Beg to differ. He can sing and makes good songs, actually. Problem is he doesn't have the charisma to sway people, let alone most his fans who supported him as an actor to listen to his music. If only he can make at least one hit song, that'd be enough for people to take his singing seriously.
Kung may talent naman sa music isusupport. Ang daming singers and band ngayon na waley sa physical at nagsimula sa walabg pangalan pero recognized ang musical talent. James maybe able to sing and compose pero hindi outstanding.napakadaming musicians at singer sa Pilipinas and dapat angat ang galing para mapansin.
Kaloka si 12:38 hahaha si Nadine ang walang talent sa music. Gusto ko yung Palm Dream ni James pero tong 2nd album niya di ko type and di ko maintindihan lyrics niya grabe sa slang.
ni hindi nga magaling na artista si james. dekada na sa pinas pero di pa rin alam mag straight tagalog. as music artist pa kaya na di nga marunong kumanta. geez
Totally agree 12:01, Filipinos with their inclination to music can easily identify a good singer, song, composer it will organically become popular! So please James, if you’re really an “artist” just go on creating music until you make it. Stop listening to your biased faneys.
That's not completely true. Filipino tastes can be very fixed. Leave Manila and it's all reggae and budots music everywhere. The problem is that the music of James has a target market that either isn't into OPM or won't pay attention to him anymore cause he was an actor na mainstream (mej baduy siguro sa mga alta) but his music is pretty good. Kudos for doing something different.
grabe ka naman sa mga hindi taga manila. alam ko maayos ang original music sa visayas region, di ko alam sa iba pero malamang may original music din sila. ang mga bars sa Cebu at CDO, seryosong mga rock bands na original music ang meron whenever I visit.
Nope, mediocre lang talaga kasi yung kanta nya and yes pinakinggan ko tapos ang target class nya pa is mga conyo rich kids na hello, alam natin na mga international song pinapakinggan ng mga yan. Kanta na lang sya ulit ng energy gap baka sakali mag hit!
True! My gosh! Maski jejemon yang Skusta, mas may faneys pa yan kesa kay James. Tigilan na nya yang pa rich kids nya kasi walang pumapansin sa kanya. Nasa masa ang pera. Look at these influencers na hindi nman tlaga mahihirap, nagpapakabakya para lang may manuod at kumita ng pera.
true yan. if gusto mong sumikat dapat ang target mo eh yung masa, hindi yung mga elitista. for example na lang yung anak ni gary v na si kiana. kapag pa-kewl rich kid ka at hindi relatable sa masa ang kanta mo eh hindi ka sisikat.
His market (and all CL singers) not for PH. With that style of music and all english, only few can en enjoy it. If he wants to win PH's music industry, maybe he can produce 1 or 2 tagalog song. Even KPop, their still use their language
Given that his target audience is the international community, he has to be wayyyy better than he currently is because his competition is STIFF. Ang daming magagaling na singers sa YT pa nga lang. At sumisikat sila kahit di magpapansin masyado kasi legit na talented kaya kusang may pumapansin. Even yung mga ibang talented hirap magka-break, tapos si James eh sinisisi na kasalan ng Pinoy fans bakit di sya umaangat sa music industry? Lol.
Tingin ko kay James he wouldn't even try to please Filipino ears. Ganyan kasi yung mga feeling artsy diba mas gusto nila yung indie indie. Kelangan nya lang mahanap yung niche audience nya. Pero syempre wag sya mag expect ng world wide success. Marami namang musikero na very niche ang style kaya kahit maliit lang ang following, considered successful pa rin
Ehh kasi yung market nya di for pinoys ! Hollywood talaga target nya and alam naman natin madami DIN struggling artist sa industry and Mas talented pa kamo.
3:16 So mina-mange ni Liza sarili nya since puri naman sya ang nag-iisip? Tapos may cut yung Careless kahit na sumusunod lang naman sila? Not so smart for Liza , don't you think?š¤
di ba tinulungan daw siya imanage ang spa niya ng careless, after a few months, ayun nagsara. Hindi ba napansin ni Liza na alat itong careless at baka maging ganyan ang kahinatnan ng career niya sa showbiz?
Also, Doesnt matter kung ilan ang kaya mo. Only those that were really good will be remembered for it, kahit nga isa lang yan eh. Jack of all trades, master of none?
Ok naman, may boses, feel good feel good lang mostly ang songs nya. Ang pinoy gusto matinding emosyon -- breakup, union, nationalism. EZmil, SB19, Skusta.. Kahit papano kay niche, nagka small following.
Pang grooving lang songs ni james, tipong papatugtugin mo sa spotify pang chill, pero hindi ifefavorite.
Sakit sa tenga, wala sa tono, puro english at pa cool. Pinoys can't relate. Ang daming ibang options and choices so bakit naman sila mag sesettle sa mediocre.
Actually truth. May talent naman si Nadine, it just that hndi rin sya papatok if hndi s perfect project nya with James (diary ng pangit). Kung hndi nya un nakuha, possibly hanggang ngayon ay side character lng tlga sya.
As for James, i really dont think na magkakaroon sya ng career without that project. Dba nga nawala sya into oblivion dhil nga ang lakas ng sawa factor nya. Super halata pa n pinagkakakitaan nya lng ang mga pinoy. Same career path lang ang end ni James kay na Andre and Fumiya if not because of his loveteam with Nadine
Artista talaga? Hindi ba pwedeng dahil gwapo siya ? Lol sorry. Tsaka yung mga kanta niya hindi naman gaanong catchy kung ipapatugtog yan sa radio ichechange mo ng station
It is not helping he is believing his delusional fans! Please James do a non biased music, brand consult to truly know where to improve and what to enhance and hire a stylist please.
Bilib na bilib talaga to si James sa sarili nya no? As a singer, as a manager.. hay, sumikat ka lang dahil sa loveteam nyo ni Nadine. Aside from that, WALEY.
Do LS really think na uusad ang hollywood career nya sa states eh mismong CEO ng management nya hirap ma hirap to prove himself abroad kaya sa pinoy nanaman kumukuha ng sympathy. Mukang na daan sa promises si LS lol
Puro ganyan rin comments sa kanya sa YouTube. Pero less than 1M subs ang official CM channel, tapos 100K liek lang sa 2M views in 4 months. Ibig sabihin, mahina talaga hatak nya.
In fairness, asawa ko na vocalist, audiophile at nagpproduce ng music - same ng observation. Gusto niya mga songs ni James technically speaking ok daw. Yung image nga lang talaga niya naoovershadow yung talent sa music kaya lowkey lang din asawa ko sa pagadmire kasi baka masira yung “cool guy” image niya. Charot! Pero personally, di ko din magets kasi parang minsan obvious na inspired ng sound ni JB.
Mukhang walang self awareness si James and he’s seeking for validation. Try niya kaya ianalyze muna bakit hindi niya makuha ang taste ng mga tao? And besides, he’s no genius musician para mag-inarte ng ganyan.
Hindi kinakagat ng tao because he lacks charisma plus his music is so-so lng. Jusko. Look at Shawn Mendes and Justin Bieber. Pa YouTube2 lang ang mga yan noon pero they managed to have a fanbase even before a label signed them up. Charisma ang kulang kay James plus his musical skills aren’t really that amazing.
Bakit ung iba di nmn singer pero sumisikat ung song nila like V. G, W. R. at si V. N… siguro catchy ung songs nila ung kay J medyo pang sosyal.. kaya most us can’t relate w…
Not fair to equate these celebs to what filipinos actually listen to. Sikat yung mga kanta ng mga taong binanggit mo kasi tinatarget nila yung mga bata. It's like saying that the whole world prefers baby shark over michael jackson because mas madaming views sa youtube.
no erase 10 minute version irelease mo james papatok yan or energy gap james' version. nasa tuktok ka na kasi tapos lumipat ka pa sa indie, parang baliktad ginawa mo.
This may be an unpopular opinion, but I don't think it's because he's an artista. It's because western and kpop artists pretty much produce the same type of music as he does, but yung final product is very polished. Aside from that, people don't take him seriously not because he does loveteams, romcoms, etc. It's because he has a reputation of being unprofessional and lazy who became famous because of his looks...and despite of getting opportunities that other people would kill for he just coasted along in the industry. I don't know how accurate that is but that's what he's known for, his inability to apply himself. It didn't help that the event he organized recently turned out a disaster.
true. wala sa boses yan e. sa style at structure ng song. kung ka sound lang ng west o kpop, e bakit ka sisikat. naalala ko yung buwan na sa karaoke ko lang narinig na kinakanta ng tita ko. never ko narinig yung original pero may catch talaga yung style nung song.
After reading the comments here, I decided to listen to his song "U&I". As a singer, medyo ordinary yung voice nya, The Weeknd ang datingan (same tone & range). The song itself is catchy and well-produced but not chart-worthy. Dahil medyo basic yung vocals nya, he needs to do something unique to stand out kasi there are millions of musicians who have way more talent.
nasa musicality yan e. ang pinakikinggan kong music ay metal at normal na ng boses na sobrang taas: pero nasa style ng kanta, paano i cut ang phrases, use ng vocal layering o chorus, palamuti, yung surprise na ang ine expect mo ganito ide deliver tapos ibang iba ang gagawin. kung generic na ang music sound mo, maging creative ka sa vocalization mo.
Well, napakinggan ko ang album nya dati. Okey naman. Nagustuhan ko pero ang problem is... parang trying hard to sound international tapos parang di rin makarelate naman mostly sa mga local listeners.
Gusto ko p rin nmn ung boom panes n V.G, Mobe Mobe/Uha Uha n E.G. totoy bibo/ Don romantico n V. N at otso otso n B. Aš … kidding aside they have to get the hearts of Filipino listeners especially ung ordinary invidual or ung masa.. let say their song doesn’t possess charisma u know nmn how great singers Filipinos are.. u just need to get their soft spot or rhythm…
He should stick to songwriting and have someone else perform his songs, medyo ipit at pacute ang boses niya. It does sound auto tuned, it should definitely sound less baby and more adult.
4:31 eh si Echo? Dba sumikat din or umangat din ang name nya dahil sa loveteam nya with Kristine? But he managed to be solo artist dhil may talent, right attitude, and charisma. James only has talent pero mediocre pa.
O anong nangyari sa international career niyan ang taas ng lipad ganyan naman yan inuuto niya mga turds niya well dapat lang hindi suportahan ng pinoy kanta niya at career para magtanda sa kayabangan.
James, masa kasi nagpasikat sayo. Naalala mo ha yung kanta nyo na taglish ni Nadine, No Erase? Pumatok yun eh. Kasi masa yung target mo nun. Eh ang nitatry mo i reach yung mga richkids na way o platform to hear music. Also, sa totoo lang huh, may mga kilala ako ng RK , when they ehar James Reid... Para sa kanila trying hard to be musician ka... For them you re Justin Bieber wanna be.
Actor singers like Sharon, Zsa zsa, Sarah..even IƱigo, JM de Guzman, Daniel have crossed over with more success than James. His tunes are okay, but nothing remarkable. They're technically okay, but forgettable. His voice is meh, sorry. He can carry a tune but to make it as a proper artist? I fun no but his self run managements isn't effective. None of their talents have made a dent. Their target market have international artists on their playlists, and the bar is high.
Delikado pala talaga si Liza kay James. Magaling pa si Ogie diaz eh. Sana hanap si Liza ng sanay na at matagal ng may karanasan humawak ng mga talent. Sayang naman ganda ni Liza at mhahasa pa talent nya in singing and acting.
Ginawa pang rason ang pagiging artista sus! , yeah he can sing pero hndi lng tlga type ng pinoy ung music nya hndi ksi relatable mga songs nya.. tpos sinabi pa nya noon na he wants to change pa daw ung style ng PH music ,! Nahiya nman sila Gary, regine,zsazsa,kz,moira,sa u haha
Hndi nya rin nman type ang mga pinoy kaya nga he didnt even bother to learn our language and culture. He just here dhil alam nya (which the whole world knows) na uhaw sa international recognition and foreigners ang mga pinoy. Kya nga rin very strong ang pinoy clickbaiters and bandwagonners(proud to be pinoy).
Masyadong bilib sa sarili ah james ,ni wla ngang kanta na tlgang pumatok sa PH music scene eh, kung meron man yung mga dating kanta nya pero under viva yun at ung duets nila ky Nadine, yung lng pumatok no!
Mga kanta nia parang laging me kulang. Walang dating. Walang "nakakaakit pakinggan" factor. Laging malungkot. Di ko alam kung kulang b sa instruments or sadyang boring lang talaga
On separate occasions, I, my husband and my sister (both are musicians) heard his song on the radio dati and thought it was of an international artist. Only after an internet search did we find out that it was him. Not to say that he's a genius, but he's actually good! Definitely not pang-masa. Probably why hirap sya mag breakthrough locally kasi hindi talaga pang local yung sound nya. still respect him for not selling out being true to the music he wants to out out there.
Actually, maganda music ni james. Kung pakikinggan mo, parang foreign music siya. Kaya hindi siya pumatok dito kasi iba ang taste ng mga pinoy sa kantahan. Admit it, ang gusto ng pinoy eh ung medyo bakya na music. Biritan, ballad, ganun
On the contrary, it's because may access sa foreign music ang mga pinoy, so of course they'd listen to those foreign artists instead of a local artist producing the exact same type of music. Yung mga binibigyan mong shade na mahilig sa "bakya" na music hindi na yun representative ng mga nagcoconsume ng music nowadays. Young gen Ys and gen zs listen to the music that is very similar to the type of music james makes (a huge percent if not the entirety of the song pinroduce sa software using samples, hindi masyadong priority yung vocals and instead focuses on "vibes") but since they have so many options the music really needs to stand out amongst the rest.
Beh, super sikat nga ang western and kpop music sa ating bansa and yet James still have difficulty penetrating here. Wala nga katapusan ang pagcocover and revive ng mga so called singers here na theyre only know to be cover queens (and kings). So make this short, sadyang walang charm and mediocre si james.
True baks. Infairness sa mga Marites this time eh hindi inuna ang pangbabash but really give an honest opinion kung bakit di sumikat sikat ang kanta ni James. š Kung sino mang faney ng Careless, pakisabi kay James what lacking.
Alam mo kung bakit James? Paprangkahin na kita, di ka kagalingan, you have a talent naman pero mas madami magaling sayo and mas interesting. Wala kang appeal. And thanks to Philippine showbiz. Magaling sila maghype ng tulad mo. After PBB hindi ka naman sikat pero with the right management sumikat ka.
Actually ang maganda nyanh kanta ay yung mga under ng Viva hahaha. Yung no erase, hanap hanap, at bahala na. Ganun ata talaga pag may experience na ang management alam na alam kung ano ang papatok sa masa.
Club music kasi amg genre nya. Hindi naman club goers ang majority ng filipino. Napakinggan ko ung album nya. And hindi mo iisipin na c james reid un. Ang problema, hindi nya market ang pinas. So kung gusto nya ipursue ang music, good decision yung pag alis nya dito.
Ewan ko lang yung kay liza kasi market nya pilipino eh.
James' fatal flaw is not knowing how to take care / cultivate his fanbase. He openly criticizes them on foreign podcasts and act very indifferent about them. Which makes this behavior all the more weird.
Kasi his toxic “fanbase” wants to stop him from growing. Property yung tingin sa kanya. Real fans will support growth, not pull you down just because you want to spread your wings and try your luck out there.
Bakit ang daming pinoy na haters? Ganyan na ba talaga ka insecure ang mga Pinoy? Mag ttrabaho ng tapat ang mga artists. Pero dinidiscourage, nilalait. Etc same people na di naman bumibili ng albums nila or nanonood ng movies nila. Pero grabe manglait at mang down. You don’t have to be a fan. Pero para i-bash ang mga artista, just because feeling niyo may right kayo? Mas pathetic pa kayo and obviously insecure sa mga buhay niyo.
Nasa chismis site ka di ba? Eh bakit ka nangangaliti? People are here to discuss and point out their observations, it just so happens na totoo yung mga sinasabi nila.
11:00 I wholeheartedly agree with you. The anonymity on the internet has given people a false sense of power and public personas are the easiest target. James is young and will make mistakes, but I find him earnest and willing to forge a path towards his ideal self. Kung anak ko siya, sasabihin ko sa kanya, “Ipagpatuloy mo lang ‘yan, anak. Nothing is wasted.”
12:16 Dapat affected ka din.š You’re part of society and it’s going to the dogs.
1:29 Yung Careless team ni James pera at hype lang ang habol sa Pinas. Diba koreaboo ang image ngayon nila James at ng talent nya bat sa pinoy sya ngayon humihingi ng simpatya.
Hurt kasi kayong mga faneys kasi totoo ang karamihan sa mga observation nila. Hello, dapat nga dito magbasa c James at yang kumpanya nya kasi totoo yang mga pinagsasabi ng mga Marites here. Kung gusto lang nman ni James magsucceed. Wag nyong gawing delulu c James dahil sa kapiranggot na faneys na enabler. He‘ll never succeed kung walang magsasabi sa kanya what‘s lacking. Magsasayang lang sya ng pera.
di man yan ang be-all at end-all ng FP ay malaking parte yan. kaya kami tambay dito kasi pampaalis namin ng boredom ang pagcomment sa mga tsismis. bago ka lang siguro dito at nag click lang dahil kay james mo
hoy 11:00 Hindi po ito site para purihin ang mga artista or singers na walang kwenta. Yung mga mayayabang na artista binibigyan namin ng Reality Check. Kasi kung minsan sobrang taas ng tingin sa sarili nila kaya inilalagay namin sa lupa ang mga paa. Mayayabang masyado.
To be fair to James marunong naman sya gumawa ng kanta. He may not be the best song writer pero yung music nya is pwede na. I think kaunti pang experience, he'll get there. Basta tuloy tuloy lang. Isa pa, he has to market his music to his specific audience kasi obviously it's not for everyone.
Mukhang hindi rin naman nya talaga type ang acting, so focus na lang sya in honing his musical skills. Not necessarily yung singing part pero yung pagproduce.
James wala ka naman kasing extraordinary talent or originality. Hwag sisihin ang pagiging artista mo kaya di ka popular in the music scene.. kasi you are basic.
He’s a talented musician naman. Some of his songs are very catchy, he just sounds too auto-tuned and the Phils is not the right market for his genre so he will never succeed there as a singer.
There are similar international songs which Filipinos appreciate, but you can hear the difference in voice quality talaga. May gigil at emote kumbaga. Di gaya ng songs nito na boring at parang memakanta lang go na. Walang hugot mapa-happy o sad o angsty. Flat in the sense na walang feels kasi yung kumakanta parang nagpa-practice lang.
Yon kanta nga ni Nadine na paligoy ligoy na nasa baul na, nahalungkat ulit at nag trending pa sa tiktok, bakit kamo kasi relatable. Yumabang na din si James, ayaw na nya balikan yon sisiw days nya, hindi nya na appreciate yon mga kanta nya under viva na sumikat naman sa masa. Actually yon Summer lang talaga na kanta nila ni Nadine ang nasa playlist ko. Atchaka na discover ko din yon music vid colab ni Yasi and Nadine, nagustuhan ko nga bat kaya di sumikat yon, authentic Ppop ang sound nya.
Wow, complaining about not being appreciated by the local audience when he doesn't even care to cultivate his fanbase. In fact, nilalayo nga nya ang sarili sa masa dahil sa isip nya he is way too cool for these people. Gusto pala sumikat as musician to , eh dapat noon pa lang na binigyan sya ng opportunity to work in Showtime dapat ginalingan nya at naging professional sya instead na umabsent at magwalwal.
Naalala ko pa nagguest sya sa vlog ni Ryan Bang, ang lantoy lantoy nya sumagot, hindi man lang nageelaborate, isang tanong isang sagot lang, mukha talaga sya napilitan magguest. Ngayon ang baksa din pala nya sa youtube, magvlog ng ganap ng CL, na wala naman talagang ganap. Mas marami pa ngan views and subscribers si Ryan Bang kaysa kay James. Dahil yon nageffort matuto magtagalog at talagang mahal nya ang pinas kaya mahal din sya ng madlang pipol.
So pinakinggan ko mga songs nya. First, di pang masang pinoy at short din pang international. nothing extra ordinary para mapansin ka internationally. Marami na kapareho sound yung songs mo. Second, weak din marketing mo and connections. Third, maliit boses mo haha.
Majority of pinoy hindi type ang music ni james. Iba ang market niya. Pero hindi panget music niya. May vibe ng foreign artist ung music niya. Magugulat ka na lang na siya pala yun. Ma attitude lang talaga. Naalala ko pa nung nag shoot sila ng commercial ni nadine sa manda nag request ng picture yung anak ng friend ko. Inisnob lang nila
Lahat ng nagcomment dito sinasabi hindi Pinoy ang market niya, so bakit pinipilit ni James at nagagalit pa sa mga pinoys na di siya sumisikat? Eh di doon sa US radios niya ipatugtog mga kanta niya. Yun naman pala market niya.
Saka napakayabang kasi. He acts as if he is better than everyone in the PH. So ayan, huwag magtaka kung hindi ka rin gusto ng mga pinoys.
ayan kaya hingalo na ang career niyan. Buti nga at wala na si Nadine under their spell at medyo bumabawi na ngayon ang career. This James group is bad news.
ang dami na kasing ganyan. tsaka hindi na rin ganyan ang taste ng karamihan ng Pinoy eh. Kung tatargetin niya Western, bat pa yan pakikinggan dun eh kung mga kamukha nila ginagawa na yan? Pag artist ka, hindi lang music labanan ngayon, pati sarili mo na tlga. kung ang BTS nga, halos same din nung sa 90s pero sikat na sikat sila not only because of music, naging bentahe nila yung mga pa-advocacy nila then fan service pa.
Ang tanging makakapag-judge kung magaling syang musician eh yung mga nakikinig ng mga kanta nya. Sabi nila di daw kasi pang-masa. Sabi ng iba mas pang-international ang market nya. Asan na yang specific market na mga yan? Magparamdam sila. Bat di natin maramdamang nakikinig sila sa music ni James? Pwede nyang i-market ang sarili any way he wants dahil kanya ang management company. Nasa kanya na ang lahat ng resources pero asan ang mga nakikinig? If he's really that good siguro naman may hype ano? Lalo na sa presence ng soc med at bilis ng word of mouth ngayon.
para siyang knock off na Justin Beiber kaya hindi sumikat sa Hollywood. Hindi din sumikat sa Pilipinas dahil hindi magets ng mga Pilipino ang genre niya. Sana magising naman sa katotohanan ito at tigilan na ang hollywood dreams.
Nasa kanya na ang bola, kumbava. Kanya ang Careless. He has the final say sa lahat - songs, creative direction, promotion and marketing. If he's really that good tapos kontrolado pa nya lahat, parang dapat ata by this time inembrace na ng mga tao ang music nya? Kahit sabihin mong di masa, sana may word of mouth man lang mula sa mga taong nakikinig? Besides, andaling magviral ng isang magandang kabta sa soc med these says.
Ewan ko, may something off sa kanya. I remember he did a collab with JayB of GOT7, pero he did not even follow him sa IG, occasionally he tagged him during the promotions. Medyo off lang. Felt like he used JayB's popularity lang haha.
jusmiyo corazon! wala siyang talent sa music! ano puro autotune? hindi yan uso dito sa pinas (well,meron naman pala yung mga rapper)
ReplyDeleteBeg to differ. He can sing and makes good songs, actually. Problem is he doesn't have the charisma to sway people, let alone most his fans who supported him as an actor to listen to his music. If only he can make at least one hit song, that'd be enough for people to take his singing seriously.
DeleteMga faney niya na delusional yan lol
Deletetrue ka diyan sissy
DeleteDi din natin ito sure. Usually pag ABS hype, auto tuned yarn! Maymay is the best example, uso sya. Support ang mga kapamilya fantards.
DeleteHindi nga maintindihan ang words niya. Autotune.
DeleteFeeling Bruno Mars pa ang peg.
You can't force people to listen to your songs if feelingero ka, di ba? Good attitude rin sana.
After pbb he used to sing live with him playing a guitar. Maayos naman.
DeleteHindi composer si James Reid. Ang composer ang gumagawa ng music. Delusional yang mga faney nya.
DeleteTbh im surprised his songs are actually quite good, yes i think tama si 12:58, kinulang sya sa appeal to sway casual listeners
Delete12:58 If he is a good musician, how come na wala syang hit song kahit isa?
DeleteHoy James, Gising!
DeleteKung may talent naman sa music isusupport. Ang daming singers and band ngayon na waley sa physical at nagsimula sa walabg pangalan pero recognized ang musical talent. James maybe able to sing and compose pero hindi outstanding.napakadaming musicians at singer sa Pilipinas and dapat angat ang galing para mapansin.
DeleteMali yan lol.. bat naman si jericho rosales kahit artista sumikat as singer… baka ung music mo di patok sa masa james
DeleteJames can sing. But his songs are boooooring! There are two songs nadine made under careless that I liked. Kay James wala ni isa na maganda .
DeleteEh yung boses niya kase parang inipit, maliit na boses na halatang galing sa maliit na tao.
DeleteKaloka si 12:38 hahaha si Nadine ang walang talent sa music. Gusto ko yung Palm Dream ni James pero tong 2nd album niya di ko type and di ko maintindihan lyrics niya grabe sa slang.
Delete6:18 Si Bayani Agbayani may hit song, yung Otso-Otso. He's a good musician, right?
DeleteNope. Not sure, not my taste
ReplyDeletein all fairness, ang feeling ni james hahahaha feel na feel eh wala naman talagang talent sa music, ni hindi marunong kumanta o magproduce ng music.
ReplyDeleteMay i know what song was the commentor referring to? As a music lover, i dont care about singers that much. If they got good song, I am all for it.
ReplyDeleteNo commentš¤£
ReplyDeleteni hindi nga magaling na artista si james. dekada na sa pinas pero di pa rin alam mag straight tagalog. as music artist pa kaya na di nga marunong kumanta. geez
ReplyDeleteEh wala nman kasi tlgang care si James sa pagiging pinoy nya. All he care is pagkakitaan ang mga pinoy. And thats a fact
DeleteFinally ☝️
DeleteNgeeee i dont think so lol. Madami lang talaga mas may talent talaga kesa sayo james. Tulog ka na at isipin mo how to promote your artists better.
ReplyDeleteTALENT? Anong talent? Your music is just not our cup of tea. Magtagalog ka. Do better!
ReplyDeleteDi tayo ang target market nya dzai haha
Delete104, yung target market nya di din sya type nun. So paano yun? š¤£
Deletetruee
DeleteTrust me bro if ur music is really that good as you claim and believe - the people will notice.
ReplyDeleteTotally agree 12:01, Filipinos with their inclination to music can easily identify a good singer, song, composer it will organically become popular! So please James, if you’re really an “artist” just go on creating music until you make it. Stop listening to your biased faneys.
DeleteThat's not completely true. Filipino tastes can be very fixed. Leave Manila and it's all reggae and budots music everywhere. The problem is that the music of James has a target market that either isn't into OPM or won't pay attention to him anymore cause he was an actor na mainstream (mej baduy siguro sa mga alta) but his music is pretty good. Kudos for doing something different.
DeleteKung magaling tlga siya at di Pinas ang target market nya eh di sana na-notice na siya sa US!
DeleteTrue! Yung latest album nya sounds like the weekend, lany wlang originality
Deletegrabe ka naman sa mga hindi taga manila. alam ko maayos ang original music sa visayas region, di ko alam sa iba pero malamang may original music din sila. ang mga bars sa Cebu at CDO, seryosong mga rock bands na original music ang meron whenever I visit.
Delete1:47 Cebuano ang Urbandub.
DeleteNope, mediocre lang talaga kasi yung kanta nya and yes pinakinggan ko tapos ang target class nya pa is mga conyo rich kids na hello, alam natin na mga international song pinapakinggan ng mga yan. Kanta na lang sya ulit ng energy gap baka sakali mag hit!
ReplyDeleteLol energy gap!
DeleteCatchy pa naman yung song na yun
Hahahahha shuta natawa ako sa energy gap!
DeleteAng cringe grabehan na ito
ReplyDeleteMakipag collab ka kay Skusta clee kung gusto mo pansinin ka ng masa James Reid.. Ceo ka nga pero wala ka namang matinong market Researcher .
ReplyDeleteNadadaan ka sa sulsol
True! My gosh! Maski jejemon yang Skusta, mas may faneys pa yan kesa kay James. Tigilan na nya yang pa rich kids nya kasi walang pumapansin sa kanya. Nasa masa ang pera. Look at these influencers na hindi nman tlaga mahihirap, nagpapakabakya para lang may manuod at kumita ng pera.
DeleteSumikat sa masa is not the only form of success. Kung hindi naman siya masaya magpakamasa, what's the point?
DeleteExactly 1235. Yung paconyo nya kasi sa middle class or mayayamann ang target. Eh sympre yung mga ganun international na ang type di na kagaya nya.
Deletetrue yan. if gusto mong sumikat dapat ang target mo eh yung masa, hindi yung mga elitista. for example na lang yung anak ni gary v na si kiana. kapag pa-kewl rich kid ka at hindi relatable sa masa ang kanta mo eh hindi ka sisikat.
Delete7:07 Masaya ba sya ngayon sa tingin mo ? š
DeleteNgayon pinapansin nya mga tard nya na halos isuka na nya noon lol
ReplyDeleteCue in “babalik ka rin”
His market (and all CL singers) not for PH. With that style of music and all english, only few can en enjoy it. If he wants to win PH's music industry, maybe he can produce 1 or 2 tagalog song. Even KPop, their still use their language
ReplyDeleteGiven that his target audience is the international community, he has to be wayyyy better than he currently is because his competition is STIFF. Ang daming magagaling na singers sa YT pa nga lang. At sumisikat sila kahit di magpapansin masyado kasi legit na talented kaya kusang may pumapansin. Even yung mga ibang talented hirap magka-break, tapos si James eh sinisisi na kasalan ng Pinoy fans bakit di sya umaangat sa music industry? Lol.
DeleteTingin ko kay James he wouldn't even try to please Filipino ears. Ganyan kasi yung mga feeling artsy diba mas gusto nila yung indie indie. Kelangan nya lang mahanap yung niche audience nya. Pero syempre wag sya mag expect ng world wide success. Marami namang musikero na very niche ang style kaya kahit maliit lang ang following, considered successful pa rin
DeleteMagaganda songs nya dati nung kay thyro and yumi yung composer.
DeleteEhh kasi yung market nya di for pinoys ! Hollywood talaga target nya and alam naman natin madami DIN struggling artist sa industry and Mas talented pa kamo.
Delete2:39 Eh bakit pinoy ang sinisisi nya at ng fans nya bakit stagnant ang music career nya
DeleteFlex flex flex lang
ReplyDelete“Was” james intindihin bago repost ok yun lang naman.
ReplyDeleteEwan ko sa yo James š Liza I still wish you the best.
ReplyDeleteLiza it's not too late to change management and direction.
DeleteBut based on OD yan ang gusto ni Liza and Careless is just following her leads.
Delete3:16 So mina-mange ni Liza sarili nya since puri naman sya ang nag-iisip? Tapos may cut yung Careless kahit na sumusunod lang naman sila? Not so smart for Liza , don't you think?š¤
Deletedi ba tinulungan daw siya imanage ang spa niya ng careless, after a few months, ayun nagsara. Hindi ba napansin ni Liza na alat itong careless at baka maging ganyan ang kahinatnan ng career niya sa showbiz?
DeleteAhh ugh uhm oki šš»
ReplyDeleteHe’s a recording artists but not a singer
ReplyDeleteHe gets overlooked because his music is not worthy of being recognized. š
ReplyDelete"Was" talaga? Tapos na? Lol.
ReplyDeleteAlso, Doesnt matter kung ilan ang kaya mo. Only those that were really good will be remembered for it, kahit nga isa lang yan eh. Jack of all trades, master of none?
Ok naman, may boses, feel good feel good lang mostly ang songs nya. Ang pinoy gusto matinding emosyon -- breakup, union, nationalism. EZmil, SB19, Skusta.. Kahit papano kay niche, nagka small following.
Pang grooving lang songs ni james, tipong papatugtugin mo sa spotify pang chill, pero hindi ifefavorite.
Two people? Baka nga scripted pa yan. Whatever floats your boat, James.
ReplyDeleteSakit sa tenga, wala sa tono, puro english at pa cool. Pinoys can't relate. Ang daming ibang options and choices so bakit naman sila mag sesettle sa mediocre.
ReplyDeleteGrabe ang inflated ego nito. Lol
ReplyDeleteHe has a beautiful voice Naman but his music is too pa-cool! Trying hard tuloy ang outcome
ReplyDeleteWithout Nadine's talent and without a loveteam, nobody will even notice you james.
ReplyDeleteNadine is not a singer. She always lypsinc.
DeleteActually š¤
DeleteActually truth. May talent naman si Nadine, it just that hndi rin sya papatok if hndi s perfect project nya with James (diary ng pangit). Kung hndi nya un nakuha, possibly hanggang ngayon ay side character lng tlga sya.
DeleteAs for James, i really dont think na magkakaroon sya ng career without that project. Dba nga nawala sya into oblivion dhil nga ang lakas ng sawa factor nya. Super halata pa n pinagkakakitaan nya lng ang mga pinoy. Same career path lang ang end ni James kay na Andre and Fumiya if not because of his loveteam with Nadine
Puro kasi walwal ang inatupag so how can people take you guys seriously?
ReplyDeleteDelusional much? š
ReplyDeleteThe blonde hair is so unflattering on him.
ReplyDeleteArtista talaga? Hindi ba pwedeng dahil gwapo siya ? Lol sorry. Tsaka yung mga kanta niya hindi naman gaanong catchy kung ipapatugtog yan sa radio ichechange mo ng station
ReplyDeleteMagaling sa auto tune????
ReplyDeleteLuh waley ka naman ng talent sa music eh
ReplyDeleteAyaw kasi mag Pilipino na music. Eh mas makamasa yung pinoy language
ReplyDeleteSomeone get this guy a reality check. Feelingero at delusional much.
ReplyDeleteIt is not helping he is believing his delusional fans! Please James do a non biased music, brand consult to truly know where to improve and what to enhance and hire a stylist please.
DeleteBilib na bilib talaga to si James sa sarili nya no? As a singer, as a manager.. hay, sumikat ka lang dahil sa loveteam nyo ni Nadine. Aside from that, WALEY.
ReplyDeleteThank you AbsCbn for the hype lang talaga sya
DeleteDo LS really think na uusad ang hollywood career nya sa states eh mismong CEO ng management nya hirap ma hirap to prove himself abroad kaya sa pinoy nanaman kumukuha ng sympathy. Mukang na daan sa promises si LS lol
ReplyDeletehndi nmn mgaling kumanta. dinaan lng sa itsura. ni umarte waley din bulol mgtgalog.
ReplyDeletePR. iisa ang script
ReplyDeletePuro ganyan rin comments sa kanya sa YouTube. Pero less than 1M subs ang official CM channel, tapos 100K liek lang sa 2M views in 4 months. Ibig sabihin, mahina talaga hatak nya.
DeleteIn fairness, asawa ko na vocalist, audiophile at nagpproduce ng music - same ng observation. Gusto niya mga songs ni James technically speaking ok daw. Yung image nga lang talaga niya naoovershadow yung talent sa music kaya lowkey lang din asawa ko sa pagadmire kasi baka masira yung “cool guy” image niya. Charot! Pero personally, di ko din magets kasi parang minsan obvious na inspired ng sound ni JB.
ReplyDeleteako din okay naman for me ung songs nya tho di ko din sya fina follow talaga
DeleteWala namang bakas na pagiging pinoy ang music mo, so ano na dong?
ReplyDeleteNah, popular opinion got it right with James :)
ReplyDeleteMukhang walang self awareness si James and he’s seeking for validation. Try niya kaya ianalyze muna bakit hindi niya makuha ang taste ng mga tao? And besides, he’s no genius musician para mag-inarte ng ganyan.
ReplyDeleteHe is mediocre at best. Laklak muna ng realidad koyah. He has delusions of grandeur.
ReplyDeleteHindi kinakagat ng tao because he lacks charisma plus his music is so-so lng. Jusko. Look at Shawn Mendes and Justin Bieber. Pa YouTube2 lang ang mga yan noon pero they managed to have a fanbase even before a label signed them up. Charisma ang kulang kay James plus his musical skills aren’t really that amazing.
ReplyDeleteBakit ung iba di nmn singer pero sumisikat ung song nila like V. G, W. R. at si V. N… siguro catchy ung songs nila ung kay J medyo pang sosyal.. kaya most us can’t relate w…
ReplyDeletesinong mga yan?
Deletevice Ganda; Willie Revillame at Vhong Navarro atah…
Delete1:31 beh, next please wag mo nang ipaghiwalay ang mga abbreviated named because thats not how FP peeps do or used to.
Delete12:45 thanks
Not fair to equate these celebs to what filipinos actually listen to. Sikat yung mga kanta ng mga taong binanggit mo kasi tinatarget nila yung mga bata. It's like saying that the whole world prefers baby shark over michael jackson because mas madaming views sa youtube.
DeleteHAHAHAHAHA!
ReplyDeleteno erase 10 minute version irelease mo james papatok yan or energy gap james' version. nasa tuktok ka na kasi tapos lumipat ka pa sa indie, parang baliktad ginawa mo.
ReplyDeleteHayme! Gumising ka na!!!
ReplyDeletenge di naman siya naka-tag? sinesearch niya sarili niya sa twitter waha
ReplyDeleteBakit naman WAS, dude is still alive. š
ReplyDeleteThis may be an unpopular opinion, but I don't think it's because he's an artista. It's because western and kpop artists pretty much produce the same type of music as he does, but yung final product is very polished. Aside from that, people don't take him seriously not because he does loveteams, romcoms, etc. It's because he has a reputation of being unprofessional and lazy who became famous because of his looks...and despite of getting opportunities that other people would kill for he just coasted along in the industry. I don't know how accurate that is but that's what he's known for, his inability to apply himself. It didn't help that the event he organized recently turned out a disaster.
ReplyDeletevery apt observation.
Deletetrue. wala sa boses yan e. sa style at structure ng song. kung ka sound lang ng west o kpop, e bakit ka sisikat. naalala ko yung buwan na sa karaoke ko lang narinig na kinakanta ng tita ko. never ko narinig yung original pero may catch talaga yung style nung song.
DeleteFeeling ko hit ang kanta if di si james ang kumanta
ReplyDeleteAfter reading the comments here, I decided to listen to his song "U&I". As a singer, medyo ordinary yung voice nya, The Weeknd ang datingan (same tone & range). The song itself is catchy and well-produced but not chart-worthy. Dahil medyo basic yung vocals nya, he needs to do something unique to stand out kasi there are millions of musicians who have way more talent.
ReplyDeletenasa musicality yan e. ang pinakikinggan kong music ay metal at normal na ng boses na sobrang taas: pero nasa style ng kanta, paano i cut ang phrases, use ng vocal layering o chorus, palamuti, yung surprise na ang ine expect mo ganito ide deliver tapos ibang iba ang gagawin. kung generic na ang music sound mo, maging creative ka sa vocalization mo.
DeleteTalent..so…so. It Factor? Nope!
ReplyDeleteWell, napakinggan ko ang album nya dati. Okey naman. Nagustuhan ko pero ang problem is... parang trying hard to sound international tapos parang di rin makarelate naman mostly sa mga local listeners.
ReplyDeleteGusto ko p rin nmn ung boom panes n V.G, Mobe Mobe/Uha Uha n E.G. totoy bibo/ Don romantico n V. N at otso otso n B. Aš … kidding aside they have to get the hearts of Filipino listeners especially ung ordinary invidual or ung masa.. let say their song doesn’t possess charisma u know nmn how great singers Filipinos are.. u just need to get their soft spot or rhythm…
ReplyDeleteKumanta ka kse ng Ama Kabogera baka mapansin ka pa James
ReplyDeletePa cool music
ReplyDeleteAnd pa cool label: careless.
DeleteHe should stick to songwriting and have someone else perform his songs, medyo ipit at pacute ang boses niya. It does sound auto tuned, it should definitely sound less baby and more adult.
ReplyDeletesa loveteam kasi siya nakilala. kaya nung nag solo nahirapan.
ReplyDelete4:31 eh si Echo? Dba sumikat din or umangat din ang name nya dahil sa loveteam nya with Kristine? But he managed to be solo artist dhil may talent, right attitude, and charisma. James only has talent pero mediocre pa.
DeleteO anong nangyari sa international career niyan ang taas ng lipad ganyan naman yan inuuto niya mga turds niya well dapat lang hindi suportahan ng pinoy kanta niya at career para magtanda sa kayabangan.
ReplyDeleteMay recall si James as laging walwal at unprofessional
ReplyDeleteJames, masa kasi nagpasikat sayo. Naalala mo ha yung kanta nyo na taglish ni Nadine, No Erase? Pumatok yun eh. Kasi masa yung target mo nun. Eh ang nitatry mo i reach yung mga richkids na way o platform to hear music. Also, sa totoo lang huh, may mga kilala ako ng RK , when they ehar James Reid... Para sa kanila trying hard to be musician ka... For them you re Justin Bieber wanna be.
ReplyDeleteActor singers like Sharon, Zsa zsa, Sarah..even IƱigo, JM de Guzman, Daniel have crossed over with more success than James. His tunes are okay, but nothing remarkable. They're technically okay, but forgettable. His voice is meh, sorry. He can carry a tune but to make it as a proper artist? I fun no but his self run managements isn't effective. None of their talents have made a dent. Their target market have international artists on their playlists, and the bar is high.
ReplyDeleteDelikado pala talaga si Liza kay James. Magaling pa si Ogie diaz eh. Sana hanap si Liza ng sanay na at matagal ng may karanasan humawak ng mga talent. Sayang naman ganda ni Liza at mhahasa pa talent nya in singing and acting.
ReplyDeleteLiza should go to talent agencies sa US & start from the beginning over there.
DeleteGinawa pang rason ang pagiging artista sus! , yeah he can sing pero hndi lng tlga type ng pinoy ung music nya hndi ksi relatable mga songs nya.. tpos sinabi pa nya noon na he wants to change pa daw ung style ng PH music ,! Nahiya nman sila Gary, regine,zsazsa,kz,moira,sa u haha
ReplyDeleteHndi nya rin nman type ang mga pinoy kaya nga he didnt even bother to learn our language and culture. He just here dhil alam nya (which the whole world knows) na uhaw sa international recognition and foreigners ang mga pinoy. Kya nga rin very strong ang pinoy clickbaiters and bandwagonners(proud to be pinoy).
DeleteMasyadong bilib sa sarili ah james ,ni wla ngang kanta na tlgang pumatok sa PH music scene eh, kung meron man yung mga dating kanta nya pero under viva yun at ung duets nila ky Nadine, yung lng pumatok no!
ReplyDeleteAng alam ko lang na kanta nya ay yung Energy Gap hahaha
DeleteMga kanta nia parang laging me kulang. Walang dating. Walang "nakakaakit pakinggan" factor. Laging malungkot. Di ko alam kung kulang b sa instruments or sadyang boring lang talaga
ReplyDeleteOn separate occasions, I, my husband and my sister (both are musicians) heard his song on the radio dati and thought it was of an international artist. Only after an internet search did we find out that it was him. Not to say that he's a genius, but he's actually good! Definitely not pang-masa. Probably why hirap sya mag breakthrough locally kasi hindi talaga pang local yung sound nya. still respect him for not selling out being true to the music he wants to out out there.
ReplyDeleteActually, maganda music ni james. Kung pakikinggan mo, parang foreign music siya. Kaya hindi siya pumatok dito kasi iba ang taste ng mga pinoy sa kantahan. Admit it, ang gusto ng pinoy eh ung medyo bakya na music. Biritan, ballad, ganun
ReplyDeleteHindi bakya ang biritan at ballad. Ang bakya yung Budots.
DeleteOn the contrary, it's because may access sa foreign music ang mga pinoy, so of course they'd listen to those foreign artists instead of a local artist producing the exact same type of music. Yung mga binibigyan mong shade na mahilig sa "bakya" na music hindi na yun representative ng mga nagcoconsume ng music nowadays. Young gen Ys and gen zs listen to the music that is very similar to the type of music james makes (a huge percent if not the entirety of the song pinroduce sa software using samples, hindi masyadong priority yung vocals and instead focuses on "vibes") but since they have so many options the music really needs to stand out amongst the rest.
DeleteBeh, super sikat nga ang western and kpop music sa ating bansa and yet James still have difficulty penetrating here. Wala nga katapusan ang pagcocover and revive ng mga so called singers here na theyre only know to be cover queens (and kings). So make this short, sadyang walang charm and mediocre si james.
DeleteHahahahahahah halaa ang feeling nya hahaha
ReplyDeleteSana nagbabasa dito si james kasi ang daming constructive criticisms at feedback and even suggestions.
ReplyDeleteDito ka na mag hire ng market researcher mo James baka kumita pa music mo.
True baks. Infairness sa mga Marites this time eh hindi inuna ang pangbabash but really give an honest opinion kung bakit di sumikat sikat ang kanta ni James. š Kung sino mang faney ng Careless, pakisabi kay James what lacking.
DeleteHaha lol. Retweet na lang ang post ng iilang blind followers nia.
ReplyDeletemasyadong pa kewl ang music ni james.. people listen to music that they can relate, hindi yung puros pa-kewl lang. kulang sa substance kumbaga.
ReplyDeleteYung mga kanta ni Nicki Minaj na Superbass wala naman subtance yun pero catchy kasi hahaha. Galing kasi mag produce ng ibang bansa.
DeleteAlam mo kung bakit James? Paprangkahin na kita, di ka kagalingan, you have a talent naman pero mas madami magaling sayo and mas interesting. Wala kang appeal. And thanks to Philippine showbiz. Magaling sila maghype ng tulad mo. After PBB hindi ka naman sikat pero with the right management sumikat ka.
ReplyDeleteTHIS 100 percent!
Deletenapaka sweet ng boses nya sarap sa ears ulit ulitin, kulang lang sa promo kaya di mabenta. need pati ng mas maraming sponsor
ReplyDeleteActually ang maganda nyanh kanta ay yung mga under ng Viva hahaha. Yung no erase, hanap hanap, at bahala na. Ganun ata talaga pag may experience na ang management alam na alam kung ano ang papatok sa masa.
ReplyDeleteChaka nga nya kumanta eh. walang kabuhay buhay lalo na sa live. Kung di pogi yan wala na yang career. Chaka pa umakting š¤Ŗ
ReplyDeleteGrabe siya rin nag aangat ng sarili nyang bangko. Kafal naman ng ganun
ReplyDeleteYung conyo kids music niya hindi papatok sa mga conyo kasi tayong Pinoy mahilig sa foreign artists.
ReplyDeleteNope, Never haah
ReplyDeleteClub music kasi amg genre nya. Hindi naman club goers ang majority ng filipino. Napakinggan ko ung album nya. And hindi mo iisipin na c james reid un. Ang problema, hindi nya market ang pinas. So kung gusto nya ipursue ang music, good decision yung pag alis nya dito.
ReplyDeleteEwan ko lang yung kay liza kasi market nya pilipino eh.
Biglang nagpapansin ang blond guy ah, kylangan nyang mag ingay at mgpapansin nkakalimutan na sya ng tao haha,mga jtardeds lng nman ded na ded jan š¤£
ReplyDeleteJames' fatal flaw is not knowing how to take care / cultivate his fanbase. He openly criticizes them on foreign podcasts and act very indifferent about them. Which makes this behavior all the more weird.
ReplyDeleteKasi his toxic “fanbase” wants to stop him from growing. Property yung tingin sa kanya. Real fans will support growth, not pull you down just because you want to spread your wings and try your luck out there.
Deletedyusmiyo growth! parqng ingrown. Dapat idefine muna ni James ano ang target market ng kanta niya kasi matumal.
DeletePlain and simple kng hindi ka bet hindi ka bet. Sure naman kng gusto ka ng tao sana na sold out agad yang concert mo at hindi mo kinacel.
ReplyDeleteBakit ang daming pinoy na haters? Ganyan na ba talaga ka insecure ang mga Pinoy? Mag ttrabaho ng tapat ang mga artists. Pero dinidiscourage, nilalait. Etc same people na di naman bumibili ng albums nila or nanonood ng movies nila. Pero grabe manglait at mang down. You don’t have to be a fan. Pero para i-bash ang mga artista, just because feeling niyo may right kayo? Mas pathetic pa kayo and obviously insecure sa mga buhay niyo.
ReplyDeleteWhy are you so affected dear? Chill ka lang, this is the Internet.
DeleteNasa chismis site ka di ba? Eh bakit ka nangangaliti? People are here to discuss and point out their observations, it just so happens na totoo yung mga sinasabi nila.
Delete11:00 I wholeheartedly agree with you. The anonymity on the internet has given people a false sense of power and public personas are the easiest target. James is young and will make mistakes, but I find him earnest and willing to forge a path towards his ideal self. Kung anak ko siya, sasabihin ko sa kanya, “Ipagpatuloy mo lang ‘yan, anak. Nothing is wasted.”
Delete12:16 Dapat affected ka din.š You’re part of society and it’s going to the dogs.
1:29 Yung Careless team ni James pera at hype lang ang habol sa Pinas. Diba koreaboo ang image ngayon nila James at ng talent nya bat sa pinoy sya ngayon humihingi ng simpatya.
DeleteHurt kasi kayong mga faneys kasi totoo ang karamihan sa mga observation nila. Hello, dapat nga dito magbasa c James at yang kumpanya nya kasi totoo yang mga pinagsasabi ng mga Marites here. Kung gusto lang nman ni James magsucceed. Wag nyong gawing delulu c James dahil sa kapiranggot na faneys na enabler. He‘ll never succeed kung walang magsasabi sa kanya what‘s lacking. Magsasayang lang sya ng pera.
Delete1:05 Satisfied ka lang sa pagiging chismosa? Yan lang ba ang be-all and end-all ng FP? Hindi naman, di ba?
Delete4:33 I-separate mo yung constructive criticism from atat na bashing. Di ako “faney” ni James. Tao sa tao lang.
di man yan ang be-all at end-all ng FP ay malaking parte yan. kaya kami tambay dito kasi pampaalis namin ng boredom ang pagcomment sa mga tsismis. bago ka lang siguro dito at nag click lang dahil kay james mo
Deletehoy 11:00 Hindi po ito site para purihin ang mga artista or singers na walang kwenta. Yung mga mayayabang na artista binibigyan namin ng Reality Check. Kasi kung minsan sobrang taas ng tingin sa sarili nila kaya inilalagay namin sa lupa ang mga paa. Mayayabang masyado.
DeleteTo be fair to James marunong naman sya gumawa ng kanta. He may not be the best song writer pero yung music nya is pwede na. I think kaunti pang experience, he'll get there. Basta tuloy tuloy lang. Isa pa, he has to market his music to his specific audience kasi obviously it's not for everyone.
ReplyDeleteMukhang hindi rin naman nya talaga type ang acting, so focus na lang sya in honing his musical skills. Not necessarily yung singing part pero yung pagproduce.
ilang taon ng gumagawa ng mga kanta si james, ni isa walang sumikat. Sana magising gising din naman siya sa katotohanan.
DeleteMagaling ba yun? Kapag pinapakinggan ko songs niya parang maliit na boses sa loob ng drum.
ReplyDeleteHahaha same. Parang boses ng bata na hindi makalabas sa loob ng drum.
DeleteJames wala ka naman kasing extraordinary talent or originality. Hwag sisihin ang pagiging artista mo kaya di ka popular in the music scene.. kasi you are basic.
ReplyDeleteMISMO!
DeleteNasal ka, dre. Marunong ka lang sumayaw kaya bumagay sa music mo. Real talk eto.
ReplyDeleteDi sya marunong at magaling sumayaw
DeleteYou either have it or you don't.
ReplyDeleteHe’s a talented musician naman. Some of his songs are very catchy, he just sounds too auto-tuned and the Phils is not the right market for his genre so he will never succeed there as a singer.
ReplyDeleteThere are similar international songs which Filipinos appreciate, but you can hear the difference in voice quality talaga. May gigil at emote kumbaga. Di gaya ng songs nito na boring at parang memakanta lang go na. Walang hugot mapa-happy o sad o angsty. Flat in the sense na walang feels kasi yung kumakanta parang nagpa-practice lang.
DeleteYon kanta nga ni Nadine na paligoy ligoy na nasa baul na, nahalungkat ulit at nag trending pa sa tiktok, bakit kamo kasi relatable. Yumabang na din si James, ayaw na nya balikan yon sisiw days nya, hindi nya na appreciate yon mga kanta nya under viva na sumikat naman sa masa. Actually yon Summer lang talaga na kanta nila ni Nadine ang nasa playlist ko. Atchaka na discover ko din yon music vid colab ni Yasi and Nadine, nagustuhan ko nga bat kaya di sumikat yon, authentic Ppop ang sound nya.
ReplyDeletewalang napasikat na kanta si James under his own management Careless. naging CAREERLESS
DeleteWow, complaining about not being appreciated by the local audience when he doesn't even care to cultivate his fanbase. In fact, nilalayo nga nya ang sarili sa masa dahil sa isip nya he is way too cool for these people. Gusto pala sumikat as musician to , eh dapat noon pa lang na binigyan sya ng opportunity to work in Showtime dapat ginalingan nya at naging professional sya instead na umabsent at magwalwal.
ReplyDeleteNaalala ko pa nagguest sya sa vlog ni Ryan Bang, ang lantoy lantoy nya sumagot, hindi man lang nageelaborate, isang tanong isang sagot lang, mukha talaga sya napilitan magguest. Ngayon ang baksa din pala nya sa youtube, magvlog ng ganap ng CL, na wala naman talagang ganap. Mas marami pa ngan views and subscribers si Ryan Bang kaysa kay James. Dahil yon nageffort matuto magtagalog at talagang mahal nya ang pinas kaya mahal din sya ng madlang pipol.
ReplyDeleteMay advantage pa nga siya na may fanbase na siya bilang artista kumpara sa ibang baguhang musicians na nagsimula sa wala.
ReplyDeleteMediocre talent ka naman sus
ReplyDeleteAnu nga ulit sumikat na kanta nya?
ReplyDeleteSo pinakinggan ko mga songs nya. First, di pang masang pinoy at short din pang international. nothing extra ordinary para mapansin ka internationally. Marami na kapareho sound yung songs mo. Second, weak din marketing mo and connections. Third, maliit boses mo haha.
ReplyDeleteMajority of pinoy hindi type ang music ni james. Iba ang market niya. Pero hindi panget music niya. May vibe ng foreign artist ung music niya. Magugulat ka na lang na siya pala yun. Ma attitude lang talaga. Naalala ko pa nung nag shoot sila ng commercial ni nadine sa manda nag request ng picture yung anak ng friend ko. Inisnob lang nila
ReplyDeleteLahat ng nagcomment dito sinasabi hindi Pinoy ang market niya, so bakit pinipilit ni James at nagagalit pa sa mga pinoys na di siya sumisikat? Eh di doon sa US radios niya ipatugtog mga kanta niya. Yun naman pala market niya.
DeleteSaka napakayabang kasi. He acts as if he is better than everyone in the PH. So ayan, huwag magtaka kung hindi ka rin gusto ng mga pinoys.
ayan kaya hingalo na ang career niyan. Buti nga at wala na si Nadine under their spell at medyo bumabawi na ngayon ang career. This James group is bad news.
DeleteI like James Reid. Enough said.
ReplyDeleteActually it's true, his music is good. But not my genre. Very western ang sound so I get why hindi talaga mabenta sa Pinas.
ReplyDeleteang dami na kasing ganyan. tsaka hindi na rin ganyan ang taste ng karamihan ng Pinoy eh. Kung tatargetin niya Western, bat pa yan pakikinggan dun eh kung mga kamukha nila ginagawa na yan? Pag artist ka, hindi lang music labanan ngayon, pati sarili mo na tlga. kung ang BTS nga, halos same din nung sa 90s pero sikat na sikat sila not only because of music, naging bentahe nila yung mga pa-advocacy nila then fan service pa.
DeleteEveryone can be singer now lalo na sa auto tune na yan. So nagkakatalo na sense lyrics at strategic marketing in which wala ang Careless...
ReplyDeletePuro sila emote , believe sa sarili , walang research data kaya ayan dyan nagagaya si Liza. THEY can do everything. :-)
Disappointed ako pag naglive flat at d makasabay sa auto tune :)
Ang tanging makakapag-judge kung magaling syang musician eh yung mga nakikinig ng mga kanta nya. Sabi nila di daw kasi pang-masa. Sabi ng iba mas pang-international ang market nya. Asan na yang specific market na mga yan? Magparamdam sila. Bat di natin maramdamang nakikinig sila sa music ni James? Pwede nyang i-market ang sarili any way he wants dahil kanya ang management company. Nasa kanya na ang lahat ng resources pero asan ang mga nakikinig? If he's really that good siguro naman may hype ano? Lalo na sa presence ng soc med at bilis ng word of mouth ngayon.
ReplyDeletepara siyang knock off na Justin Beiber kaya hindi sumikat sa Hollywood. Hindi din sumikat sa Pilipinas dahil hindi magets ng mga Pilipino ang genre niya. Sana magising naman sa katotohanan ito at tigilan na ang hollywood dreams.
ReplyDeleteNasa kanya na ang bola, kumbava. Kanya ang Careless. He has the final say sa lahat - songs, creative direction, promotion and marketing. If he's really that good tapos kontrolado pa nya lahat, parang dapat ata by this time inembrace na ng mga tao ang music nya? Kahit sabihin mong di masa, sana may word of mouth man lang mula sa mga taong nakikinig? Besides, andaling magviral ng isang magandang kabta sa soc med these says.
ReplyDeleteEwan ko, may something off sa kanya. I remember he did a collab with JayB of GOT7, pero he did not even follow him sa IG, occasionally he tagged him during the promotions. Medyo off lang. Felt like he used JayB's popularity lang haha.
ReplyDeletecollab kayo ni liza soon! for sure dami manunuod at makikinig!
ReplyDeletekung ready ka for more cringe sige. nakita mo ba ad ni Liza with Maya?
Delete