed by years of MUSICAL experience and achievements.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Exactly exactly. I mean, kung wala naman silang ibang makuha, parang dapat ata si Billy Crawford ang naging judge sa kanilang dalawa, experience-wise.

      Delete
    2. Very true k dyan. Despite yung iba ay hndi singer pro alam ng nakakarami n kya magpasikat ng tao s music industry

      Delete
    3. 1:24, dami nyong dunung-dunugan dito, pero pag hinarap naman kayo, wala kayong mga face.

      Delete
    4. 1:55 Oh, I can face you hunny. Atsaka walang masama sa sinabi ko. Ikaw i-compare mo ang resume ni James at Billy pagdating sa music, kung sila din lang ang pagpipilian, mas lamang si Billy. Pero ginawa lang cyang host at si James ang judge kasi mas maraming fans si James.

      Delete
    5. correct! maski si Moira, bakit daw yun wala naman masabing international stardom to her credit?!?

      Delete
    6. 1:55 mas wala kang face at wala kang dunong. So wag kang puro kuda , anonymous ka rin naman.

      Delete
  7. Okay nako na alam niyang maraming critics para di galingan niya sa pag jujudge.

    ReplyDelete
  8. bakit pag matagal mo siyang tignan sa pics parang may pagka banlag?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Lets see muna what he bring to the show. Minsan kasi kahit hindi singer can be a good judge sa mga singing comp din. Minsan nga kahit singer mapapakamot ka na lang sa way of judging and choosing contestants eh. Remember X-Factor Philippines? That show was such a mess. Imagine natalo pa nung Kedebon ang AKA Jam? So lets give this guy the benefit of the doubt baka naman may maibubuga pagdating sa judging.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Dear Billy,

    Naghahanap pala kayo ng “papasikatin” - bakit di niyo pasikatin yung judge niyo? I mean sorry ha, pero James is all hype. Hindi niya nga mapasikat sarili niya so maghahanap pa kayo ng ibang papasikatin. Gigil mo ko.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hahahhaa tawang tawa ko sa yo bakss!! Pak!

      Delete
    2. 1:07, sige lang, nang pumutok ang ugat mo at mabawasan ang masasamang tao na tulad mundo sa mundo.

      Delete
    3. Exactly. Puros yabang!

      Delete
    4. sorry pero sikat talaga siya kaya wala kang magagawa

      Delete
    5. Hahaha si 1:22 pikon. Hndi ksi matanggap ni hndi sikat ang music ni james. Pinalala p n hndi n ganyun kasikat siya

      Delete
    6. 1:44, walang pikon dito, kayong mga haters ang stressed sa galit dahil judge si James. Kung hindi na sikat si James, bakit affected kayo sa mga shows niya???

      Delete
    7. Hello I'm with the same age of James... and yes I'm updated sa mga latest trends and ok na music ... but to be honest wala ako Alam sa mga kanta niya....

      Delete
    8. Affected kmi 2:09 because this is first show of miss regine in abs cbn after return. Kung makakasama lng ni miss regine ay hndi credible to be judge, paano kmi mapapalagay n success ito lalo n ang mga common folks ay hndi kumbinse kay n james and moira n wla pa nman npapatunayan s music.

      Delete
    9. correct!!!!! hahahaha, oo nga bakit hindi naman gaanong sikat sila Moira at James.

      Delete
    10. check na check! 2:40 walang credibility yang dalawang yan, James and Moira, kung sila nga hindi man gaanong sikat. Ano daw ijudge nung Moira, kung antukin ang style ng pagkanta? yung ganyang style parang kinopya lang dun sa Casper na nag audition sa The Voice noong araw.

      Delete
    11. 2:18 Magaling si Casper, unique ang boses. Tapos pretty face pa. I have a soft spot pa naman pagdating sa pretty face and voluptuous or curvy body. I liked Moira dun sa The Voice, pero nung naging singer na, I agree nakakaantok nga boses niya. Need niya ng better songs (Moira).

      Delete
    12. Wala kayong magagawa. Sila James and Moira ang naging choices kasama si Regine as judges of the show. They all have their own strengths and weaknesses. Let them be. Wala pa nga yung show, puro kayo putak. Lakas nyong maka nega...

      Delete
    13. 3:16 correct! I like that Casper, I wonder what happened to her. She was such an original character. Anyways sana man lang yung Moira lets go of the boring style and have upbeat songs.

      Delete
    14. 2:09 hello gising ka sa katotohanan! hindi nya yan show. So wag nyang hatakin pababa yang magandang show na yan.Kaloka ka at kelan naging kanyang show yan. Kala ko kay Regine talaga yan?!?

      Delete
  11. Auto tune naman sya

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 1:20, kesa naman sa nag pipilit kumanta, pero sintunado naman. Eauw!

      Delete
    2. Boomerang effect 2:10 ang comment mo.

      Delete
    3. baka pagalingan sa pag aauto tune mga contestants.

      Delete
    4. yung isa auto tune, yung isa naman parang laseng na kantahan.Baka may ganung style mga contestant.

      Delete
  12. Replies
    1. Umuusok ang mga ilong ng mga bashers ni James. Hahaha... stress pa more sa inyo. Sige lang...

      Delete
  13. Talented, grounded at unassuming. Pinili siya diyan dahil meron siyang macocontribute.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I do hope n makatulong din sya s work ethnic since napakahalaga nun s lhat ng uri ng trabaho.

      Delete
  14. medyo boring siya. Magaling Lang siya pumarty.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Love you James. Prove them wrong

    ReplyDelete
  16. Ang cringe kapag iniintroduce si Billy na may nakakabit na "international pop star," or "international singing sensation." Di naman yan magsisisiksik dito kung talagang star siya sa international scene. Look at Bailey, nag appear ulit sa asap recently. Mukhang nararamdaman na di naman umaalagwa ang grupo niya.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. billy nag top yan ng charts for sometime in UK. Ewan bat nanumbalik sa Pilipinas baka mas malaki ang offer.Pero si James, saan umalagwa ang career, sa interview parang tinulungan pa ni Billy.

      Delete
  17. Yung mas talented pa yung contestant kesa yung judge. lol! Push parin ng push sa kanya eh halos wala na silang natirang fans na dalawa ni nadine dahil sa sobrang kanegahan

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. yun nga eh, iba din itong ABS pag nagpa HYPE pati autotune yun na ang voice quality ngayon.

      Delete
  18. Record producer? Own label? Walang pake casual listeners sa music mo. Sa fans mo lang yan mabenta puro kasabawan lyrics

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. MTV kinopya sa ex pati tunog.

      Delete
    2. Kopyang kopya. Ngayon Lang niya tinuloy mga music niya coz he has funds na.

      Delete
  19. dapat viva idol panay viva talents haha ka umay pramis... sana magfranchise ang abs ng survivor phils at si retsard ang ulit ang host go retsard ❤

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ewan ko ba sa Viva, kahit yung mga flop binigyan ng mga shows.

      Delete
  20. Totoy na totoy ang Katawan ni James lol

    ReplyDelete
  21. Let’s be honest, he wasn’t picked for his talent as there’s so many others more talented than him. He was picked to attract the mellenial/younger generation. That group will not watch the show if it’s a bunch of veteran/older singers they aren’t aware of.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. wala na bang mas sikat dyan, o kahit singer na lang para may credibility.

      Delete
  22. jusko, let's give him a chance. kung ayaw nyo sa judges eh di wag kayo manood. tapos

    ReplyDelete
  23. Gosh grabe dming mga criticism prang kyo na Rin Ang judge ksi Kung mkapag jugdge kyo Kay James wagas bkit di nyo bigyan Ng chance galit kyo ksi hndi idol nyo Ang nakuha..hndi nman siguro sya kukunin Jan Ng wlang dahilan..


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. hindi, kasi nahahalata ng mga tao na wala namang basehan kugn bakit nga sila ni Moira judge.Actually may point dito yung mga taong nagsasabi ng totoo. Ang hirap sa inyo, kala nyo natutuwa lang mga nanonood sa lahat ng mga palabas ninyo.

      Delete
  24. Mas matitiis ko naman si James kesa kay Moira. ZZzzzzZz

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Si moira may alam sa style ng kanta at marunong mag payo. Si james kailangan pa ni billy

      Delete
    2. hello, si Moira, nakakaantok yung mga kanta. 12:22

      Delete
    3. correct din naman ito. Bakit nga si Moira?!? antukan ba ang labanan. Kung makakatulog audience sa kanta, mas bet.

      Delete
    4. oo daw 11:00 magdala ng mga kumot at unan mga audience.

      Delete
  25. Grabe mga bashers ang gagaling niyo pa kesa sa producer nang show. James was chosen for a reason so give him a chance kung maka pag down kayo nang artista kala niyo ang gagaling niyo. 😤

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. sa dami ng singing contest sa Pilipinas, natural lang na sanay na mga Pilipino kung sino talaga ang mga magagaling at karapat dapat mag judge.

      Delete
    2. Eh di ikaw ang mag produce nang show ang galing mo eh 2:23 😂

      Delete
    3. that's the point, we cannot find any reason why James became a judge.

      Delete
    4. 9:51 e kung ikaw kaya sumali para kasing nagmamagaling ka.

      Delete
  26. He's to young and inexperience to be a judge of a prestigious singing show like this!

    ReplyDelete
  27. Haters always gonna hate dahil mga sarado ang mga utak. They will only believed and insist what they want to believe. How I wished all the celebrities in Philippines must just ignore and play dedma will all the bashers and haters coz hindi ka mananalo sa mga ganitong klaseng tao. It’s a fact only in the Philippines are the most judgmental people. Toxic at salot sa lipunan!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. then don't live here and get a life somewhere else. Kung nagbabasa ka ng mga socmed, maski sa ibang bansa ganun talaga mga comments, if they don't like you they say it. Walang tulak kabigin. Alangan naman purihin ka pero mediocre.

      Delete
  28. Matunog yang name na James Reid pero hindi kasi ako naging interesado dyan kaya di ako nagbabasa ng any article about him. Now lang cause nagulat ako na judge daw yan? Bakeett? Anyway natatawa ako pakinggan yung boses nya. Parang tunog lata🤣 very unexpected

    ReplyDelete
  29. Tignan na lang natin kung anong gagawin ni james at moira, papanuorin ko ito sa umpisa pero kapag hindi nila ako naimpress sa istilo ng judging nila goodbye!!!

    ReplyDelete
  30. parang itong interview na ito humingi ng resbak si James Reid kay Billy dahil hindi nya maexplain kung bakit nga naman siya judge.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Regardless of what he'll bring into the table, producers & executives will choose the people going to the next round especially top 10. If you watched Idol for the past decade you'll know that not all deserving contestants get to make it. Somehow, there's influence from executives as to who they want to win & who are novelty contestants. These judges somewhat are like puppets. But it helps boost the show & ratings if they can deliver lively & entertaining bantering, comments & antics. And don't forget, bottomline is audience text votes. Viewers still decide and have the power to make an IDOL hopeful win. Come top 10 these judges will just be decorations, so better focus on the contestants you will root for.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i concur 10:23. also, nobody remembers the last philippine idol winners. wala akong matandaan. pero si erik santos, KZ tandingan, kahit si mitoy, tanda ko.

      Delete
    2. judges are not mere decorations. they can make or break the show. why was american idol the most watched tv show before, wasnt it because of simon cowell? try nyo lagyan dyan ng mga boring na judges na hindi swak ang opinion, kung may manood nyan.

      Delete
  32. Well, lets all be honest here. The only reason why he is in pinas showbiz is because he is a half-breed. Talent-wise he is quite mediocre at best. Let’s admit that at least.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. kaloka, katagal na nila sa Pilipinas, amboy pa rin ang project.Chos. Ano yan slow sila maka intindi ng tagalog.

      Delete
  33. That’s pinas showbiz for you. They make even a very good show, horrible. The four judges are no good at all. They’ll ruin the show.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Wether you like it or not andyan na si James isa siya sa na pick na mag judge and siya ang pinili nang producer. Kaya wag niyo siyang sisihin pinili siya eh. Mga bitter na lang kayo👊

    ReplyDelete
  35. Paano nyo na-judge si James eh si Billy ang pumapel ng pumapel. Gosh!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. true, parang may tigapagsalita si James in the form of Billy.

      Delete
  36. Kalokohan lang talaga sa pinas. They just ruin everything. Those judges are no good at all.

    ReplyDelete

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...