Monday, January 26, 2015

FB Scoop: Vet Who Injected Pregnant Dog with Anti Poison Airs His Side



Images courtesy of Facebook: Leonardo Esteleydes

72 comments:

  1. Damage control baka matanggalan ng lisensya.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's not damage control if he's airing his side. Everyone has a right to be heard. Hindi lahat ng dehado, tama. Minsan ang akusado pa ang lumalabas ng nagsasabi ng totoo.

      Delete
    2. Tama anon 12:14

      Delete
    3. Pero bakit hindi naniwala si dr.doods na preggy yung aso? What if yun ang dahilan kaya nahihirapan yung dog? Malinaw na sinabi din ni dr.doods na he found no sign of pregnancy ayon sa check niya sa dog…

      Delete
    4. Sa tao, kapag may problem sa atay, bumababa ang production ng albumin (protein) kaya namamaga at lumalaki ang tiyan. It's the same for dogs. Another vet could have misdiagnosed the dog of being pregnant. Or pwede rin namang pregnant siya AND may sakit sa liver. Kawawa ang dog. Pero sana considerate ang mga tao at padaanin sa proper channels ang mga problema at di sina-subject lahat sa trial by social media.

      Delete
    5. Ginagawa na kasing sumbungan bg bayan ang FP sa mga establishments. Syempre yung inaakusahan marerebut through social media dahil they were all judged by the netizens. Hindi iti damage control but he's waiving for his rights too. THERE'S ALWAYS TWO SIDE OF A STORY. They have their faults. The vet may have misdiagnosed the dog while the owner didn't took care of her pet. Especially she already knew/predicted that her pet is pregnant before bringing to the vet. I am just sad because a helpless creature had passed away.

      Delete
    6. His integrity as a vet was compromised. Tama lang that he aired his side on social media, na nagjudge agad agad sa kanya. Well hintayin na lang natin kung may masasagot pa yung dog owner regarding this.

      Delete
  2. OMG. Mahirap kasi yung nagpopost lang dito sa social media basta basta. Dapat dalhin yan aa korte kung saan may mga experts din na titingin sa result ng autopsy

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mga tao talaga, lahat na lang dinadaan sa social media. From kilay, to parlor to vet. Wag mashadong OA sa pag gamit ng social media. nakakasira kayo ng pangalan ng tao.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Trial by publicity ang kayang gawin. Kung totoo ang sinasabi nya, bakit di niya to dalhin sa korte? Have the license of this doctor revoked? Pathetic.

      Delete
    2. Talaga? me nakukulong ba sa medical malpractise dito sa pilipinas? mas pathetic ka.

      Delete
    3. Kung hindi po makukulong, lisensya po ang tinatanggal.

      Delete
  4. So dr. Doods, liar yung isang dr. Na nagsabi after checking na buntis and aso? Hala ka.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, he mentioned naman na if ever nga na preggy yung dog, di naman nakakamatay yung ininject nya na gamot, sabi pa nya ginagamit pa daw yun as anesthesia for cs ng dogs. Lets hear nalang yung side ng animal experts sa court kung sakaling dalhin sa korte ito

      Delete
    2. hindi naman nya sinabi na hindi buntis, sinasabi nya na the medicine couldnt have taken effect immediately para maconclude na yun ang kinamatay.

      lahat na lang kasi sinosocial media

      Delete
    3. @12:25 @12:23 hindi ba kayo nagbasa? O hindi niyo naintindihan? Sinabi ni dr. Doods na there is no sign of pregnancy! Pero iniinsist nung me ari na buntis nga kasi!

      Delete
    4. Kung malapit n mamatay ang pasyente dapat na perform ang emergency cs para ma save man lang ang puppies pero ininsist nga nya na walang signs of pregnancy kaya may mali pa rin siya.

      Delete
    5. 1.41. Hindi nga daw pwede dahil nga na sa kritical na condition 'yong aso. Kung sakaling ginawa niya yan at namatay yong aso. Sa palagay mo hindi siya mababaliktad? Sa case nga na ito, nabaliktad na siya eh? Isip-isip din.

      Delete
    6. Basa basa ulit. Sabi nya sa bandang dulo kung may pagkakamali daw sya eh yun yung hindi nya eksaktong nadiagnosed na buntis pero wala naman daw yung kinalaman para mamatay yung aso. Saaad :(

      Delete
    7. Due to the critical condition ng dog, syempre dapat yung first aid agad, sabi naman ng vet, based on his statement, he made visual check sa dog kung preggers or hindi, maybe, just maybe he was also thinking to further test the dog kundi nga lang namatay.

      Delete
    8. Emergency cs sa asong papatay na? I doubt na mabubuhay baby nun.

      Delete
    9. for anon 2:27

      yes nandun na tayo sa kritical na condition ng aso.. sabihin na natin na namatay at hindi na umabot... kung diniclare niya lang na buntis ang aso edi sana nagperform ng CS para masave yung puppies? and of course pano babaliktad dahil alam ko bago iCS ang aso my pipirmahan poh na waiver! ikaw poh hindi nagiisip.. kung tama ang diagnosed ng vet sa una palang at hindi lason ang kanyang conclusion maybe he can save the puppies or maybe kasama ang mother... Isip-isip din

      Delete
    10. anon 1:15 PM

      ayon sa nabasa ko sa statement nilang dalawa walang first aid na nangyari ang alam ko poh sa emergency SOP poh ang first aid like dextrose poh.. at sabi poh ng owner ay buntis ang aso so bakit hindi naniwala si Doc Doods? dahil sa visual check niya? and kung further test poh ang hinahanap niyo hindi na poh emergency tawag dun. kaya nga EMERGENCY diba may mali talaga ang vet sa una palang

      Delete
  5. Sana nga matanggal talaga license nitong Dr.Doods dog-killer! Halatang puro PALUSOT!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. How do you know? Do you even have enough knowledge to support your claim?

      Delete
    2. Ikaw yung halatang aso!
      -snoopy

      Delete
    3. @12:35 Sumilip at nag comment ka rin pala dito Dr.Doods!

      Delete
    4. Conclude agad kulang pa nga ebidensya? Wag ganun!

      Delete
    5. 2:14 sumama ka dun kay 12:20. Parehas kayong utak talangka.

      Delete
    6. try mo kasi magbasa mabuti anon 2:14AM. kain ka narin kamote haha

      Delete
    7. Ang bilis magjudge kasi. Un may-ari naman dapat kasuhan na lng nya. Huwag sa social media magreklamo

      Delete
  6. Ayon naman pala. Baka naman talagang naghihingalo na yung aso when he was brought to the vet. Kahit tao man dalhin sa emergency room, despite all the qualified doctors around, pag ang condisyon malala na at beyond hope, there is no guarantee of survival.

    -Frogilita dela Cruz

    ReplyDelete
    Replies

    1. tsaka kung itry pa i-CS yung dog sa tingin ba nung owner makakasurvive 100% yung mga puppies?

      Delete
  7. Based on his statement, I think he's an incompetent doctor. Tingin ko siya ang my mali.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. how can you say that? are you a medical examiner or an expert? #justcurious

      Delete
    2. Tulog na dr doodz

      Delete
    3. Anon 12:23 Nag judge ka agad based sa kwento dito sa fp ng namatayan ng aso. One sided kang tao kalurkey ka!

      Delete
    4. 12:23 Ikaw ba ang presidente ng asosasyon ng mga vet for you to conclude that? Beats me if you even know the technical terms used. Tsk Tsk.

      Delete
    5. At Anon 10:02 AM, sabihin mo kumain si 12:23 ng kamote sawsaw sa iodized salt, LOL.

      Delete
  8. hindi naman lahat ng reklamo sa social media credible...syempre some would leave out other details para mas kaawaan...and also there are always two sides to every story...reputation nya nakasalalay dyan natural sasagot yan tawagin mo mang damage control karapatan nya yan...kung sa korte nga innocent until proven guilty pero sa social media guilty until proven innocent ang labas...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tama ka dyan. At maraming tao mas kakampi sa dehado w/o knowing the whole story.

      Delete
  9. Minsan naman talaga may mga clients kung kelan malala na ang kondisyon ang aso nila that's the only time they will rush them
    To the nearest vet clinic. Pag na check na sila usually the vet will try the best to cure kung Hinde na kaya... Namamatay sila. Parang tao din kasi mga aso... :) they need a annaul check up like vaccination/ anti rabies and etc.. Responsibility yan. Kaya the next time makita niyo aso niya may sakit wag na antayin lumala pa.... Kaya ang consequences niyo is you will end up paying a lot or mamatay ang aso niyo di Oras.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Totoo yan! Baka di lang tanggap ng namatayan na namatay yung aso nya kaya sinisisi nya yung vet na pinag dalan nya.

      Delete
    2. True. As dogs age, prone na din sa mga malalang sakit just like humans.

      Delete
    3. True. Minsan din kasi as pet owners may tendency tayong magmarunong.

      Delete
  10. Yun naman pala. Kaya dapat wag tayo nagjujudge or nagbibigay ng opinion hanggat di natin nadidinig both sides.. if the second clinic will back up the complainant's testimony and address the pregnancy issue, with evidences. e baka maniwala pa ko ke girl. But as of now mas malinaw pahayag ni doc. I still feel sorry and sad about the death of the dog dont get me wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Last 2 minutes na siguro nung dinala niya ang aso sa Vet. Well, you cannot blame the doctor, the fact that hindi na kinaya ng aso mo. Oh well.

    ReplyDelete
  12. As a helping professional, I'd always err on the side of caution. That's what's ethical. It sounds like the doctor has been able to explain his rationale for the intervention he did. I'm not sure though if he educated the dog's owner of the possible outcome of his treatment so that the dog owner would be able to make a truly informed decision.

    If the doctor was cautious enough in providing treatment, given the dog's delicate situation and if the dog owner was informed of the pros and cons of the treatment and gave th doctor the green light to proceed with it, then the doctor would not be at fault and this could just be a case of MISPLACED GRIEF on the part of the dog owner.
    Just my two cents.

    ReplyDelete
  13. It was too late for the dog :( di naman completely kasalanan ng vet. We all look for people, things and situations to blame kapag emotional pero unfair sa vet dahil he did his job. Condolence sa family nung dog..

    ReplyDelete
  14. yan ang hirap eh. porke namatayan ng alaga isisisi sa beterenaryo. hindi dyos mga yan tao din sila. kaya namatay aso mo napabayaan ng mga nagaalaga

    ReplyDelete
  15. I'm not here to defend the Vet, but, according to the woman, her dog is "vomiting and seizures" as she tries to give birth. As far as I know, laboring dogs doesn't throw up at all. Then, the vet added here that the dog is dehydrated and yellowish (gums and tongue). There must be already wrong with the dog and must not be giving birth at all, instead, I assume that she have ate something not good for dogs. The brother of the owner brought the dog too late since she is yellowish, yellowish gums and tongue is already critical state since she have lost too much red blood cells.

    Does the owner know when her dog is about to give birth? the signs? if not, then, I can't blame the Vet, he seems to did the best he could have done to save the dog, but the brother brought her too late.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. josko naman sa english mo, 'te. mag tagalog ka na lang kung simpleng subject-verb agreement di mo kayang iconstruct ng maayos.

      Delete
  16. Sa susunod, bago mag comment, alamin ang buo at totoong story. Kung ako kay Dr. Doods, I will file a libel case. Nakakasira ng reputation yung ginawa ng may ari ng aso. Be responsible. File a case, do not use media para makaganti. Baka sa yo pa bumalik ang problemang inumpisahan mo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. OO nga sa susunod bago ka din magcomment alamin mo din ang totoong story :) edi bumalik din sayo yung sinabi mo :) im assuming na alam mo yung totoong story? are you present that time poh ba?

      Delete
  17. I want to give this Doc Doods the benefit of the doubt, but one thing's for sure - Doc Ara of Animal House Alabang (yung nag-entertain sa pet owner for x-ray) is a credible vet. She's been the vet of my dogs for the past 4 years and I feel her genuine love and concern for my dogs whenever we see her for appointments (at sa dami ng mga patients niya, she still knows all my dogs by their names), plus my dogs love her back too. Add the fact that she entertained the owners despite being an unusual case also shows her compassion as a vet.

    I just find it unfair na sinabi nung Doc Doods na kahit sinong vet hindi gagawin yung CS kasi critical na yung condition nung aso. Para kasing he's implying na hindi credible yung sinabi ni Doc Ara sa owner. The dog was already dead when it was brought to Animal House, but the x-ray proved that the dog was pregnant. The owner probably left out some details when they asked for an xray, kaya nasabi ni Doc Ara na the dog and her puppies could have been saved if a CS was performed.

    I feel bad that the dog died, but I wish the people directly involved settle this privately instead. Madadamay pa yung ibang taong ginagawa ng maayos yung trabaho nila. May justice be served to whomever is telling the truth.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I feel sorry for what happened dun sa dog. Sure Dr. Ana is good vet, but of course she may have said that CS could have done but she wasn't the one who saw and check the dog during the most critical condition of the dog. Based on the statement of Doc Doods, he cannot perform CS due to the condition of the dog. Malamang that time the dog will not endure the operation if ever. I believe Doc Doods wants to stabilize the condition of the dog first before proceeding to next steps. #justmy2cents

      Delete
    2. Like I said earlier, I want to give Doc Doods the benefit of the doubt. I would like to believe that he had good intentions with what he did. But one thing that really bothers me was that despite being told by the owner/s that the dog was pregnant, he insisted that it wasn't just because his visual checks made him arrive at that conclusion :(

      I mean, for an emergency case like that at such an ungodly hour, a little extra caution wouldn't hurt. By insisting that the dog was not pregnant based simply on visual checks was a little careless (lalo na first time patient yung aso sa clinic niya), wouldn't you agree?

      For the owner/s' part naman, I find it fishy that their dog's condition became that bad in such a short span. Bakit parang biglaan lang nangyari? A pregnant dog, like pregnant humans, must have regular checkups during pregnancy. I just don't understand how the dog went from normal to critical just because she started her labor. I'm not a vet, so I'm not sure if those kinds of special cases really happen (baka nagkaron ng complication yun pregnancy?), pero kung may sakit na talaga yung dog as Doc Doods claims (since sabi niya critical na daw nung dinala sa kanya), then that just means nagkaron din ng lapse sa part ng owners. At kung talagang sa Animal House sila nagpapatingin, how come they didn't know na 24hrs yung Animal House Makati branch? :/

      Delete
  18. sa mga nagsasabi na bakit sa social media nagrereklamo yung iba at hindi sa korte, REALLY? Gaano ba katagal bago magkaron ng result dito? Kung sa tao nga walang medical malpractice na nakukulong dito sa alagang hayop pa? Sa media naman, MAY BAYAD PO. Nung nagkaron ng mga squatters na tumira sa kalsada namin, isang buong street ang tinirhan, sa Bayan Patrol kami nagtweet para kumilos yung Brgy. Captain namin para mapaalis sa kalye, nasolve dahil sa social media. Thank you FP sa pag publish ng mga ganitong reklamo :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. madaling manira pero kung may sapat kang ebidensya or grounds ay malalaman sa korte. madaling manisi ng iba kesa manisi ng sarili.

      Delete
  19. Bukas kaya ngayong umaga yung clinic ng doktor? O puyat sya sa kakasagot dito?

    ReplyDelete
  20. it's always easier to point a finger than accept your own fault

    ReplyDelete
  21. My two cents worth, pag medical issues mahirap patunayan na may pagkakamali ang isang doktor unless obvious ang pagkakamali. It is irresponsible for the other doctor to say that a CS would have saved the puppies ang its mother. From what I know, di ka pwedeng magbigay ng medical opinion kung di naman nya mismo na diagnose ang aso whle alive. On the other hand, I do not understand why Dr Doods were not able to detect that the dog was indeed pregnant.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. exactly my thoughts.

      Delete
    2. Yes, bakit hindi nadetect ng mismong vet na pregnant ang dog?? and sinabi naman ng owner na buntis ang aso? dun palang ata may malaking difference na

      Delete
    3. I never said that a CS could have saved the dog and her puppies. As I told the owner, I have no way of knowing since I was not the one who initially checked on her dog. It really is unfair for Dr. Doods, as well as for Animal House, when she made a statement that did not come from us.

      Delete
  22. Hindi nadetect ni dr doodz na buntis (kung buntis nga) yung aso kaseh malala na nung dalhin sa kanya. Ang may pagkukulang dito eh yung may ari. Bakit pa kase nag aalaga ng aso hindi naman pala kaya g ipacheck up.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. sir naniniwala ka ba talaga na critical na ung aso nung dinala? wala pong patunay si DOC DOODS na critical na ang aso! at panong hindi kaya ipacheckup ang aso kita mo naman poh sa breed ng aso diba? aso palang mamahalin na pacheckup pa kaya? hindi mo alam sinasabi mo ser ANON 5:01 PM

      Delete
  23. ang mahirap sa may-ari kung kelan papatay na ang aso ay saka dadalhin sa vet at pag namatay ay saka isisisi sa vet. kung talagang tama ang claim ng nagrereklamo ay idemanda mo at huwag mo gamitin ang social media para manira ng pangalan. Lumaban ka dr. doods, sya naman idemanda mo sa paninirang puri.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Actually, an xray (not an ultrasound) was done where 3 (not 4) puppies were seen. And there was no statement given by Animal House that a CS could have saved the dog and her puppies. I already asked the owner to edit her post, which she based on how she was told by the person who brought the dog to our clinic.

    ReplyDelete