12:10 I REMEMBER SEEING HER AND HER BROTHER AND LOLA (CHARLENE'S MOM) AT THE PICC WHEN CATS WAS SHOWN IN MANILA. THEY ATE PALABOK SO FAST AND THEN WENT INSIDE. THEY EACH HAD A YAYA TAPOS THE LOLA WAS DONYANG DONYA AND HINDI SWEET SA KANILA.
Maganda ang boses. Dami lang flats. Soon, she will learn proper vocal placement para di mabilis mapagod ang lalamunan nya at mamaos. Yan ang challenge ng musical actors. Dapat buga ang boses pero unstressed dapat amg throat para di. Masira ang vocal cords.
She can sing but not really a good one. I tried listening hoping na mali sinasabi ng ibang nang judge sa kanya. Unfortunately, was not so impressed lalo na't may twang pa ang tagalog nya. They could've hired a better lead character before siya sinabak sa lead role 😌
12:14 She didn’t choose to be born to the parents she was born to. Nepo na hardworking and napaka-humble. Alangan naman she says no to offers para lang sumaya ka! Get over yourself.
Gets naman. Ang sheltered ng twins and wala pa masyadong life experiences na mabigat, which is ideal. Sanaol. Everyone should be so lucky na wala pa masyadong feels at 20+.
1:48am e kung ganon at factor pala siya sa performance at portrayal niya ng character, edi sana di na lang siya cinonsider para sa role noh. Ang dami daming magagaling sa philippine theater no
Maganda naman ung pagkanta. Ung diction lang syempre susyal pa din pero mukha namang may speech coach sya??? Kasi kung wala feeling ko mas malala pa ung twang nya.
Annie Batungbakal can’t be represented by someone who looks like her, acts and talks like her, or sings like her. It does not match at all. Siguro pang princess in distress pwede siya.
The twins both studied abroad. U.K. and Spain pa. May natapos naman. Bakit nag pipilit mag artista. Wala bang makitang mas related sa mga tinapos nilang courses ang kambal na ito? Sayang ang pinag aralan sa ibang bansa pa.
Business course nila so for sure nag-iipon lng yang 2 ng sariling pera then magput up na ng sariling business. Baka mas prefer lang talaga nila ng sarili nilang capital.
More practice and more hasa pa sana before siya nilagay sa lead role. Cz parang di ko na feel yung emotions nya sa pgkanta. But hey, i trust that those people who put her there will help her improve more. Help her speak tagalog fluently without accent and not to be conscious sa crowd and of her singing kasi halata eh.
Also, you can perhaps constructively criticize her to improve not give a free pass coz cz anak cya ng big celebrities.
Girl, lahat ng sinabi mo ay sinabi din ng karamihan dito so bakit may pa "you can perhaps constructively criticize her" kang nalalaman? Sa tingin mo ikaw lang ang nakapagbigay ng constructive criticism dito?
May times naman na hindi questionable ang pag cast sa nepo kid sa theater like si KC Conception sa Little Mermaid and Karylle sa West Side Story. They can act and sing and lets face it, nakakatulong talaga pangalan nila panghatak. Eto kulang pa sa practice.
Agree kay Kim M..masang masa ang dating ,which has been proven sa mga roles nya sa teleserye..And her voice...Award-winning ang voice and sanay na sa stage plays..The aura,Pinay na Pinay .BATUNGBAKAL
She is not bad but not good enough para isabak sa title role sa isang malaking musical sa teatro. Di porke may pangalan ka, pwede na. Madami pa syang dapat matutunan. She is not a Karylle.
1:32 Jusko ganyan din naman dati si Karylle. Give Atasha time. Although agree ako na di sana lead role agad. Sana major supporting role lang (kung gusto nilang mataas billing nya panghatak ng audience) ganun.
Among all industries, theater is the one where nepo babies really show their true colors because there's nowhere to hide lol you sing live, dance live, act live. I really can't fathom why they'd choose someone like her for this role. I get that she has name recall, but we have a lot of other mainstream actors who could (and have already proven to) pull it off a lot better and may even have bigger or around the same fanbase (Julie Ann, Zephanie, etc.)
Kung like repertory philippines or sandbox or 9works theatrical or theater group asia or barefoot collab ang theater company na nag produce, pwede pa. Kasi ayon mga alta at conyo theater kids talaga market non. Kaso yung newpprt is very masa e
Kasi ayun nga. Sa pinas na nga lumaki e kahit sa loob ng bahay, sa school (international school sila) kahit sa environment and circles, english sila kausapin.
She’s good but not that great to portray Annie Batungbakal. The singing is so-so. Mas marami pang mas magaling mag perform for sure. Hirap nga mag Tagalog eh born and raised sa Pinas. Mas magaling pa nga siguro tagalog ko kahit bisaya ako hahhaha…
.jpg)
Pati pagkanta ng tagalog may twang 👎
ReplyDeleteYou mean like the way you speak English na may punto na mas di kaaya-aya?
DeleteNgeh wala sa tono si Ateng. Palakasan na lang talaga ng loob eh. More practice pa. Lalo na yan siya bida diyan. Kung San San napupunta yun tono
Delete12:10 I REMEMBER SEEING HER AND HER BROTHER AND LOLA (CHARLENE'S MOM) AT THE PICC WHEN CATS WAS SHOWN IN MANILA. THEY ATE PALABOK SO FAST AND THEN WENT INSIDE. THEY EACH HAD A YAYA TAPOS THE LOLA WAS DONYANG DONYA AND HINDI SWEET SA KANILA.
DeleteAkala ko ako lang nakapansin. Yung huling linya may twang.
DeleteMaganda ang boses. Dami lang flats. Soon, she will learn proper vocal placement para di mabilis mapagod ang lalamunan nya at mamaos. Yan ang challenge ng musical actors. Dapat buga ang boses pero unstressed dapat amg throat para di. Masira ang vocal cords.
ReplyDeleteHindi maganda ang boses
DeleteMaganda boses.
DeleteMay boses naman kaya lang yong boses na aral. Kailangan with feeling, matutunan nya din yan in the long run.
DeleteMagaling naman, haters lang kayo talaga.
DeleteShe can sing but not really a good one. I tried listening hoping na mali sinasabi ng ibang nang judge sa kanya. Unfortunately, was not so impressed lalo na't may twang pa ang tagalog nya. They could've hired a better lead character before siya sinabak sa lead role 😌
Deletebalikan natin ‘to pag diretso na ang dilang managalog. ✌️for now, nepo privilege all the way.
ReplyDelete12:14 She didn’t choose to be born to the parents she was born to. Nepo na hardworking and napaka-humble. Alangan naman she says no to offers para lang sumaya ka! Get over yourself.
DeleteAgree, sorry kse mas may deserving for that role. Even itsura nya di bagay sa kanya yung ayos etc.
Deletei second that.
Deletekorek, dapat aralin muna and maging fluent sa tagalog for ph career. andaming may talent na na-overlooked para sa mga nepo babies na to
DeleteMej kulang pa ng feels.
ReplyDeleteGets naman. Ang sheltered ng twins and wala pa masyadong life experiences na mabigat, which is ideal. Sanaol. Everyone should be so lucky na wala pa masyadong feels at 20+.
Delete1:48am e kung ganon at factor pala siya sa performance at portrayal niya ng character, edi sana di na lang siya cinonsider para sa role noh. Ang dami daming magagaling sa philippine theater no
DeleteYung parang pinakanta mo ng tagalog si Erika Fife at Vanessa Del Bianco
ReplyDeleteHahaha jusko nahahalata edad natin isama mo pa si Donita Rose haha
DeleteBeh sumakit likod ko bigla sa comment ko. Huhu.
Deletehello batchmates lol
Delete😂😂😂😂..keri lng yan...
DeleteTeh kung sino ka man pinasaya mo umaga ko! hahaha @12:17am
DeleteGinising mo ang natutulog ko mga muscle inday
DeleteAno nga ba itsu ni erika fife nakalimutan ko na
Si vanessa alam ko parang mala anne curtis ang boses non
Isali mo na din si janette mcbride haha
DeleteHa....ha..ha.. kapanahunan ko to. Baluktot mag-tagalog. :)
DeleteSino si Erica Fife?
DeleteShe sounds like Anne Curtis
ReplyDeleteOut of tune. Isinisigaw pa imbes na kumanta. Dapat sa experienced theatre artist napunta yung role hindi sa kanya.
ReplyDeleteAgree
Delete12:11 TRUE. OKAY NAMAN KUNG NEPO BABY ANG MAKAKUHA KUNG SUPER TALENTED BUT NOT IN HER CASE.
DeleteSeryoso ba toh? Maluh peet nah? Singing waley acting hilaw pati pronunciation sablay.
ReplyDeleteIn fairness maganda naman boses nya pero there's something off sa way ng pagkanta nya, parang pasigaw or parang kulang ng emotions.
ReplyDeleteKaya nga.need further training..Bakit bida agad..
DeletePilit pagkanta niya. Walang dating. Kahit dancing overrated. Pero benta tickets dahil nepo
DeleteFeeling ko si Aga at Charlene ang nagtraining sa kanya sa pagkanta kaya ganyan ang resulta
ReplyDeleteHahahahahaha natawa talaga ako so comment mo 12:26, thank you for putting a smile on my face.
DeleteHayup tawang tawa ako. HAHAHA!
DeleteParang may bahid ng katotohanan hahahaha
DeleteKaloka
DeleteSana mabasa nga nila eto para ma -realize nila what they have done to this poor girl..
DeleteMaganda naman ung pagkanta. Ung diction lang syempre susyal pa din pero mukha namang may speech coach sya??? Kasi kung wala feeling ko mas malala pa ung twang nya.
ReplyDeleteTeh bakit kasi pinipilit syang bigyan ng pangmasa na role eh di naman nya keri
DeleteKailangan ba ang Annie Batungbakal ang gaganap pulubi or squatter area nakatira?
Delete7:26 teh masa lang. Masa PERO HINDI CONYO O ALTA. This is acting so BELIEVABLE SANA DAPAT
DeleteAnnie Batungbakal can’t be represented by someone who looks like her, acts and talks like her, or sings like her. It does not match at all. Siguro pang princess in distress pwede siya.
DeleteKung maka comment naman ang iba dito akala mo ang gagaling kumanta at mga expert
ReplyDeleteYou do not have to be an music expert para malaman na di talaga ok ang singing niya
Delete1:21 hindi nga ako masyadong magaling kumanta kaya di ako nag audition lol, sana ganun din siya.
DeleteShe can sing. It's a skill that needs constant practise so... keep doing it girl
ReplyDeletepractise?????
DeleteI actually like her voice. Sophisticated. It has grit and promise.
ReplyDeleteAs long as she's cute, penoys will gladly support her :D :D :D
ReplyDeleteTH
ReplyDeleteay ang cute ng kanta lol
ReplyDeleteAng awkward nya pakinggan. She should stick to dancing and hosting.
ReplyDeletepinipilit na maging masa
ReplyDeleteThe twins both studied abroad. U.K. and Spain pa. May natapos naman. Bakit nag pipilit mag artista. Wala bang makitang mas related sa mga tinapos nilang courses ang kambal na ito? Sayang ang pinag aralan sa ibang bansa pa.
DeleteBusiness course nila so for sure nag-iipon lng yang 2 ng sariling pera then magput up na ng sariling business. Baka mas prefer lang talaga nila ng sarili nilang capital.
Deleteso hard to get into theater tlg pag walang connections minsan. She's lucky
ReplyDeleteMore of well-connected,than Lucky..
Deletewow ang harsh ng comsec. kinula, nilabhan, binanlawan at sinampay si Atasha. i thought it wasn't worse at all but it could be better
ReplyDeleteanong ginagawa ng anak ni aga at charlene 😂😂😂
ReplyDeleteEto na Yun? And she got the role...
ReplyDeletekala cguro cute pakinggan ang may slang na tagalog, ang sagwa.. sobrang TH in all levels
ReplyDeleteDami comment sa FB that the role should have been given to Maris Racal instead..
ReplyDeleteYes, magaling na umarte, magaling pang kumanta si Maris. So natural...
Delete5:47 ngayon ko lang din naalala si Maris. Yeah, she is fit for the role sana. alexa I din
Deletemay boses pala si atashya, ok yan, madedevelop pa yan
ReplyDeletenanalaytay sa dugo nya ang pagiging talented na artist way to go atasha 👏👏👏
ReplyDeleteMay boses namam sya. Pero kulang pa sa technique at halatang kabado. Yun nga lang may twang parin talaga.
ReplyDeleteSiguro kung nineties keri pa yung ganyang mediocrity pero my gosh 2026 na
ReplyDeleteOo nga lakas loob magkkanta nina gelli carmina ruffa aiko noon
DeleteKaloka
Im sure mas payat pa siya sa personal
ReplyDeleteMore practice and more hasa pa sana before siya nilagay sa lead role. Cz parang di ko na feel yung emotions nya sa pgkanta. But hey, i trust that those people who put her there will help her improve more. Help her speak tagalog fluently without accent and not to be conscious sa crowd and of her singing kasi halata eh.
ReplyDeleteAlso, you can perhaps constructively criticize her to improve not give a free pass coz cz anak cya ng big celebrities.
Girl, lahat ng sinabi mo ay sinabi din ng karamihan dito so bakit may pa "you can perhaps constructively criticize her" kang nalalaman? Sa tingin mo ikaw lang ang nakapagbigay ng constructive criticism dito?
DeleteMay times naman na hindi questionable ang pag cast sa nepo kid sa theater like si KC Conception sa Little Mermaid and Karylle sa West Side Story. They can act and sing and lets face it, nakakatulong talaga pangalan nila panghatak. Eto kulang pa sa practice.
ReplyDeleteMas bagay kay Rita Daniela to or Julie Ann or Kai or Kim M or... ang haba ng listahan. Andaming singers.
ReplyDeleteAgree kay Kim M..masang masa ang dating ,which has been proven sa mga roles nya sa teleserye..And her voice...Award-winning ang voice and sanay na sa stage plays..The aura,Pinay na Pinay .BATUNGBAKAL
DeleteYes kay Kim Molina, legit talented.
DeleteParang kumakanta lang sa karaoke. Get a singing coach if you are seriously considering a singing career.
ReplyDeleteShe is not bad but not good enough para isabak sa title role sa isang malaking musical sa teatro. Di porke may pangalan ka, pwede na. Madami pa syang dapat matutunan. She is not a Karylle.
ReplyDelete1:32 Jusko ganyan din naman dati si Karylle. Give Atasha time. Although agree ako na di sana lead role agad. Sana major supporting role lang (kung gusto nilang mataas billing nya panghatak ng audience) ganun.
DeleteAmong all industries, theater is the one where nepo babies really show their true colors because there's nowhere to hide lol you sing live, dance live, act live. I really can't fathom why they'd choose someone like her for this role. I get that she has name recall, but we have a lot of other mainstream actors who could (and have already proven to) pull it off a lot better and may even have bigger or around the same fanbase (Julie Ann, Zephanie, etc.)
ReplyDeleteAng nipis na nya tingnan. Ok na yung katawan nya dati, she looked healthy.
ReplyDeleteTita Leah could never!
ReplyDeleteOk, i really find Atasha very pretty. But in this video clip - the hair, camera angel, medyo ai-ai hawig nya
ReplyDeleteWe all know why she got chosen. And it's not because she can sing like Lea Salonga. My question is - may hatak ba talaga sya to sell tickets?
ReplyDeleteKung like repertory philippines or sandbox or 9works theatrical or theater group asia or barefoot collab ang theater company na nag produce, pwede pa. Kasi ayon mga alta at conyo theater kids talaga market non. Kaso yung newpprt is very masa e
DeleteBakit ganun? Sa pinas naman lumaki bakit may twang at di marunong mag straight tagalog?
ReplyDeleteKasi ayun nga. Sa pinas na nga lumaki e kahit sa loob ng bahay, sa school (international school sila) kahit sa environment and circles, english sila kausapin.
DeleteMatatas pa magtagalog mga anak ko na dito sa US pinanganak. Eh kasi sa atin pag english with twang, yamanin di ba. Mayaman din naman sila talaga.
DeleteIt’s a bit sad kasi ang daming mas promising talents sana na mas fit for the Annie Batungbakal role.
ReplyDeleteJusko naman surname pa lang ng karakter dapat pinay na pinay. Bat naman ganyan! I mean no offense but they could have casted better.
maimai entrata couldve been a better choice
ReplyDeleteAtasha is talented but di ba jack of all trades master of none ika nga. She can dance but not gracefully she can sing pero she is not a singer.
In a musical db dapat singers talaga dancing pwede remedyohan.
Hindi bagay ang role as Annie B, di kasi siya pang-masa. Nakakanta naman pero parang hirap na hirap siya dito.
ReplyDeleteShe’s good but not that great to portray Annie Batungbakal. The singing is so-so. Mas marami pang mas magaling mag perform for sure. Hirap nga mag Tagalog eh born and raised sa Pinas. Mas magaling pa nga siguro tagalog ko kahit bisaya ako hahhaha…
ReplyDelete