Monday, July 2, 2018

FB Scoop: Annette Gozon Valdes Calls out Magazine Article for Lack of Research on Article about GMA's 'Victor Magtanggol'

Image courtesy of Facebook: Annette Gozon Valdes

122 comments:

  1. Kasi daming kuda about copyright ek-ek. Hindi pa nga napapanood ang kwento. O ayan tuloy medyo may pa spoiler na si Atty Anette. Aabangan ko ngayon ang Victor Magtanggol dahil dito.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pfffft Pero ang Marvel kasi ang unang gumawa na gawan ng character as a Hero ang isang Myth. E bakit hindi niyo na lang pinahaba buhok ni Alden at kinuha ang Samson o kaya as Nimrod?! Kelangan pa talagang kopyahin ang Marvel! Wag Ako GMA!

      Delete
    2. 1:06 Ang Disney unang gumawa ng Snow White film. So bawal na rin gumawa ang iba???

      Delete
    3. 1:06 Sweetie, magreklamo ka rin dapat ke Mars Ravelo. Dahil tbh, rip off din ang Darna sa Wonder Woman ni Moulton Marston a long long time ago. Pati Captain Barbell rip off din from DC Comics. Para naman hindi halatang sa GMA ka lang nagagalit. LOL

      Delete
    4. 1:06 Sigurado ka na Marvel ang nauna sa pag gawa ng myth characters into heroes? Ano yun silang lang pwede maglabas mg heroes?

      Delete
    5. And do we forget 1:06. Lobo trilogy is also inspired from Twilight series because of its vampires vs wolves theme, et al. Now, lets talk about "copycat". LOL

      Delete
    6. Additional info for you 1:06 para maintindihan mo ang ibig sabihin ng "inspiration". Ayoko naman sabihin mong biased ako sa GMA, maiba tayo. Ang "Okay Ka, Fairy Ko" sitcom dati nina Bossing ay inspired lang din sa "Bewitched" US tv series circa 60's, kung saan ordinary guy nakapag asawa ng witch. Sa case sa "Okay Ka", ginawa na lang fairy. If your not familiar sa Bewitched old sitcom, naging Nicole Kidman movie siya mga mid 2000's.

      Delete
    7. 12:14 lol puwede ba obvious namang tards ka ng kaH sa comment mo. ni di ko nga alam na atty yang si anetter ikaw alam mo. Hehe.

      Delete
    8. bish 2:08 prof ko si atty anette sa law school. wag kang assuming.

      Delete
    9. 2:08 halatadong hater ka, lahat ng tao alam na atty yan

      Delete
    10. away pa kau. ipanalangin nyo na lang wag langawin😂 malamang waley na naman to hahaha!

      Delete
    11. It's not about copyrights kasi true naman na free for all ang mythology PERO thr fact is they're making this Victor character at after the success of Thor/Avenger series. Which makes Victor a ripoff. Kahit iba ang story.

      Nakikisakay sila sa popularity ng naunang movie/series much like sa Alyas Robinhood & Sherlock Jr.

      Hindi deserve ni Alden yun after his award winning Alaala.

      Delete
    12. 2:08 AM bish, harvard law school lang naman po si annette nag-aral.

      Delete
    13. 2:02 Skepticism is understandable w/out being vulgar in comments. Same case rin dati sa original "Engkantadia" na maraming skeptic dahil rip off daw sa "Lord of the Rings" series, evendue spin off yan ng "Mulawin". Pero nag hit, pati na rin ang recent remake. Speaking of award winning actors, the likes of Ate Guy, Ate Vi, Maricel Soriano, Edu Manzano also portrayed superheroes in the past. Naging kabawasan ba sa stature nila? Michael Keaton and Christian Bale also wore caped superheroes. Its ironic ke Michael Keaton dahil comedian siya, portraying a serious superhero role. Pero naghit sila sa audience. Dont limit Alden's capability sa drama he if can do any roles with gusto. Ang tunay na actor, kayang gampanan ang kahit anong role, kahit taong grasa pa. Lets give Alden a chance by supporting this project.

      Delete
    14. Eto kasi iyon. Had there been no Marvel's Thor, would Annette's writers ever come up with this concept. Guess NOT in a million yrs. Kaya tama na itong public domain, Norse myth, etc. Kopya pa rin na maliwanag.

      Delete
    15. 7:51 And your shallow mind is so smaller than Alden's mask.

      Delete
    16. todo tanggol na naman si Glinda.. gaya gaya na naman ulit ang ending FLOP parin. whahahahahaha

      Delete
    17. Kesa naman mga makikitid na utak na ignaciatics na katulad mo Manggalina ang dapat kung ipagtanggol. LOL

      Delete
    18. Glinda. tulad nga nga naipost ko.. ang ENDING.. FLOP pa rin. hahahahaha

      Delete
    19. In the bulk of your pea brained ignacia head Manggalina. LOL

      Delete
    20. In the bulk of your pea brain ignacia head Manggalina. LOL

      Delete
    21. aasa ka na naman Glinda. kaya ka lalong nasasaktan. ilang beses ka ng umasa sa mga pinagtatanggol mo. nalaos na nga yang aldub mo hanggang ngayon naasa ka parin tatabo yan sa ratings. whahHahahahahahaha

      Delete
    22. Magsitigil na nga kayo. Nakakatawa kayo sa totoo lang. Hindi pa nga pinapalabas ang show.

      Delete
    23. Kumusta naman ang Bagani natin Manggalina? Nakakahiya naman sa most expensive prod at most premier loveteam Lizquen, nilalampaso sa ratings ng show na not-so-famous ang mga bida. LOL

      Delete
    24. ayon at patok pa rin sa ratings Glinda. kahit tingnan mo pa sa NUTAM. ni di nga makapagyabang yung writer ng kamuning sa Ratings diba?kasi Lugmok. whahahahahahahahaha

      Delete
    25. Saan mo nakuha ang source mo Manggalina. Sa kapamilyakingdom? sa starmometer? Na pinagyayabang ang La Luna Sangre dati, pero naligwak pa rin dahil sa kalaban. LOL

      Delete
    26. Eh di sa NUTAM na pinopost ng KAMUNING. ay oo nga pala madalang lang sila magpost kasi napapahiya sa ratings ang kamuning dahil lugmok a rin. Whahahahaha

      Delete
    27. Keep on talking to the hand Manggalina. LOL

      Delete
    28. Glinda.. di ka updated? whahahaha
      may bagong released ang kamuning na ratings ah... lugmok ang KAMBAL mo samantalang umiibabaw ang BAGANI sa NUTAM? kamuning mo na naglabas nagdadahilan ka pa. whahahahahahaha

      Delete
    29. Expected na sayo yan Glinda. Nakakahiya naman kasi yung lugmok na Kambal mo eh. Whahahahahaha

      Delete
    30. In your wild imagination sweetie Manggalina. LOL

      Delete
  2. Oh ayan Suzzzzzy dapat ganyan magpaliwanag hindi yung bira ng bira

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. syempre atty si annete! eh si suzzy ano so what would you expect?

      Delete
  3. Ganyan din issue sa Alyas Robinhood Nung pinalabas wala ng complaint about copyright. Maganda nga lumabas yung TS na yun.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kaya nga ginagaya din nila yung same publicity. Pero maswerte robinhood kasi kumagat yung bida ng arrow, nagcomment. Eto walang kumakagat. Mga kaf tards lang.

      Delete
    2. no need po, Alden richards po yan.

      Delete
  4. All these publicity, good or bad, is creating more interest in this teleserye. People now want to watch to see if it's a copycat or not.of Marvel's Thor.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. On the first week lang..

      Delete
    2. 1:11 You can't just judge kung first week mo lang panonoorin.

      Delete
  5. Small handle ang hammer sa photo ni Victor Magtanggol.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Todo explain nanaman to eh for sure gusto lang naman nya na mapag usapan tong korni na show na to. Sounds cliche pero yes FLOP to for sure.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And your comment was soo CLICHE.

      Delete
    2. 1218: she needed to explain for people like you -- too loud on their opinion based on zero to little knowledge. in short, basher. baka sakaling makapagisip ka bago ka mamintas at mag hate.

      Delete
    3. 12:43 12:45 bakit feeling nyo ba girls hindi to magiging Flop? At hindi ba kayo nakokornihan dyan? HAHAHAHAHHAHA

      Delete
    4. 5:35 Hindi lahat ng tao Nega tulad mo.

      Delete
    5. 1218/535: ang sigurado pa lang sa ngayon ay ang basher/hater ka, sa kabila ng kaunting nalalaman mo. kung flop or hindi ang show ay hindi pa sure. try to suspend judgment, especially if you know very little. wala pang napahamak jan. at mat train ang utak mo na maging open.

      Delete
    6. Korni talaga eh, try nyong magpakabit ng cable para malaman nyo yung hindi korni na shows. HAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAA

      Delete
    7. 1008: you are behaving accordingly, as a basher/hater would. now you're judging and trying to insult us on a personal level, without knowing anything about us. see our replies to you? mayroon ba diyang humahamak sa iyo at hindi base sa totoo (ang png judge mo ng baduy at flop gayung wala ka pang alam tungkol sa show)? what we suggested that you do is to at least suspend judgment. by the way, we have cable.

      Delete
    8. @1218,535,1008 Kapal ng mukha nito. Baka magulat ka na karamihan sa aming mga tards dito, mga professional at mga subscriber ng more than a hundred channels. Wag mo kaming itulad sa iyo na m pretty sure, low life at pagiging basher lang ang alam. Pasosyal ka pa, hindi naman halata sa comment mo. Tseh!!

      Delete
  7. Same lang naman sa hanash ni Suzette sa Bagani before, remember? Now that they are called out for the Thor issue, super defend rin sila.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. hindi rin, napakalayo kaya.

      Delete
  8. at least may ingay dagdag sa publicity,ang tanong hanggan kelan ang show?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thor the superhero isn't in the public domain. If your Thor was wearing beast skins and armor, and is a Norse God, then iyon ang nasa mythology. Problema sa GMA ngayon eh sobrang gayagaya. Akala ko ba panay original kayo.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ay! Napanood mo na ba yung show??? Akala ko coming soon pa lang cya?

      Delete
    2. 1231: he is. read up before you comment. if at first you don't understand, read again, until you get it. better that than spew opinion based on wrong info. nakakahiya.

      Delete
    3. 12:31 Can you differentiate a superhero from a myth god? Thor as superhero is based on Thor from the myth including his hammer and super powers.

      Delete
    4. 1:20 Marvel made Thor the super hero, basing it on Thor the Norse god. Tapos GMA is making a super hero based on Thor the Norse god. So gaya gaya din talaga sa Marvel.

      Delete
    5. True. Copya copya copya lahat. It’s embarrassing.

      Delete
    6. If the it won't rate, they'll say "8 weeks lang talaga ang story nito". #advancelangmagisip

      Delete
    7. 11:43 - hindi dapat #advancelangmagisip ang hashtag mo kundi #ifatfirstyoudontsucceed. nabutata na kayo sa first try niyo kaya sa ibang anggulo naman kayo titira.

      Delete
  10. Arrow and Thor on GMA7!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I don't care if its rip-off, copycat, blah blah. Basta excited na ako sa paglabas ng Victor Magtanggol. Kung puwede, bukas na, charot.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ako din gusto ko mapanood. GMA is known for good fantaseryes.

      Delete
  12. the issue is obviously because of the hammer na hawak ni victor magtanggol,which i also think is the whole point of it all,kung wala ung hammer, no comparison, tama yung isang commenter na its like alyas robin hood all over again.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thor in Norse mythology has a hammer. The hammer is not something Marvel created. Please read post of Anette Gozon re hammer.

      Delete
    2. Kailan pa naging pagmamay-ari ng Marvel ang hammer ni Thor? nakakahiya naman sa mga totoong nagsulat ng Norse Mythology.

      Delete
  13. Kasi daw don't judge a teleserye by its teaser.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Saka na magreklamo ng copyright infringement pag si Alden naging long-haired at may balbas na.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Parang puputok na yung cheeks ni Alden dahil sa mask nya lol

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 12:59 lol lagi na lang ganyan comment. Wait ka pag pinalabas nya at kung ganyan pa rin same sa picture.

      Delete
    2. Ang tindi ng insecurities ng mga haters ni A! Bakit kaya,12:59? Sorry na lang kayo, mamatay kayo sa inis ng mahaba pang panahon LOL!!!

      Delete
  16. hays....ganito lang yan ibig bang sabihin na si mars ravelo ginaya din nya sina capt barbel,darna,dyesabel,lasticman etc kay marvel,disney at dc? pati narin yung obra ni carlo caparas may pinag-gayahan din ba? #researchmunakasi

    ReplyDelete
  17. Grabe naman kase pagkakamukha Kamuning. Un sa arrow at ngaun sa magtanggol na yan.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ah okay daw sabi ng La Luna Sangre 🤣😂

      Delete
  18. i dont think na mag-ri-risk ang gma sa isang production,kung alam nila na magkaka problema sa copyrights o kung ano pa mang chenes... si suzette doctolero magaling yan mag research at maghukay ng mga kasaysayan ,origin etc. kayo lang kasi masyadong judgemental. for example yung arrow sa us...ginawa lang naman ni dc na mas hi-tech..pero nang galing parin yun k robin hood. #research

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mga ignoranteng Dostards kasi mga yan, palibhasa mga telefantasya nila baduy or flopchina bwuahaha

      Delete
  19. Reading the comments. Daming "myths" about copyright infringement.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Lol hindi porket libre ang story eh gagayahin na lang lahat. may sarli naman tayong mythology at LIBRE rin. Bakit hindi yon ang pagbasehan. Ayaw din kasing magresearch aney. Okay sana kung yung mga cgi effect on par sa mga thor movies ng marvel. Nakatsamba lang sa robinhood at naging controversial kaya nagrate akala makakaulit. Lumang publicity na naman ito. haha. Sadya.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. nakagawa na nga di ba ng pilipino myths na may kabuluhan... remember Amaya & indio....maganda quality at story nun. ano gusto mo gumawa ng maria makiling,si malakas at si maganda etc... bakit di ba pwede mag explore ng ibang myths? pag ibang bansa pwede? lagi kasi nasa isip nyo gaya-gaya lang...ikaw ba hindi ka ba nang gaya sa talambuhay mo?hindi ka nangopya nung nag aaral ka? sa looks/fashion/life style hindi ka nang gaya..? im pretty sure nang gaya ka rin...

      Delete
    2. Sabihin mo yan sa La Luna Sangre na gaya gaya lang sa Vampire Diaries or Twilight @1:50... or worse sa Encantadia na flopchina! Akalain mo sa flop na show pa ginaya ng idolets mo! Bwuahaha 🤣😂

      Delete
    3. 12:41 Sweetie, fanaticism in your katol network makes you blind to reality. No matter how hard you want to deny, Encantadia is not a flop, or else, walang may nag eexist na Bagani sa katol network. LOL

      Delete
  21. Haaaayyyyy pinas.......puro rip-off lang. nakakahiya kayo.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 2:38 mass kahiya hiya ka

      Delete
    2. 2:38 yeah anyway Annette & Suzi put it, whether a norse god of public domain, kopya pa rin.

      Delete
    3. Rip-off is everywhere my dears, including sa theater world. "My Fair Lady" at "Gigi" ay rip-off din sa Pygmalion legend. Nagkaroon pa nga ng mga descendants sa Hollywood like "Pretty Woman", "Mannequin", and the movie adaptations itself. "Mean Girls" movie ay rip off din sa old "Heathers" movie. "Pretty Little Liars" tv series was inspired from "I Know What You Did Last Summer" movies and "Gossip Girls" tv series combined. Superman comics gave the world numerous imitations in movies, tv et al. Marami pang cases sa rip-off pero I only mentioned few examples. Baka wala nang space sa FP comment. But the bottomline here is. Its not "Only in the Phil". LOL

      Delete
    4. So true, puro kopya lang talaga sa pinas. It’s embarassing, no imagination at all.

      Delete
    5. True, and it’s not even a good rip-off, it’s usually poorly and cheaply made. It’s hard to watch.

      Delete
    6. 1226 pm, maybe so but they are well made and beautifully done, unlike our local copies that are so horribly and cheaply done.

      Delete
    7. 4:55 There is no "maybe". In fact they really are. You can even ask their original creators. And based on some comments here, ok lang pala na mangopya ang ibang bansa, pero wag lang ang Pinas. Ok lang pala mangopya ang Hollywood sa mga Japanese, French, Italian, Hispanic products. You even judge the show as cheap eh, hindi pa nga pinapalabas sa tv. That's what you call Biased thinking.

      Delete
  22. I can't get over that costume! His cheeks are about to pop out of that mask! Walang walang muscles man lang or anything. No wonder ganyan ang costume. To make his body look more muscular and stronger.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Bakit nung nagamit yung salitang "sanggre" lakas niyo makaputak na ginaya daw ng ABS pero eto harap harapan na panggaya kay Thor tas galit pa kayo nung sinasabi na ginagaya niyo? Double standard at its finest.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. @Anon 5:03 Jumping on the bandwagon is different from accusing that is not true.

      Delete
  24. Hay ilabas na kasi! Excited na kami sa Victor Magtanggol!
    Mga nega, salamat sa dagdag na ingay 😁

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Korak! At sa dagdag na ratings. Siempre manonood sila para may mabash LOL.

      Delete
  25. Kabaduyan at its finest.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 9:44 Not really. Hater ka lang talaga.

      Delete
    2. 10:06 baduy ka rin nakakasuka ka

      Delete
    3. 944: tama si 1006. hater ka talaga.

      Delete
  26. Liked the explanation but not the costume. Jusme.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Tama naman si Miss Annette. Haha. Feeling ko lang di smart move na gumawa ng ganitong adaptations when you have other versions na sobrang maganda (like in this case nga, Thor). So lagi ma-cocompare and ang hirap lumamang or pumantay man lang di ba. I hope GMA would rather stick with their original stories kasi it worked out namn like My Husband Lover.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Basta nasa public domain, anyone can make film about it. Yung works ni Shakespeare, Jane Austen etc. Iibahin lang ang treatment. Pwede namang i-adapt ang story ni Thor sa Phil. setting pero sana iniba ang costume.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thor in Norse mythology has a hammer, belt and iron gloves. Pag tinaggal yun, parang sinabi na rin na kalbuhin si Rapunzel.

      Delete
  29. lol mga bitter! mag amplaya kau wapakels kami, basta excited na sa victor magtanggol and alden as a lead star sobrang nakakahappy and fyi lang magaling ang gma pagdating sa teleserye noh!

    ReplyDelete
  30. No copyright violation but is a ripoff. Bakit ngayon nila "naisip" yung serye kung kelan sikat na si Thor.
    Same with Robinhood.

    Sayang ang talent ni Alden when he could do award winning specials.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Ang masagwa yung nagtext talaga sa Marvel Phils. Grabe yung crab mentality gusto talaga pabagsakin yung show. Sulsulero And super threatened kay Alden

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. aldub_inspires daw siya pero trying to destroy the al in aldub. marami namang maayos mag-isip at mag behave sa kanila. pero sadly, mayroon din sa kanila na bashers ni alden.

      Delete
  32. Dapat kasi drums nalang hawak niya para Victor Magtambol na lang ang title para wala na ginaya issue.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Walk the talk muna Ms Annette. Andami mong pinangako at sinabi..anyare mumsh? The secret plan, surprisingly fell short of the expectations/hype. Teaser pa lang flop na..costume, computer graphics, pinaghandaan. NOT! Hype kayo!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And your comment made me feel dizzy. Hindi naman po bawal magtagalog.

      Delete
  34. Even Marvel has deliberately ripped off a lot of their characters from DC:
    1. Thanos from Darkseid (because they couldn't come up with a villain as powerful and angas him)
    2. Deadpool is a straight up copy of Deathstroke
    3. Quicksilver from The Flash
    3. Dr. Strange from Dr. Fate
    4. Hawkeye from Green Arrow

    I can go on and on and on and on. But this isn't to say that DC hasn't done the same thing too. Point is, even both of these comic book giants are no stranger to "taking inspiration" from the things around them. Kahit na Marvel catches wind of Victor Magtanggol, they won't do anything because: a) they are not bothered as they're too busy counting their billions and b) they are GUILTY of doing the EXACT SAME THING. Besides, Annette Gozon's explanation about how Victor Magtanggol can wield Mjolnir is accurate because anybody apart from Thor can use it is as long they are worthy. In fact, in the DC-Marvel crossover, Wonder Woman and Superman were able to use Mjolnir. In addition, another fictional mortal character by the name Eric Masterson, aka Thunderstrike, was given Mjolnir and became a superhero as well. But at the end of the day, if the premise of the show's story will draw from the Norse mythology more than anything, all other arguments are invalid because, as Annette has said, the Norse mythology is public domain and anyone can interpret it however they wish to. Kaya please, tama na ang kuda ng copyright ek-ek in this case, lalo na kung di niyo naman alam 'yung mga pinagsasasabi niyo.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Don’t make excuses. Copya is a copya. Period.

      Delete
    2. 4:42 ....and ignorant is ignorant, we can't really make excuses.

      Delete
    3. LOL DOUBLE STANDARDS PALA, hindi double-sided hahaha my bad

      Delete
    4. HAHAHAHAHAHAHA! Mema na lang na walang laman, anon 4:42? Is that all you got? Or kinulang ka sa comprehension kaya hindi mo nakuha 'yung gist ng comment ko? I wasn't even making excuses. I was just educating everyone here na hindi familiar sa gawain ng comic book giants. Kasi 'di ba, yung mga nagmamarunong dito puro, "kakahiya Pilipinas blah blah blah". Eh what about Marvel itself? Malinis ba si Marvel sa gawain na 'yan? Or porke ba American company it's okay? Is that it, they can do no wrong? Huwag double-standards at ignorante, teh, para hindi mahina 'yung argument mo.

      Delete
  35. That’s pinas for you, ang daming fake.......hahaha.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Basta ako excited na ako sa Victor Magtanggol. Team abroad here

    ReplyDelete

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...