Sunday, October 27, 2013

Inspiration or Imitation: Mute Math Performing "Typical" on Jimmy Kimmel Live 2007 vs Karylle Tatlonghari, Jugs Jugueta and Teddy Corpuz on It's Showtime 2013

Reversed

Backwards

88 comments:

  1. kakapal talaga ng kapamilya first time daw in history of tv ... naku ..uso mahiya ah

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They never said it was the first in the history of television. They said it was the first here in the Philippines. TSE!

      Delete
    2. first tome i perform live. at surprising kasi di alam ng audience n gnun pala. wala sila sinabi na sila ang nagkauna idea nun. mdmi videos na ganyan din like coldplay,rem etc. bitter ka masyado.

      Delete
    3. Uy te. First time on PHILIPPINE TV Hndi naman nila claim na sa history of TV! Kaloka!

      Delete
    4. Teh ! Noud ka ulet sa performance ng TKJ ah ?? Live po kasi yan tapos ni Rewind lang.

      Delete
    5. dalawa ang vid. un live din .. natgalan kasi i rewind kasi 2007 pa yan .. 2013 ngayon kaya mabilis kaya ok lang talaga totally live

      Delete
    6. si 1211, halatang network war ang cause ng bitterness. wag makitid ang utak pwede

      Delete
    7. first time daw makikita sa buong Pilipinas sa buong mundo, which is probably half truth kasi nga they did it live, that is kung sila nga ang naka una. some of you are missing the point, the concept is not theirs and yet pinabayaan nilang purihin sila to the highest level without even mentioning that it is semi-inspired or semi-copied (you know glass half full, half empty). and yes, they copied some part of the parts in Mutemath's performance in JK Show.

      Delete
    8. bat ganun? pag may magandang nagagawa or napapakita ung mga pilipino, kapwa pilipino din ung naghahanap ng paraan para makapanira? hay.

      Delete
    9. Sinabi ni teddy na 2years ago pa daw nila naisip yung concept na yan. Tsaka first time on philippine tv nga. Nakakabad vibes naman yung bumabatikos hehe. Anyway ganon talaga may haters.

      Delete
    10. To: AnonymousOctober 27, 2013 at 1:53 PM

      They never said the concept was theirs. Paano naman if original nga ang idea and they did not know na may ka pareho. I think they are smart enough to say that they are inspired by it, or maybe hindi lang talaga na i-detail masyado.

      Delete
  2. TKJ's performance was done LIVE. Yan yung first. Pwede ba ang nenega nyo. Pati to gagawan ng issue? Utak talangka eh.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True! And they never claimed na original concept yan.

      Delete
    2. Korek! Palibhasa bitter ang iba dyan kasi d sila nakakaisip ng ganyan. True talented tlga mga KaF.

      Delete
    3. and they never said that the concept was inspired by other aritsts and even copied some part of the video. just sayin'

      Delete
    4. sana di nalang sinali yung pagbuhos ng soda at pagtapon ng paint para di naman sabihin ng haters na ginaya talaga. sa totoo lang pareho man ng concept ay magkaiba padin. inspiration na matatawag yung kila TKJ.

      Delete
  3. ang trying hard nitong SHOWTIME kahit kelan!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They only want to Make People Happy sorry kung di mo naappreciate pero marami naman naappreciate yan khit dito sa Abroad, inaabangan namin yong sine mo to and Thats my Tomboy nila, sumaya kami at tumawa, nawala homesickness namin kahit 2 hours lang

      Delete
    2. Trying hard ba yung umabot ng 4 years???

      Delete
    3. bakit kailangan laging nega? super effort kaya ung ginawa nila. why can't people just appreciate, and if you don't like it, then just ignore.. di ba??

      Delete
    4. wala kasing maipalit kaya umabot ng 4 yrs! hahaha TH OVERLOAD! dagdag mo pa ka-OA-yan ni Anne Curtis.. si Vice at Vhong lng nagdadala jan eh

      Delete
    5. Anon 12:22 at 1:04 masyado kang nega ha. Yung totoo, kaS ka no?? Over ka sa bitter dahil tanggal na yung fave show mo sa tanghali na katapat ng showtime at eat bulaga no?

      Delete
    6. wala akong pakelam sa network war, totoo lng sinasabi ko na trying hard ang showtime at OA na si Anne di na bagay sa edad nya!..kahit trying hard kailangan magbulag bulagan kasi fantard? sori di ako ganon!

      Delete
    7. Ang nega mo kahit kelan!

      Delete
    8. 3:46 Pm, ndi obvious na insecure ka kay anne no? mas kadiri kung ikaw gagawa nun. Salamin2x din pg may time.

      Delete
    9. To: "kahit trying hard kailangan magbulag bulagan kasi fantard? sori di ako ganon!"

      Argument invalid. Hindi ako "fantard" but I like the show. If you don't like it, don't watch it and stop putting them down as they are doing much good to the madlang people than you. Peg.

      Delete
    10. Mas trying hard naman ata mga pinaggagawa nila. obvious naman na naghanap sila ng ipantatapat sa 4th time anniv showtime.

      Delete
  4. Hindi ba live din ang jimmy kimmel?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. live ung act pero lip sync

      Delete
    2. Live un action pero ndi live un kanta....wla nmang mic, galaw lng ng galaw pero ndi nakanta.

      Delete
  5. Imitation kasi pati small details tulad ng inumin na binuhos sa katawan tsaka yung paint nsa tkj vid

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I guess this is common act in all "rewind" clips. Para mas makita ang yung effect ng rewind.

      Delete
  6. Pagpalagay na natin hindi sila ang unang gumawa nyan. Pero to do it live, eh achievement na yan anu. Mahirap makuha ang managg pagbigkas nang pabaligtad na lyrics na swak sa original na tono. Huwag naman po pairalin ang crab mentality.

    ReplyDelete
  7. obviously, the jimmy kimmel performance wasn't live..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. hindi naman live or not live ang tanong.

      Delete
    2. so, what is your point?

      Delete
    3. Sumakit ulo ko sa video nung mute math. Although kakaiba yung concept kasi nung 2007 pa pala ginawa yun, and that time malamang namangha din mga nakapanood nun. Pero mas klaro yung kila TKJ. tsaka talagang aktwal na kinanta nila ng pabaliktad. Kasi yung mute math backmasking naman dun sa 'backwards' video. literal na baligtad na pinatugtog ung kanta.

      Delete
  8. Parang nagkakalat lang si Karylle.

    ReplyDelete
  9. inspiration. to be fair never naman nila kinlaim na orig ung concept noh.just first time on phil tv. at on live broadcast nila ginawa

    ReplyDelete
  10. theyve done in live, they momerise the lyrics backwards, its an inspiration since the first performance was pre recorded.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True. Pre recorded ung mute math performance

      Delete
  11. Napabilib pa nmn ako ng TKJ nung napanood ko yan.. yun pala may pinaggayahan lang... pati yung pagtapon ng soda ginaya...

    ReplyDelete
  12. LIVE DIN YUNG SA MUTE MATH FYI LANG SA PAULIT ULIT NA NAGSASABI NA LIVE ANG SA SHOWTIME!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True Live din yung sa Mute Math pero hindi yung backward version. Live yung performance nila ng normal version. Sa Showtime Live yung backwards version kaya 100% maganda ang performance nila. Wag kayong bitter, maging proud naman kahit hindi fan ng ST.

      Delete
    2. Agree ako 5:14. Kaso wala na tayong magagawa sa mga sarado na ang utak, i babase na lang nila yun sa kesyo gaya gaya daw. Eh aminado naman talaga teddy na hindi sya nauna sa gantong concept. Baka nagbingi mga haters nung sinabi ni teddy yung part na yun? Haha

      Delete
  13. masyado kasing feeling tong mga trying hard na taga showtime na to eh

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hindi naman issue ang live o hindi live. Ang tanong lang imitation o inspiration. At obvious naman na...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Obvious na inspiration. Naging imitation lang dating sa mga closr minded peeps dun sa soda at paint splash. Pero tingin ko sinadya ni teddy na isama yun sa performance as a reference para sa mga mahusay magresearch. Di nman ilalagay ni teddy ng ganon para lang batikusin ng ganyan.

      Delete
  15. Inspiration for me. May mga IBANG scene ung sa Mute Math n kapareha tlga ng sa tkj. At may ibang scenes din naman sa tkj ang wala dun sa Mute Math. Sana lang marealize din ng ibang nagkocomment dito that tkj's performance was done LIVE compare dun sa Mute Math na recorded na and thats the big difference, and showtime or tkj dont claim that this was first on TV. Sa philippine tv yes and it was performed LIVE.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Jimmy kimmel is not alive fyi. they always pre tape kapag may mga performance nagaganap.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. *LIVE* typo bago may mag nega nanaman dyan.

      Delete
    2. alive! Alive! alive! Hahahahahah- Bading Capiznon

      Delete
  17. Whether it was Imitation or not, the thing is EFFORT on the part of TKJ. Sobrang saludo ako! Nakaka-inspire ang commitment nila!

    ReplyDelete
  18. alam nyo d ko nagustuhan ung performance nila. sumakit lang ang ulo ko lalo na sa kanta ni karylle. naloka ako, di ba nag mumusical xa pro waley sa tono ng bongga at over hingal pa.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ikaw kaya try mo magpagulong gulong at mag ballet at split ewan ko lang kung di ka hingalin! chuserang palaka ka.. hahahaha kung sumakit ulo mo mag overdose ka ng advil! lol

      Delete
    2. Yup. Natabunan na naman niya ang boses ng iba. At parang nagwawala lang sa stage.

      Delete
    3. try mo mgulam ng iba teh. indi nakakbuti ang pagkain lagi ng ampalaya

      Delete
    4. its my opinion te. walang pakialamanan. pwede nman kasi itone down ang lakas ng boses kung may hingal factor na, e top of her lungs pa ang pagkanta. wag maxado defend lola. try mo kaya mag suot ng hearing aid. bingi ka na yata.

      Delete
  19. Live naman yung sa Showtime kaya okay lang. Galing parin nila.

    ReplyDelete
  20. lipsynch yung sa mute band. halos di ko makita yung bibig niya sa dami niyang ginagawa. Alam kong nagawa na yung backward performance abroad pero I'm still impressed with TKJ's magpasikat number. Nagets ko it was backward sa" pa pa pa" portion. TKJ na ang winner para sakin for this year.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good for you. Gawa ka ng blog na ang title eh "Live or Lipsynched". Meanwhile, dito sa post na ito na Inspiration or Imitation, halatang Imitation.

      Delete
  21. Inspiration!
    Billy,Vhong and Coleen's performance also have some similarities with Adele's Chasing Pavements' Music Video.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Turn off ako sa start ng TKJ video na sinabi na idea daw ni Karylle! At hindi naman kumontra si Karylle. The nerve.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. palabas lang nila yun,para ma surprise yung audience

      Delete
    2. inspiration 1.8 million views:)

      Delete
  23. its both imitation and inspiration, ang daming part sa performance ng tkj na kapareho talaga sa math mute, so its imitation. Inspiration at the same time cause they were able to make it live.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Karamihan naman ng sumasagot sa question ni FP na imitation or inspiration, kadalasan ang sagot imitation. Puro kayo bitter! Alam nyo ba ang difference ng imitation sa inspiration?

    ReplyDelete
  25. Porke ba may gumawa na before imitation agad just because they were the first one? Does that follow that kind of logic?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Preach. It's as if once a thing has been done, it cannot be repeated again because people will say it's imitated. Get a life, people.

      Delete
  26. TKJ sang live! Sila nag-act lang sa ni-reverse na song... Walang wala sa ginawang effort ng TKJ... Pati intro ni Jimmy Kimmel reversed lang... Not live! TKJ pa rin!

    ReplyDelete
  27. Ke ginaya o Hindi, still laudable yung ginawa nila. Mejo off lang na sinabi ni Teddy na matagal na nyang na conceptualized yun

    ReplyDelete
  28. at the end of the day, mhirap kumanta ng pabaliktad na lyrics, so i still give teddy's group a big clap. they never claimed their concept as an original idea. ang mga super nega d2 eh ung mga malulungkot ang buhay at walang ginawa kundi kumain ng ampalaya.

    ReplyDelete
  29. YUn sa TKJ "LIVE" at napakahirap gawin nun.... yung sa banda pwedeng inedit... pwedeng lipsynch... hindi ba pwedeng bumilib naman tayo sa "TALENTONG PINOY" at maging masaya na me mga matatalino at magagaling na kababayan tayo???? Continue to sharpen your TALENTS... TKJ!!!

    ReplyDelete
  30. direct copy, syempre sa pinas tayo diba?

    ReplyDelete
  31. inspiration- mas maganda pa nga yung sa tkj.ilang beses kong pinanood.nakakaaliw.!

    ReplyDelete
  32. wala pang gumawa nyan ditto sa pinas at nakakaaliw,first time ko rin makapanood nyan for me inspiration

    ReplyDelete
  33. it was inspiration pure and simple. was the performance done before -- yes. nag-claim ba sila na first sila ever - no. was it first on Philippine television -- yes. nag enjoy ba yung target audience nila - hell yeah! dyoskoh network lang ang peg ng mga bitter bitter na lola. Agree ako kay Anon 4:38PM

    ReplyDelete
  34. lahat naman sila nanggagaya. even Vice Ganda his performance yung kumakanta sa harap ng mirror ginaya kay Michelle Chamuel sa finals ng the Voice Season 3 mas cheap lang ang pagkagaya because we don't have the right technology.

    ReplyDelete
  35. unang una hindi naman at never nag claim sila jugs and teddy na original yun concept nila.. pwede pa siguro sabihin na una itong ginawa sa philippine tv. ang sinasabi ni teddy at na matagal na nya na conceptualized is gusto nila gawin yun sa showtime.. 2 years ago pa sa magpasikat week nila kaso hindi pa kaya ng editing dept. ng ganun kabilis dati.. pero ngaun kaya na kaya nagawa nila.. sa panahon ngayun wala ng original no.. lahat may pinangalingan na inspiration or ideas!

    ReplyDelete
  36. Sige lang, mainis kayo sa pagiging corny or overrated, panahon kasi ng showtime ngayon eh, balang araw lilipas din at pag lumipas na yun for sure mamimiss yan ng mga taong di natutuwa sa showtime.

    ReplyDelete
  37. INSPIRATION! mga bitter lang magsasabing imitation yung sa TKJ.. hindi maka-appreciate ng effort ng kapwa..at hater lang ang magsasabing hindi maganda ang ginawa ng TKJ..wala talagang sasabihing maganda..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tomoh. Masyadong pinapairal ang Network War.

      Delete
  38. Imitation kasi halos lahat ng details ginaya kung inspiration kasi idea lang tapos umisip sana sila ibang gimmick.. anyways tapos na yun.. napabilib na nila tayo eh...

    ReplyDelete