Monday, July 2, 2018

FB Scoop: Writer Allen Tolosa Claims Alex Gonzaga and Fifth Solomon's Film 'Took' His Title without Proper Acknowledgement





Images courtesy of Facebook: Allen Tolosa

81 comments:

  1. Title lang ba issue nya or ang story mismo? Well napanood ko ang teaser at nagustuhan ko mga hugot lines at nakakatawa

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Give credit where credit is due. Ayusin nyo to or else kakarmahin kayo. Tsk tsk...

      Delete
    2. Ayoko ng mga ganitong pangyayari. May nagtiwala na bigay ang obra tapos lolokohin lang ayaw bayaran aagawin pa pinagpaguran. Please!!!! Tama na mga ganito. Mahiya nman kayo sa balat nyong na gluthathione!!!

      Delete
    3. 9:56 bakit pag aari ba ni allen yung salitang “nakalimutan”??? Hindi natin alam kung pareho kwento dahil teaser palang at the same time iba naman title hindi parehong pareho. Ano ngayon iccredit???

      Delete
    4. They asked him first, tapos biglang sinabi ni fifth na hindi na lang. Tapos makikita mo almost same ng title? Hindi parehong pareho pero pareho ng meaning. Sana nagisip sila ng ibang title ung malayo sa gawa ni allen, maniniwala pa ako. Maybe they can’t think of anything good. So stealing pa rin yan. Kahit iacknowledge lang nila ang creative input nung writer.

      Delete
    5. Parehong pareho naman

      Delete
    6. Antay nyo nalang muna pelikula bago kayo dakdak! Dami dami nagpapareho ng title naiba lang ilang salita wala naman issue. OA lang tong Allen

      Delete
    7. LIAR! HE OBVIOUSLY CARES!!!! Ginawa pang sangkalan yung creative minds kuno e creative mind na nga siya na naetsapwera!

      Delete
    8. 1:38 true. paulit ulit ang "don't care" pero ang totoo, nagccare naman talaga

      Delete
  2. This may not be a violation of the copyright law per se but this is definitely unethical. Ano ba naman na i-acknowledge siya

    ReplyDelete
  3. i kind of feel for Allen. While it is true that copyright law doesnt cover film titles, creative minds should at least be protected. i think it's about time to have title rights.

    Catchy kasi ang title kaya siguro pinush pa din ni Fifth na gamitin without even letting the "owner" know. Or Fifth did his research and found no legal implications for such. Lowest of low if the allegation is true.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ikaw rin ung nasa fb? Or ginaya mo lang even the wordings? Gets kita kaya nga nakakainis sila. They should acknowledge Allen!

      Delete
    2. That’s business heller. Wag kayo sensitive. Wait for the movie muna bago kayo humanash at gumawa ng mga allegations at kwento

      Delete
    3. 1:22, yes, that's business. Pero hindi ba mas magandang mag-start sa business ng wala kang inaapakang tao. Kung isa kang nagsisimulang writer/director, tapos unethical na agad ang galawan mo, malamang wala kang pupuntahan

      Delete
    4. 2:17 dont expect this industry or business to be ethical this isnt a church. Ganyan talaga.

      Delete
  4. Wala ba sila pangbayad kay allen or need lng tlaga iacknowledge si allen?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Di ko rin gets. Dapat abangan nalang natin kysa magjudge

      Delete
  5. Is this part of a gimmick?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ano pa nga ba. Pampaingay sa movie. Hindi uubra yung follow-unfollow medyo obvious na

      Delete
  6. fifth solomon...magpaliwanag ka. what a shame!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Halaaaaaa patay. Kahiya naman nyan!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Awww! So feeling pag-aari nla ang gawa ng iba.

    ReplyDelete
  9. kapal naman ni fifth

    ReplyDelete
  10. Kahit na title lang nung poem yung kinuha nila, dapat may acknowledgement pa din kahit paano or nagpaalam man lang ng maayos. Ang kinakagalit naman yata nung Allen yung ang sabi sa kanya na gumawa sila ng ibang poem tapos nung ipalabas ang trailer, aba yung title pa din ng poem ni Allen yung ginamit. Pag naman hindi uminit ang ulo mo.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Kahit title lang yan, magpaalam kayo ng maayos. The fact na alam na nung may-ari na baka sakaling gamitin yung poem nya. Yun yun e.

    ReplyDelete
  12. "Gumawa na lang kami ng sariling poem. Di na namin nagamit yung poem mo". Tapos gagamitin mo pa din yung title, that is so low! Pwede naman sigurong sabihin na "pero since catchy yung title, gagamitin pa din namin". Courtesy lang.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yun nga e, kahit pa title lang yan. Unethical ang galawan ni fifth dyan

      Delete
  13. tsk tsk... sana nalang may acknowledgement, in fairnez catchy ang title!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Korek, proper acknowledgement. Pwede naman nilang sabihin na inspired by Allen's poem... mahirap bang gawin yun? O gustong magpabida, writer and director? Hmmp!

      Delete
  14. Even if the poem was not used, aminin, inspiration nung movie yun title nung poem, ginawa ngang title eh, so dapat may credit pa rin

    ReplyDelete
  15. As a noob writer myself, this gives me anxiety thinking any of my work could get stolen and the thief could get away with it. Ugh!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Sus, pampaingay isyu 101!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Di bale mr tolosa..siguradong bagsak/flop naman itong akex gonzaga movie!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. E di wow! Madam auring ka eh alam mo future e

      Delete
    2. Not as a prediction, karma lang naman!

      Delete
    3. Baka ang karma pa kumita dahil nilalait nyo tandaan ang binababa siyang tinataaa ni Lord

      Delete
    4. Wag nyong idamay si Lord dito, mga fans ni Alex

      Delete
  18. How about intellectual property rights that has been violated? It may not be the copyright but the intellectual property

    Wellsago

    ReplyDelete
  19. Gusto ni allen pagusapan din siya. Oo pareho ng thought yung title pero iba naman wordings.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kitid din ng utak mo. Gusto nya lang sana na iacknowledge siya ng proper way

      Delete
    2. 12:08 gawain mo din yan

      Delete
  20. Nagsisimula palang si fifth ganyan na sya. Sobrang unethical

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pwedeng first time kaya wala pa alam
      Masyado

      Delete
  21. Wow. This guy knows how to make papansin and maging pa-bida. If you could’ve settled it privately then it would be better. Teaser palang yan gusto mo na agad iacknowledge ka?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sa yo yan gawin? Matutuwa ka?

      Delete
    2. 1:11 kakausapin ko ng maayos di magrant agad at di idadamay ang artista na wala naman kinalaman dyan

      Delete
    3. Maybe the reason why he tagged Alex kasi screenshots yun ng IG stories ni Alex, you know... proper acknowledgement šŸ˜‰

      Delete
    4. 2:34 or to just make his papansin more viable?? Famewh*r* MUCH

      Delete
    5. Hahaha, good point 2:34

      Delete
  22. Wag idamay si Alex or artista. Si fifth at produ habulin mo. Gusto mo ba ishoutout ka nya sa vlog nya?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dapat lang malaman ni Alex. Para aware sya na may ganyang issue sa movie nya. She can spin it into a positive PR pa nga if she wants to. Not to petty shoutouts that you, 1:08 is suggesting. If she is smart, she will know what to do

      Delete
    2. 1:24 pwedeng itag si alex pero bakit kailangan idamay so alex sa copyright law ek ek nya? Sorry pero PAMPAM si allen

      Delete
    3. 2:00 AM, sinabi ni Alen na hindi sya bihasa sa copyright law, di ba? Masyado ka namang triggered. Sinabi lang nya na time to review, wala syang sinabi na magdedemanda sya. Gusto mo separate pa pag tag ke Alex at kay Fifth? Wow lang, demanding ng iilang fans ni Alex

      Delete
    4. True. Leave Alex out of this.

      Delete
  23. Huuuy, mga comments nyo nagpapakita lang na mukhang wala kayong respect for creativity ng isang tao. For someone na tulad ni Allen Tolosa, napaka improtante ng acknowledgement. It wouldn't have been unethical if Fifth Solomon has not contacted Allen sa umpisa. He can claim ignorance of the existence of a poem with similar title. But he did. They used his poem title but didn't use the poem. Even if kung totoo na wala yung copyright infringement, as a respect lang naman sana sa kapwa nyang artist sana nilagyan na lang nya ng "inspired by the poem" with same title.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Parang lang yung kay Noel Cabangon ba yun? Yung pinagcompose sya ng GMA ng song tas gumawa sya then sinubmit then biglang sasabihin hindi na raw gagamitin tas biglang pinalabas na yung ibang ginamit na song, yung music katulad ng ginawa nung Noel medyo iniba-iba lang konti. Kaasar yang ganyan. Mandurugas lang ang dating.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sobrang kaasar

      Delete
    2. oo nga. mandurugas talaga ang dating.

      Delete
  25. Not illegal, but highly unethical.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. At kelan pa ba naging ethical ang showbizness???? Isa pang unethical, magrant sa FB

      Delete
    2. Just because swapang ang iba, hindi ibig sabihin maging swapang ka na din 2:08

      Delete
    3. 2:08, I do understand your sarcasm but there is such a thing as biz ethics.

      Delete
  26. Si koya mong allen gusto bumida. Nagsocial
    Media agad. Alam naman pala nya number ni fifth di nalang muna kinausap. Cheh

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. E alam din naman ni fifth yung number ni Allen, o bakit hindi sya nagpaalam ng maayos? Pag sa akin ginawa as in kukuda din ako

      Delete
    2. Victim blaming. Grabe. I feel for this guy. Parang sa work lang yan. Wag credit grabber :(

      Delete
  27. Publicity is publicity. Tinulungan mo pa sila Allen!

    ReplyDelete
  28. Nagkainteres pa naman ako sa movie na ito dahil sa title kahit ang WEIRD lang na sa JOB APPLICATION pa talaga siya naghugot lines. TITLE na nga lang ang may sense nakaw pa sa idea ng iba. Eh di wala na akong rason para panoorin ito.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kung ayaw mo manood e di wag. Paannounce announce ka

      Delete
  29. Haaayyy naku...sue them. That should teach them a lesson.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Sbi ni pareng allen i dont care aboit d credit; i dont care about the tallent fee PERO humahanash!!!! Yeah right you dont care nga...hlatang halata!

    ReplyDelete
  31. Very similar ang title sa song nina Shakira and Rihanna. Un ang npansin ko

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Eh buti daw sina shakira nagpaalam sa kanya. Orig kasi concept wala iba pwede makaisip LOL

      Delete
  32. Dinamay pa niya si Alex eh artista lang yan malay ba niya sa ganap ng production diba

    ReplyDelete
  33. Nakakatawa yung film base sa teaser! Dahil dito lalo iingay at mapaguusapan

    ReplyDelete
  34. Promo lang yan para magkaron ng ingay yan.

    ReplyDelete

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...