Thursday, January 30, 2014

CCTV Footage Appears to Bolster Vhong Navarro's Version of Events

Image courtesy of www.gmanetwork.com

Source: www.gmanetwork.com

The NBI on Wednesday showed CCTV footage that seems to support actor Vhong Navarro's version of events on the night of January 22, which left him hospitalized after being badly beaten.

Before the CCTV video was shown to the media, the sensational case had pitted Navarro's word against the claims of several others, including 22-year-old Deniece Cornejo who said Navarro had tried to rape her in her condo unit.

But the video clearly shows Cornejo entering her building's elevator and then exiting the building shortly after Navarro arrived. She did not appear like she had just survived a rape attempt, and casually examined herself in the elevator mirror.

Navarro was mauled by businessman Cedric Lee and his friends that night, after Lee said he found the actor on top of Cornejo. But the video appears to show that Navarro and Cornejo were not in the condo unit at the same time.

"Tugma ang CCTV footages sa testimony of Vhong Navarro," said NBI-NCR Assistant Regional Director Vicente De Guzman during the presentation.

The footage was provided by the Forbeswood Heights condominium in Bonifacio Global City, where the attack on Navarro took place last week.

"Noong pumasok si Vhong Navarro, after a few minutes, si Ms. Deniece Cornejo went out sa elevator," De Guzman said.

Recorded times

Based on the video footage, Navarro entered the lobby at 10:38 p.m. wearing a shirt, shorts and cap and carrying something in a paper bag. Two minutes later at 10:40 p.m., Cornejo appears in the same lobby, leaving the building alone.

The time stamp of a separate CCTV camera in the elevator showed Cornejo leaving the elevator just a minute after Navarro arrived. Inside the lift, she casually examines herself in the elevator’s reflective door.

At 10:41 p.m., three minutes after the actor entered the building, Lee entered the lobby and headed to the elevator. Minutes later, two other males entered the lobby. One of them has been identified as a certain Ferdinand Guerrero.

In the elevator footage, the NBI noted that there were two unidentified men inside the lift. They said that these men did not enter the building after the actor has arrived.

“Wala po sa video footage na pumasok ‘yung dalawa. Siguro they came in earlier. May dalawang lalaki doon sa room. Ibig sabihin, andun na sila,” De Guzman noted.

According to Navarro’s statement earlier, when Deniece left him inside the unit, two men, who came from Cornejo’s room, beat him up. One of them pointed a gun at his face.

With Cornejo still outside the building, Lee’s sister Bernice Lee entered the lobby at 10:56 p.m. and left with Cedric three minutes later. The two were having a conversation inside the lift, with Bernice gesturing with her hands as if counting.

At 11:01 p.m., Cornejo and the Lee siblings entered the building again and headed to the elevator to go back up to Cornejo's unit on the second floor.

Twelve minutes later, at 11:13 p.m., Navarro, the Lees, Cornejo and five other men were seen in the lobby leaving the building together. The footage shows Navarro being escorted out with his hands bound behind his back.

Condo owner

The NBI also clarified that Cornejo is not the owner of the condo unit. The owner has been identified as a certain Soledad Ramos, who was set to appear before the NBI today, Wednesday.

“A letter from Soledad Ramos allowed her [Cornejo] to stay in the unit,” De Guzman said.

Police blotter

Navarro, who is currently in the hospital recovering from surgery following his beating, was brought to the Southern Police District by Lee and his companions that night to file a blotter entry detailing an alleged rape attempt on Cornejo by Navarro.

The blotter entry detailed Navarro's supposed attack on Cornejo and bore both their signatures. In an interview with Butch Francisco on "Startalk", Navarro's lawyer Alma Mallonga denied the veracity of the account, saying the whole incident was an attempt at extortion.

"This horrible crime that was created against Vhong—he was a victim of detention, tinorture siya, he was blackmailed, he was being extorted—at itong ginawang krimen sa kanya, pinabalahaan siya na huwag siyang magsalita, huwag siyang magbigay ng kahit anong pahayag sa media at itago niya ang ginawang krimen sa kaniya, at ginamit nila itong paglagay sa police blotter ng isang hindi makatotohanang akusasyon," she said.

104 comments:

  1. I knew that Vhong was telling the truth.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dahil lumabas na ang CCTV e eto na ang theory ko. Watch nyo ulet ung video ng interview ni vhong dito sa FP! Me discrepancy sa kwento nya coz nilalagay nya sa same room sina Cedric at deniece gayong sa CCTV e wala si deniece sa room ng ilang oras and sa lobby nasa labas si deniece nung pumasok si Cedric! So eto theory: nagkasalisi sila ni vhong and nung pumasok sa room si deniece after nyang kitain mga tropa ni cedric e nagulat sya coz andun na si vhong dahil sinundo nya ang grupo nila Cedric kaya ung Sabi ni vhong na nagulat si deniece nung magkita sila sa 2nd floor ng elevator and sabi ano ginagawa u dito Hindi pa ako nakapaglinis e sinabi ni deniece pagpasok nya sa unit nya and andun na si vhong! Set-up Ito!

      Delete
    2. Parang food delivery boy lang si vhong dito e!

      Delete
    3. So sa CCTV e obvious na plinano, ang question now is bakit? Dahil ba me relasyon sina Cedric at deniece? O si Bernice at deniece? O dahil high class e si deniece at hindi nagbayad si vhong dahil gwapo at artista kaya siningil dahil isa Ito sa mga best babes nila!?

      Delete
  2. Ayan na ayan na ngayon mo sabihin js na tugma ang version nina lee! Napakalinaw na totoo ang sinasabi ni vhong! Buti nalang magaling field reporter mo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sana Me full footage si FP ng CCTV! Magulo pa din coz me time lapse na 14mins nung nasa loob ng elevator ung mag kapatid na lee and nung isakay si vhong sa elevator. Ibig sabihin ba nun binabalasa ng mga tropa ni Cedric si vhong nung mga oras na yun?! Pero dinidiin ni vhong na andun si Cedric sa buong pangyayari! And 1 Oras nilang hawak si vhong at tinorture?

      Delete
  3. tapos sasabihin ng deniece na na-rape sya ng ganun kabilis? ano yan minute to win it?!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Omg hahaha! TRUE!

      Delete
    2. laughtrip sa minute to win it!

      Delete
    3. HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!

      Delete
    4. May point ka teh!

      Delete
    5. hahahaha. winning comment!

      Delete
    6. Hahaha panalo comment mo

      Delete
    7. I CHOKED ON MY SALIVA

      Delete
    8. more on RAPE IT TO WIN IT!!!
      HAHAHAHAHAHHAHA

      Delete
    9. Hahaha winner ka, dapat kang bigyan ng award.

      Delete
    10. You've got a minute to rape her! Hahahahahahaha

      Delete
  4. Mali naman Ito. Hindi 11:13 kungdi 11:33! And me discrepancies pa din sa interbyu ni vhong dahil sabi nya sabay sila pumasok ni D and nagkita sila sa 2nd floor sa elevator! And kita sa footage na nagkasalisi sila dahil paakyat si vhong pababa si D! 21:59 and 22:00! And ang sinalubong ni D sina Cedric! And ang Sabi ni V e nung papalabas na ng pinto si D e me tumutok ng baril sa kanya e pano un nangyare e ilang minuto silang Hindi magkasama?! And ung mike e galing sa 4th floor pababa ng elevator! Ibig sabihin taga duon ung mike!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. anong mali? sabi ni vhong pagpasok nila ng room ni deniece lumabas agad ito at yun ang nakita si deniece sa elevator..2 minutes is enough para lumabas ng room at pumasok ng elevator..at nabilang mo ba ang nakita sa cctv na pumasok? hindi lahat ng character pumasok di ba pero lahat ng character lumabas.. meaning may nasa loob na..at yun ang tinutukoy ni vhong na nakita nya sa loob ng room..

      Delete
    2. o nga, buti nmn di lang ako ang nakapsanin. Pero TV Patrol was emphasing. repeating over and over again that: "so hindi tugma sa cctv ang salaysay ni cedric lee and deniece"--- ignoring that even vhong's account was also inconsistent. actually, d only thing d cctv proves in ngdala nga ng food si vhong.

      Delete
    3. Tama pala. 10:33 sa elevator 11:13 sa lobby me 40min gap.

      Delete
    4. Yung kay mike na part... hindi siya galing sa 4th floor nakita sa cctv na he also entered the lobby

      Delete
    5. Mas Mali ka teh 9:04. Ang haba kung explain ko pa. Tignan mo ulit interview ni Vhong. Hahaha.

      Delete
    6. Cedric Lee ikaw ba yan? O ikaw c Bernice? Hahahahaha

      Delete
    7. aw alam mo na?,,, ikaw seguro ang isa sa mga nambogbog,, surrender na habang maaga pa,, alam mo ang right time,, so ikaw na si mike?,,,,

      Delete
    8. Anon 9:04 PM, nood-nood din ng mabuti ha. Sa CCTV, from the time na lumabas si V ng elevator, isang minuto pa, bago pinakitang sumakay ng elevator si D. Sa isang minuto na iyon, maari namang nasalubong na nya si V at nadala na sa condo unit nya, tapos nakabalik na sa elevator para bumaba. Mas imposible yung sa pagdating na yun ni V sa 2nd floor, kung saan nandon ang unit, at nandon din si D, at yung ONE MINUTE na yun bago bumalik si D sa elevator, e yun na yung time na masalimuot na eksenang sinabi ni D sa statement nya. Saka teka, close kayo nung Mike? Alam mo kung saan sya nakatira?

      Delete
    9. Nagkasalisi? It was the same freaking elevator! Buti sana if she rode another elevator down while vhong rode another one up! Duh!

      Delete
    10. Paano mo nalaman na may discrepancy, andun ka ba?

      Delete
    11. Watch the full nbi report. Misguided ka. Peace

      Delete
    12. denephew isdatchu????

      Delete
    13. late ng kaunti yung time sa cctv sa elevator i forgot kung ilang seconds yun sinabi sa news. Yung timeframpe di nagsisinungaling how come she was rape eh iniwan nya si vhong sa condo unit.napangiti pa nga yung bruha habang papasok sa elevator yan ba ang na trauma

      Delete
    14. Puro ka e, tulog na cedrick.

      Delete
    15. te hindi pa kasi pinakita ang lahat ng cctv. nabanggit mo dyan mismo na nagkita sila sa 2nd floor di ba? yung inilabas ng NBI ay yun g sa lobby pa lang at pag pasok ni vhong sa elevator. malay natin sa 2nd floor lumabas si vhong at dun sila nagkita ni deneice. nanonood ka ba ng balita?

      Delete
    16. mali ang sabi ni vhong ngkita cla s may pinto ng elevator tapos sabay clang pumasok s condo..tapos nilapag ni vhong ung pagkain n dala nya sabay labas ni deniece..

      Delete
    17. mali ka din..panuorin mo kasi mabuti.. hindi sila nag kasalisi kasi sabi ni vhong ang tagal ng elevator kaya nung bumukas na umakyat na sya after umakyat ni vhong nagulat si deniece na nandun na sya sa taas ng condo unit nya..kasi dapat susunduin sya ni denise sa lobby..dahil according to her mahigpit a lobby pero nung nakapasok si vhong at bumukas yun elevator sumakay na sya at hindi na hinintay si deniece.. pinapasok nya si vhong sa unit nya then dito mo na makikita na minute lang yun pagitan yun cctv footage.. bumaba si denise sa lobby.. then yun sinasabi ni vhong na pag punta nya sa sala may lumabas na lalaki na nakatututok yun baril sa knya.. yun sa cctv footage makikita na padating na sila cedric lee.. meaning bago pa makaakyat si denise saka cedric na gulpi na si vhong nung dalawa na nasa loob ng kwarto nung deniece

      Delete
    18. Ikaw kaya ang ipabugbog ko ng ganun. Tingnan natin kung may maalala ka pa ng sakto!

      Delete
    19. Haler! Pano makakapasok c Vhong sa kwarto kung nagkasalisihan sila, xempre nagpang abot sila sa taas kasi dumeretso na si Vhong dahil matagal c Deniece at saktong bumukas ang elevator. Sa taas naman pinapasok na ni Deniece si Vhong saka xa lumabas ulit at voila anjan na dalawang goons, dumeretso na c Deniece pababa. Anong discrepancy dun, magaling kapa sa NBI teh?

      FP pakipost naman po nito

      Delete
  5. Unti unti ng lumiliwanag ang lahat, tingin ko kahit manalo na si vhong sa kaso, maapektuhan parin ang career nya sa mga nagyari.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. tama! siya ang pinaka apektado.

      Delete
    2. makakabalik pa rin sya.. lalo na kung mapatunayan na sya ang nagsasabi ng totoo nasa kanya ang simpatya..

      Delete
  6. nagpabook na daw si deniece at cedric papuntang ibang bansa..nung lunes pa. alam na!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Para unbelievable na talaga sila Deniece kasi yung nilagay nila sa blotter was attempted rape tapos ngayon sa sinampa niya nirape na siya. Ano ba talaga

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hindi lang parang. Talagang unbelievable yung babae. Napanuod ko yung isang interview niya today, umaacting na siya, may pa-luha luha na, at may "para sa Pilipinas" pa siyang nalalaman. Imbiyerna lang.

      Delete
    2. 11:21 naloka din ako nung sinabi nya yun. Magbibigay honor daw sya sa sarili nya at sa pilipinas. Beauty contest lang, te? Mukha namang rehearsed ang mga sinasabi nya pero wala talagang sense.

      Delete
    3. Nagfefeeling Beauty queen ehoserang retokadang palaka!

      Delete
    4. @11:21 lumuluha na xa , sa hiya nya kc alam na ang kapok***an nya!

      Delete
  8. However, no copy of the CCTV footage were given to Southern Police District. Why disregard and eliminate them from this issue, kahit na sabihin na nating 'kasabwat' ang mga pulis.

    That's a big question mark. If Navarro's side, Security Agency and NBI wants to have a fair media blow then sana hinayaan din nilang mag-investigate ang mga pulis.



    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Uhm..hindi mo ba napansin ang pagka incompetent ng mga pulis noong nagpa blotter sila? Ang dami nilang mali, so yes, mas maganda na NBI ang mag investigate.

      Delete
    2. Tanong mo admin ng Condo bat di nila binigay ang CCTV copy til now?

      Delete
    3. it doesn't make sense to have both cops and the nbi conduct separate investigations if you take into account the meager resources in the philippines. this being a high profile case, it is expected that the nbi takes charge and i'm sure the cops have more than enough cases, albeit not as high-profile, that remain unsolved.

      Delete
    4. t**ga. matter of jurisdiction yan.

      Delete
    5. The case was already turned over to Taguig City Police. Obviously, SPD had loopholes in handling the said matter. No need to give them the CCTV footage.

      Delete
    6. Ate nakakaunawa kaba tlaga? Wala sa kamay nila Vhong ang pag allow o di pag allow ng imbestigasyon. At wala sa kanila ang CCTV dahil ung admin o mgt ang magbibigay nyan. Anubey

      Delete
  9. sa CCTV mo malalaman kung sino ang nagsasabi ng totoo.Kanino kayo papanig sa biktima o sa nambiktima?

    ReplyDelete
  10. C vhong tlga ngsasabi ng totoo based sa cctv.

    ReplyDelete
  11. wala na kayong kawala ngayon mga asal demonyo kayo

    ReplyDelete
  12. Conspiracy theory.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nako goodluck na lang kung makakasuhan si cedric masonic pa ata ang mokong #masoniclaws

      Delete
  13. Nakasumbrero pa sj vhong para d makilala. Lumandi kasi kaya tago2x din pag may time no?

    ReplyDelete
  14. Isa na namang kwento nina David and Goliath. Sino ang mag-aakalang si vhong navarro lang ang makakapuwing sa higanteng si Goliath. Siguro ginamit si vhong para matigil na ang kahayupan ng grupong ito.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Sana i-lie detector test din ung mga yan para magkaalamanan na talaga..puro papalit palit ng statement! Attempted rape na biglang rape na pala!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Galing talaga ang maging talent dos, pag may nangyari sa iyo ang bilis mong makamit ang 'hustiya', lilinis at babango ng reputasyon mo huli.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Nag-iisip na siguro ng paraan yung mga salarin kung paano makakalabas sa Pinas ASAP!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Dapat sa tropa ni Cedric, kasama si Deniece at Berniece i- lethal injection lahat ASAP!

    ReplyDelete
  19. wala nang kawala ang mga suspect. dapat mahuli na lahat. goodluck na lang sa non-bailable na serious illegal detention

    ReplyDelete
  20. The CCTV camera is shows crystal clear that Denise and Cedric are telling lies. They are both lier!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Grabe di ko maintindihan pati yung sister ni cedric ininvolve ang sarili nya sa ganito? Para lang sa 1m? Ganyan ba sila kadesperate? Grabe kakahiya sa pamilya nila ha.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mukhan palang di na pagkatiwalaan un ate.. 1M malamang initial palang un,hihingi pa ng kasunod easy money sang tawag lang pera na.. kaya nga siya pina blotter pang blop,vinedeohan pa. akala cguro nila di magsasalita si vhong.

      Delete
    2. ako rin dun ako sa sister nakatutok. di ko rin mawari baket.

      Delete
  22. Wow!!! Denise was for 2 minutes.
    They should also show how she looked when she was in the elevator. Usually raped victims are distraught.
    The sister is also a big liar.

    ReplyDelete
  23. New movie: " Raped in 120 seconds"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Less than 120 eh nakapagbihis pa nga ang haliparot

      Delete
  24. I have always believed that everyone has their expiration.
    Finally this Chinese mob would be placed in jail.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Nag tataka lang ako bakit si cedric lee and vhong navarro nung lumabas sila ng elevator sa right side sila dumeretso.. Pero yung the rest papuntang left tapos nung sabay sabay na sila bumaba galing sila sa left side. Dalawa ba ang room?? Hindi naman pede nag kamali lang both si cedric at vhong.

    Ayun lang napansin ko sa cctv eh

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wala kasing label kung anong floor. Pero based sa observations ko, pag sa right side sila lumabas/galing, sa 2nd floor yun, sa condo unit nung Deniece. Pero pag sa left side, nasa lobby sila.

      Delete
    2. True. also base sa damit parang yung 2 may hawak kay vhong did all the dirty work. Kumbaga sila yung henchmen ni cedric. Kung sa pelikula sila ang humahawak magkabila kay vhong para makasuntok si cedric.

      Delete
    3. Usually sa condos maraming elevators, 2 on each side facing each other. Kaya minsan parang galing yung tao sa opposite sides ng building pero magkaibang elevators yun.

      Delete
  26. Grabe mas naawa ano nung makita ko na nakagapos si vhong papasok ng elevator at obvious na in pain... Yung katawan nung mga yoon! Jusko ang lalaki kumpara sa katawan no vhong! Maka citizen arrest kuno sa katawan pa lang nila talo siya.

    ReplyDelete
  27. i read somewhere na sa SUCAT pa daw sila nag pa blotter.. nasa taguig ung condo pumunta pa all the way to sucat!

    ReplyDelete
  28. Cedric Lee buwahahahaahahahaha. You think you are invisible.
    May araw ka din at dumating na yon.
    Buwahahahaahahahaha hahahaha. Evil laugh for an evil person

    ReplyDelete
  29. I just wanted to laugh when he said Hindi siya papasok ng showboz at politika. As if tatanggapin siya.
    He was so arrogant in saying he would do the same thing all over again.

    ReplyDelete
  30. The case of Denise of attempted rape would have been stronger than rape.
    Who the hell would believe that you got raped in 1 minute.
    Even quickies do not happen that way.

    ReplyDelete
  31. bukelya na sila cedric and deniece... aminin n lang nila ang pagsisinungaling nila, ng hindi na lumaki pa ang kaso nila.

    ReplyDelete
  32. hindi pwede maging artista si Demonice kasi hindi marunong umarte!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  33. Kung walang manloloko walang maloloko . Karma ni vhong yan. Cheater sya eh. Sana lahat ng cheaters ma vhong navarro.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. be careful what you wish for

      Delete
    2. Be ready 11:27 baka sayo or sa pamilya mo unang bumalik yang sinasabi mo

      Delete
    3. Anon, 11:27, oh well, thanks to a Vhong Navarro at hindi na puede makabiktima ng iba ang gang ni Cedric Lee.

      Delete
  34. Vhong is no saint. But he is clearly the victim here. Grabe naman pala talaga tong cedric lee na to. Sindikatong feeling above the law. Im sure he's making arrangements now sa pag takas nila ng kabitchina nya.

    ReplyDelete
  35. pansin ko dalawa ang unit kasi si vhong pumunta ng right tapos ang ibang kasanmahan ni Cedric sa left ..yong dalawang tao na di nakita sa CCTV baka isa sa kanila nag rerent duon at nakapunta na ng unit ni Deniece bago pa dumating c Vhong kaya nong pag baba ni Deniece ang dalawa na yon isa sa kanila tumutok ng baril kay Vhong saka umakyat c CEdric paran planado ito at yong mga binibiktima nila ay yong mga taong iningatan ang pangalan kagaya ng mga artista at politiko baka hindi lng 2m an gmakukuha nya dyn kay Vhong kng di kumanta baka buwan buwan eh my sustento sila

    ReplyDelete
  36. no need to worry. Paaimbestigahan na sa senado ni senator jinggoy ang lahat. Mananagot ang may sala. Aksyon agad

    ReplyDelete
  37. Ano na lang kung walang cctv. Talagang malaki naitutulong niyan sa paglutas ng mga kaso. Grabeycious! Dapat lahat ng building may cctv na eh. MalaPBB dapat. Haha!

    ReplyDelete
  38. Ba't nung dumating si Vhong sa condo, nung nasa lobby pa sya papasok, nakablack shirt sya, nung nasa elevator na, nakawhite shirt naman? Nung pababa na sila kasama mga thugs nakawhite, nung nasa lobby palabas na nakaduct tape mga kamay nakablack na naman? Pakiexplain. Labyu!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The color of his shirt is actually black. It's the light that makes it look white.

      Delete
  39. Anon 1:08 it is because of the lighting...

    ReplyDelete
  40. hay sana talga ma resolbahan na tong kaso na to. I always knew naman na Vhong was the one telling the truth eh. jusko may narape bang napaka kalmado. eh feeling ko kung ako narape hanggang langit ang galit na mararamdaman ko e. grabe lang. F*** U ka talga deniece go to effin hell!

    ReplyDelete