Kindly educate me and sorry agad di na naka review sa chika, what is the prob against the movie? Bakit naging controversial and may mga against sa plot? Sorry po uli di lang updated. Mejo busy sa life haha
I just discovered that the executive producers of the film are E.A. Rocha and Fernando Ortigas, both coming from long-entrenched Spanish mestizo landed families in the Philippines. This is not about personalities or making accusations against them as individuals. This is about understanding the powerful historical context behind who gets to shape our national narrative.
During Spanish colonization, the Philippines was controlled not directly by Madrid, but through local spanish elites, mestizo families, friars and landholding clans who accumulated vast wealth and political influence through the encomienda and hacienda systems. Under colonial law, land was often granted or claimed by these elites using the principle that as far as the eyes could see, land could be declared theirs. Indigenous Filipinos and native communities were dispossessed of ancestral lands, reduced to tenants on their own soil and placed under systems of tribute, forced labor and rent.
These elites were not passive observers of history. they were active beneficiaries and enforcers of colonial rule. Their influence carried through the american period and into the modern era, where landownership translated into political power, media influence and control over cultural institutions. Many of today’s largest estates and business centers originated from these colonial land grants. For example, Ortigas & Company traces its roots to these historical estates, which eventually developed into Ortigas center.
This is why it matters who produces films about Philippine history. When descendants of colonial-era landed families finance or shape films about our past, it is reasonable to critically examine the lens through which that history is being told. We must ask: Is the narrative aligned with the truth of our struggle against colonization or does it subtly sanitize, glorify or reinterpret events in favor of elite perspectives?
This is not about attacking individuals. It is about recognizing that throughout history, those who hold economic and social power have also controlled the writing and filming of history. If we do not question these narratives, we risk consuming propaganda disguised as patriotism. History is not just what happened; it is what we are allowed to remember.
Love this. :) thanks for the history lesson din; it's summarized well. Good that you pointed out. Kaya ko din tiningnan yung producers nito. Baka kasi ang ending ng mga historical movies is to just push propaganda from one elite to another without identifying the root cause of why are still corrupt. Sila sila din yan. It's keeping the wealth within these families and the citizens are just mere consumers pero sila din ang yumayaman lagi. Politicians and the rich have always been allies since power and money often go hand in hand. Kaya blinded tayo kung sino lang ang yumaman at nasa mataas na posisyon.
Nakasalubong ko sya sa McKinley Hills siguro mga 2009-2010 when I was still working there. Nagkalapit kami kaya natitigan ko talaga yung face nya. She’s really so pretty. Petite, morena and makinis. Very alta and expensive ang aura nya. Nakakahiya lang talaga magpapicture sa place na yun kahit kaming dalawa lang naman that time haha. Yung pwede nya ko sabihan na eto 10M, layuan mo ako haha.
pretty pero matapobre sa totoong buhay. I used to like her until I saw the video of her super cursing some staff.., di makain ng aso kung paano nya murahin ung mga kawawang tao.
12:19 Bka there was a back story. Di sa ok ako sa ganun pero u don't know the whole story. Oh well, yung iba 'dyan pati si God minunura pero tanggap ng iba. Ako yun ang di ko tanggap.
Totoo yan sa ibang bansa ang focus from kinder to grade 3 are reading and story re- tell or tinatawag nating comprehension na you challenge young readers to explain the 5 W ‘s of retelling a story and every kids must demonstrate improve reading and comprehension skills as they move up a grade. Ang Pilipinas ang hina ng curriculum natin tapos gagawan nyo pa ng satire or fake news ang history natin dahil sa artistic freedom kuno nyo eh mga lumaking mahina na nga sa comprehension mga studyante paano na kaya pag lumaking madaling magpaniwala sa mga fake news dahil hindi maka identify ng satire or kalokohan sa katotohanan.
If u do your research, HINDI SYA FAKE NEWS...facts are researched -based..Yung satire dun is the entire interpretation pero actually,lahat yun based on facts...TOTOONG GANUN KA YABANG AT MAINITIN ULO NI QUEZON..kung naba astusan kayo sa bibig ni Duterte, read about how he spoke about a woman who accused him of rape..ENGLISERO lang pero mas magaspang sang sinabi..
Can anyone tell me if may iba pa bang city sa Pilipinas na naka pangalan sa dating Presidente? Sadly, a big city pa in NCR named after someone who proudly declares na okay lang mala-imyerno ang buhay ng kapwa nya Pilipino basta SYA magpatakbo...BAkit ko sinabi sya? Dahil sino ba tinutukoy nyang "run by Filipinos"? Eh di sarili nya kasi sya leader nun..Nahiya pa..ginamit pa FILIPINOS, di nalang dinirecho "RUN BY ME"
6:47 doon sa Q and A movie apo na nga ni Manuel Quezon disputed na kathang isip ang movie at yung mismong gumawa ng movie nagsabi na nasa manonood na lang mag isip kung satire or totoo ang mga pangyayari tapos ikaw to sabi mo totoo sige nga cite an Author and title of the book na mayabang at mainit in ulo ni Quezon, ibahin mo Ang leader na may strong personality dahil may paninindigan kesa sa passive aggressive politicos na mayabang na puro flowery words magsalita wala namang sense because they like to hear themselves talk Magbasa ka ng History of The Filipino People by Gregorio F. Zaide and read books about Philippine history ni Zaide who was not only a brilliant kababayan but also a well respected historian. May mga books din mga ka mag anak ni Quezon, na mas detailed. Lumaki kami na mga real physical books ang at binubuklat sa library Hindi Gino- google or AI search. 3:44 unless nakaranas ka na magpalaki ng mga anak na umuuwi ng may naka ziploc na 5-10 short books pwera pa yung reading app shut your pie at tigilan mo ko sa gender identity lang pinagkakaabalahan sa school. Prove it or didn’t happen. Masyado kayong fake news peddlers at mas kakaloka ka back to you !
Classic period daw ang time ng sampaguita, lvn, premiere. Second golden age naman ng pinoy cinema ang panahon nina brocka, bernal, castillo and a few which is which is time ni marcos
Sayang si OP sa haba haba ng punto ni Pinky Amador ang nahagip ng isip mo lang ay she misspelled or misspoke. Bakit kailangan ba grade - an ang negligible grammar mistake nya. Ang punto dito is about scripts and directing liberty, may na contribute ka ba besides YOUR 😁 a GRAMNAR nazi ?
As a History student, I agree Ms. Pinky. When we research and write history and use historiography, we have to validate, verify and retest our data over and over again. For Historians, calling a movie a biopic means that ginamit and historiographic treatment. If gawin siyang source material ng pagaaral, dapat tapat sa kasaysayan. Therefore this movie does not pass the history litmus test and is a false narrative. It also means it misrepresents Quezon and that is all kinds of wrong.
Gusto good side lang? So what if ang frail lola mo nag rally? So many ordinary elders have done so; lately marami for Leni..PERO Ano motibo ng lola mo? What is wrong kung ipakita ang human side ni Q.. Anyway, eto pa rin tayo..in a country run like hell by Filipinos..so proud ka, Pinky? Oo nga naman, di ka dapat pinapansin, u r speaking from a subjective point of view..personal pala syo eto..Siguro iniisa isa ako tawagan ni Ricky..like John Arcilla, to speak out.
Yes agree with pinky.. yan problem sa mga entertainment industry. Heck even kay ed gein sa netflix mali mali eh! And no one will always find a history book to read, movie or tv shows madami nanonood at mas gullible sila dun lalo penoys.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
Kindly educate me and sorry agad di na naka review sa chika, what is the prob against the movie? Bakit naging controversial and may mga against sa plot? Sorry po uli di lang updated. Mejo busy sa life haha
ReplyDeleteWatch the movie.
DeleteI just discovered that the executive producers of the film are E.A. Rocha and Fernando Ortigas, both coming from long-entrenched Spanish mestizo landed families in the Philippines. This is not about personalities or making accusations against them as individuals. This is about understanding the powerful historical context behind who gets to shape our national narrative.
ReplyDeleteDuring Spanish colonization, the Philippines was controlled not directly by Madrid, but through local spanish elites, mestizo families, friars and landholding clans who accumulated vast wealth and political influence through the encomienda and hacienda systems. Under colonial law, land was often granted or claimed by these elites using the principle that as far as the eyes could see, land could be declared theirs. Indigenous Filipinos and native communities were dispossessed of ancestral lands, reduced to tenants on their own soil and placed under systems of tribute, forced labor and rent.
These elites were not passive observers of history. they were active beneficiaries and enforcers of colonial rule. Their influence carried through the american period and into the modern era, where landownership translated into political power, media influence and control over cultural institutions. Many of today’s largest estates and business centers originated from these colonial land grants. For example, Ortigas & Company traces its roots to these historical estates, which eventually developed into Ortigas center.
This is why it matters who produces films about Philippine history. When descendants of colonial-era landed families finance or shape films about our past, it is reasonable to critically examine the lens through which that history is being told. We must ask: Is the narrative aligned with the truth of our struggle against colonization or does it subtly sanitize, glorify or reinterpret events in favor of elite perspectives?
This is not about attacking individuals. It is about recognizing that throughout history, those who hold economic and social power have also controlled the writing and filming of history. If we do not question these narratives, we risk consuming propaganda disguised as patriotism. History is not just what happened; it is what we are allowed to remember.
Tama ka. Kaya pala si Xandra Rocha Marcos puring puri ang pelikula.
DeleteKung si Ed Rocha, tinawag na political satire ang pelikulang pinondohan nya, paano tayo makasisiguro na accurate ang pelikulang ito?
grabe ang tyaga mo 🧐
DeleteLove this. :) thanks for the history lesson din; it's summarized well. Good that you pointed out. Kaya ko din tiningnan yung producers nito. Baka kasi ang ending ng mga historical movies is to just push propaganda from one elite to another without identifying the root cause of why are still corrupt. Sila sila din yan. It's keeping the wealth within these families and the citizens are just mere consumers pero sila din ang yumayaman lagi. Politicians and the rich have always been allies since power and money often go hand in hand. Kaya blinded tayo kung sino lang ang yumaman at nasa mataas na posisyon.
DeleteSo away mayaman ba eto? Hindi ba Spanish meztizo landed family din ang mga Quezon?
DeleteSorry if out of topic pero I really find her pretty. Yung pang altang kontrabida. She's also a great actress.
ReplyDeleteYes, out of topic
DeleteI absolutely agree specially in her younger years
DeleteYes super agree maganda sya at super agree out of topic ka.
DeleteNakasalubong ko sya sa McKinley Hills siguro mga 2009-2010 when I was still working there. Nagkalapit kami kaya natitigan ko talaga yung face nya. She’s really so pretty. Petite, morena and makinis. Very alta and expensive ang aura nya. Nakakahiya lang talaga magpapicture sa place na yun kahit kaming dalawa lang naman that time haha. Yung pwede nya ko sabihan na eto 10M, layuan mo ako haha.
DeleteAgree, and ang bongga din Pala ng lineage niya.
Deletepretty pero matapobre sa totoong buhay. I used to like her until I saw the video of her super cursing some staff.., di makain ng aso kung paano nya murahin ung mga kawawang tao.
Delete12:19 Bka there was a back story. Di sa ok ako sa ganun pero u don't know the whole story. Oh well, yung iba 'dyan pati si God minunura pero tanggap ng iba. Ako yun ang di ko tanggap.
DeletePS: Medyo kahawig nya si Kat Agarrado, vocalist ng Sino Sikat.
ReplyDeleteDi naman talaga sya sikat.
DeleteHina ng comprehension mo 5:52 am. Lol. Sinosikat is a band. Ang vocalist nun ay si Kat Agarrado.
DeleteSei molto arabiata. Midispiace signora Pinky.
ReplyDeleteTotoo yan sa ibang bansa ang focus from kinder to grade 3 are reading and story re- tell or tinatawag nating comprehension na you challenge young readers to explain the 5 W ‘s of retelling a story and every kids must demonstrate improve reading and comprehension skills as they move up a grade. Ang Pilipinas ang hina ng curriculum natin tapos gagawan nyo pa ng satire or fake news ang history natin dahil sa artistic freedom kuno nyo eh mga lumaking mahina na nga sa comprehension mga studyante paano na kaya pag lumaking madaling magpaniwala sa mga fake news dahil hindi maka identify ng satire or kalokohan sa katotohanan.
ReplyDeleteIf u do your research, HINDI SYA FAKE NEWS...facts are researched -based..Yung satire dun is the entire interpretation pero actually,lahat yun based on facts...TOTOONG GANUN KA YABANG AT MAINITIN ULO NI QUEZON..kung naba astusan kayo sa bibig ni Duterte, read about how he spoke about a woman who accused him of rape..ENGLISERO lang pero mas magaspang sang sinabi..
DeleteCan anyone tell me if may iba pa bang city sa Pilipinas na naka pangalan sa dating Presidente? Sadly, a big city pa in NCR named after someone who proudly declares na okay lang mala-imyerno ang buhay ng kapwa nya Pilipino basta SYA magpatakbo...BAkit ko sinabi sya? Dahil sino ba tinutukoy nyang "run by Filipinos"? Eh di sarili nya kasi sya leader nun..Nahiya pa..ginamit pa FILIPINOS, di nalang dinirecho "RUN BY ME"
DeleteSaang ibang bansa pinagsasabi mo 1.40? Kakaloka ka. Sa Amerika nga puro gender indentity pinagkaka abalahan ng mga skwelahan.
Delete6:47 doon sa Q and A movie apo na nga ni Manuel Quezon disputed na kathang isip ang movie at yung mismong gumawa ng movie nagsabi na nasa manonood na lang mag isip kung satire or totoo ang mga pangyayari tapos ikaw to sabi mo totoo sige nga cite an Author and title of the book na mayabang at mainit in ulo ni Quezon, ibahin mo Ang leader na may strong personality dahil may paninindigan kesa sa passive aggressive politicos na mayabang na puro flowery words magsalita wala namang sense because they like to hear themselves talk Magbasa ka ng History of The Filipino People by Gregorio F. Zaide and read books about Philippine history ni Zaide who was not only a brilliant kababayan but also a well respected historian. May mga books din mga ka mag anak ni Quezon, na mas detailed. Lumaki kami na mga real physical books ang at binubuklat sa library Hindi Gino- google or AI search.
Delete3:44 unless nakaranas ka na magpalaki ng mga anak na umuuwi ng may naka ziploc na 5-10 short books pwera pa yung reading app shut your pie at tigilan mo ko sa gender identity lang pinagkakaabalahan sa school. Prove it or didn’t happen. Masyado kayong fake news peddlers at mas kakaloka ka back to you !
Bago ipalabas yan diba ni re review yan, ni review muna ng mga kamag anak, historians dapat e nung showing na saka kayo nag iiiyak
ReplyDeletendi nga daw sila nabigyan ng consent bago ipublish or bago iproduce.. check mo un FB ni Ricky Quezon
DeleteWhen was the last time penoys made a really good movie :D :D :D Yung, wow, ang ganda :) :) :) The golden era of penoy movies are over ;) ;) ;)
ReplyDeleteWhy do you keep calling us penoys? I find itinsulting. Hindi ka ba Pilipino? Enough of your sarcasm. Hindi nakakatuwa.
DeleteWhen was the golden era? The classics are nostalgic but only a very few maybe are truly good.
DeleteClassic period daw ang time ng sampaguita, lvn, premiere. Second golden age naman ng pinoy cinema ang panahon nina brocka, bernal, castillo and a few which is which is time ni marcos
DeleteHaba. Nag stop ako sa WHO'S EXPENSE 😅 Whose kasi yon miss pinky.
ReplyDeleteinuna mo pa yan
Delete😂😂😂
Delete1:56 ang talino mo nga pero mababaw ka naman. Sayang lang din. Perfect example ng reading to respond, not to understand. Sayang ka.
DeleteSi pinky ang sayang. Perfect na sana kaso...
DeleteSayang si OP sa haba haba ng punto ni Pinky Amador ang nahagip ng isip mo lang ay she misspelled or misspoke. Bakit kailangan ba grade - an ang negligible grammar mistake nya. Ang punto dito is about scripts and directing liberty, may na contribute ka ba besides YOUR 😁 a GRAMNAR nazi ?
DeleteAs a History student, I agree Ms. Pinky. When we research and write history and use historiography, we have to validate, verify and retest our data over and over again. For Historians, calling a movie a biopic means that ginamit and historiographic treatment. If gawin siyang source material ng pagaaral, dapat tapat sa kasaysayan. Therefore this movie does not pass the history litmus test and is a false narrative. It also means it misrepresents Quezon and that is all kinds of wrong.
ReplyDeleteGusto good side lang? So what if ang frail lola mo nag rally? So many ordinary elders have done so; lately marami for Leni..PERO Ano motibo ng lola mo? What is wrong kung ipakita ang human side ni Q..
ReplyDeleteAnyway, eto pa rin tayo..in a country run like hell by Filipinos..so proud ka, Pinky? Oo nga naman, di ka dapat pinapansin, u r speaking from a subjective point of view..personal pala syo eto..Siguro iniisa isa ako tawagan ni Ricky..like John Arcilla, to speak out.
Naalala ko pa rin kay ms saigon ay yung pagmumura niya sa mga kaluoy na staff ng hotel
ReplyDeleteCovid time naman kasi yun di ka ata na praning good por u.
Deletehmm tagal na ako ng tuturo ng history ,may flaws lahat ng administration..but it doesn't mean wala cla naiambag n mganda sa govt.
ReplyDeleteYes agree with pinky.. yan problem sa mga entertainment industry. Heck even kay ed gein sa netflix mali mali eh! And no one will always find a history book to read, movie or tv shows madami nanonood at mas gullible sila dun lalo penoys.
ReplyDelete